UNIVERSAL PERIODIC REVIEW OF MICRONESIA

UNIVERSAL PERIODIC REVIEW OF MICRONESIA

By Pooja Reddu

Submission to the Universal Periodic Review of the United Nations Human Rights Council 4th Cycle – 51st Session 

Right to Education

Country Review: Micronesia

Submitting Organization: BROKEN CHALK

 

June 2025

By

 Pooja Reddu

 

 

Submission to the Universal Periodic Review of the United Nations Human Rights Council 4th Cycle – 51st Session

Right to Education

Country Review: Micronesia

Submitting Organization: BROKEN CHALK

 

June 2025

By Pooja Reddu

Broken Chalk is an Amsterdam-based NGO established in 2020 that monitors and minimises worldwide human rights violations in education. We aim to promote universal and equal access to education for all.

We encourage and support achieving societal peace with our international sponsors and partners by advocating for intercultural tolerance, preventing radicalism and polarisation, and tackling educational inequalities.

 

Table of Contents

 

 

  1. Introduction…………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 3

Brief overview of the last UN-UPR cycle……………………………………………………………………………… 4

Challenges……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 5

Access to Education……………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 5

Learning and Skill Gap…………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 6

Financial Constraints………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 7

Language and Cultural Disconnect…………………………………………………………………………………….. 7

Recommendations…………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 8

XI.References……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 9

 

 

I.     Introduction

 

  1. The following report has been drafted by Broken Chalk as a stakeholder in contribution to the fourth cycle of the Universal Periodic Review (UPR) for Micronesia. As Broken Chalk’s focus is to combat human rights violations within the educational sphere, the contents of this report and the following recommendations will focus on the Right to Education.
  2. Micronesia is an amalgamation of around 2000 islands in the Oceania region. It mainly formed of 4 archipelagos, administered by various countries, including USA, Republic of Palau, Republic of Kiribati, Republic of Marshall lands and sovereign islands. Federated States of Micronesia has a status of UN member state attached to it, making it an identity of whole of Micronesia.[i]
  3. Central level is administered by The National Department of Education, dealing with setting national standards for school accreditation. Whereas Regional level by their respective State departments of Education. With respect to Tertiary Education, Congress of FSM holds responsibility in cooperation with the National Department of Education. Division of responsibilities is still a recurring issue. [ii]
  4. 3 Types of schools are present, State-run, Private and Home schooling. State-Run schools have a maximum share of 88%, whereas 12% are non-state educational institutions. Central governments not only fully contribute to State-run schools but also partially funds non-state institutions. [iii]
  5. As per the estimation, Gross Enrolment Ratio at Primary level stands at 96.8%. Similarly 83.3% at Lower Secondary Level, citing measures taken by the government regarding compulsory education for a period of 8 years. Though Early Childhood Education is not included in mandatory schooling. According to estimated data, the number of schools catering to Early Childhood Education is 24, whereas enrolment is only close to 60%.[iv]
  6. This data appears promising, yet hidden stats showcase another side of coin. A significant population of 29.9 percent of females and 28.7 percent of male, over the age of 21 years failed to advance to higher levels of education from Primary levels. [v]
  7. To assimilate the student to the outer world, Primary Level curriculum includes social studies as a major subject. At Intermediate level, 2 types of tracks are available, One for vocational Training and another for general Education. Some privileged students are granted permission to undergo General Education. Students undergoing general education are offered further opportunity to attain Secondary Education. The demand for general education has been more than Vocational Training, thus reducing the importance of vocational education.[vi]
  8. The curriculum adopted at Secondary Level contains advanced topics more closely framed in line with the US education system. High dependance on the US resulted in ignorance of local culture, geography and national aspects. [vii]
  9. Tertiary Level fails to replicate same figures as the Gross Enrolment Ratio of Primary and secondary Level as figures are as low as 14.1%. Attainment of Tertiary Education is dream for many due to lack of institutions at that level as mostly students pursue higher education in foreign locations. Due to the high cost of infrastructure, The FSM spent a share of 12.46 percent of its GDP, while developed countries spent around 4.99 percent of its GDP (UNESCO[viii]).
  10. Micronesia has accomplished the task of achieving gender parity. On Contradictory, share of population with No-schooling contributes to a larger figure of 12.3 percent. Though No-schooling figures have shown improvement from 24.8 percent of population in 1980[ix]. Various policies of no discrimination is in place.[x]

       Brief overview of the last UN-UPR cycle

 

  1. The 3rd cycle of review for Micronesia was conducted in 2020. Out of 154 recommendations, 141 were supported by the country. This marks an increase of 123.80% in comparison to the 2nd cycle. Recommendations largely focused on SDGs under Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions, Gender Equality, Decent work and Economic Growth, Reduced Inequalities, Good Health and Well-being[xi].
  2. According to the National report submitted by the Federation of Micronesia at the 37th session of Working group on the UPR under Human right council, New national and state legislation have been brought up to be in line with the purpose of Human Rights Council. Family protection Law for Kosrae, Domestic Violence Law for Pohnpei, Age of Consent Law, Pohnpei Disabilities Act of 2019 are to name a few. [xii]
  3. As per the recommendations in the field of Human Rights Education and training, the need for including women and children’s aspects in the educational curriculum arises. Also, human rights awareness campaigns for students and for training of teachers should be conducted to ensure students safety and helping them build up healthy relations, thus ensuring gender equity. [xiii]
  4. Regarding overall economic development, national (2004-2023) is ongoing. It focusses on sector wise planning matrices. FSM National Gender policy is chalked out to showcase the commitment for ratified international treaties under Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC), Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), Pacific Leaders Gender Equality Declaration (PLGED). SOPs are provided to health workers to sensitise them towards clinical management of rape and assault. [xiv]
  5. FSM strategic development plan consists of 5 goals for education sector. They target quality education, quality teaching, performance monitoring, data-based decision making, increasing participation and accountability of the education system. Thus ensuring quality education for all. [xv]
  6. FSM has also developed a kindergarten curriculum to increase reading and numeracy ability of young kids. This will strengthen the Early Childhood curriculum for national benchmarks. [xvi]

Challenges

   Access to Education

 

  1. Micronesia (Federated States), politically is divided into 4 states, containing more groups of more than 600 islands. The country covers a wide distance of around 2,600,000 square kilometres. Citing this huge geographic on Pacific Ocean, connectivity and logistic challenges are but so obvious. [xvii]
  2. A few islands are connected through small planes, but most of the islands are connected only through ships. Connectivity has always been a point of concern in Education sector. This can be clearly visible by strength of the students in respective schools. As per the stats, 74 of the schools have less than 100 students and 43 schools have less than 50 students. Remote locations and Outer Islands schools have lesser strength of students. [xviii]
  3. Not only distant location and connectivity is a point of concern, lack of basic amenities are also a hindrance. According to statistics, only 37.6% of the schools have access to electricity. Schools in FSM do not have uniform electrical power and even accessibility from state centres leads to reduced personal development and thus even reducing the ability to provide technical assistance at school’s levels. [xix]
  4. Internet connectivity is even harder to achieve in such a fragmented geography. As per most international standards, Internet connections across the country are extremely slow. Most of the country rely on satellite-based connections, which are proven to be slow and unreliable. FSM’s rate of internet access lags at 35%, being one of slowest rate of access in Pacific Ocean. [xx]
  5. World Bank with funding from Asian Development bank has already been working on the The Pacific Regional Connectivity Project concerning Federated States of Micronesia, to build internet infrastructure over the Pacific Ocean. [xxi]
  6. Higher Education needs a huge improvement. Only one Higher education institute is available in Pohnpei as College of Micronesia. It offers associated degrees and 3-year program in education. University of Guam in Micronesia is for advance degrees. This points out the unavailability of basic institutes for higher education and points out towards inability to multiple to reach out to this distant location of education. [xxii]

 

Learning and Skill Gap

 

  1. According to the figures, school enrolment rate is 73% at elementary levels and drags down to 47% at secondary level. This clearly cites that half of the children are not being enrolled for secondary education. The percentage of children dropping out of the schools is 31%, 18% and 43% at Pre-Primary, Primary and Secondary Level respectively. [xxiii]
  2. There can be ample of reasons for such figures of enrolment and dropout like connectivity, standard of education, incidences of non-communicable disease. Thus posing risk to learning and even hampering lives of the children. In FSM, half of the children population are suffering from obesity during their adolescents. This indicates diets with lower nutritional value, leading to anaemia. [xxiv]
  3. As per World Bank, the learning-adjusted period of education among children in FSM is merely 7.2 years. Whereas the years of actual schooling at primary and secondary level stands at 13 years. This indicates a child is not capable enough to complete 13years of basic schooling of primary and secondary level. This poses risk to child health and survival rate. [xxv]
  4. A huge gap in learning can also be gauge through the parameter of Numeracy ability and Reading ability. As per data by UNICEF, Numeracy ability for Grade 7 stands at 56% and reading ability is lagging at 47% for same grade. At lower grade, this percentage reduced even more. At Grade 5, Numeracy ability stands at 55% and reading ability lags at only 35%.

 

  1. The effect of these stats can be observed in Labour market. Labour force participation rate stands at 57%, where 68% is for males and 46% for females. Similarly Youth employment rate stands at a huge number of 19%, in which 30% and 10% is for female and male youth unemployment rate respectively. This clearly highlights dire need to focus on not only providing education but also ensuring the quality of the education as the required international standards. Otherwise, the country will continue to fall in the trap of vicious cycle of lack of learning ability, leading to unemployment and thus reduced economic growth of the country and increasing inability of the country to provide for education, health, connectivity and infrastructure. [xxvi]

Financial Constraints

 

  1. The Federated States of Micronesia falls under the category of lower middle-income country. 41% of the population in FSM lies under the national poverty line. [xxvii]
  2. This in turns reduces the ability of the state to invest in primary sectors like health and education. When it comes to education sector, it is primarily provided through State compact funds. A certain portion of the fund comes from US, under The U.S. Federal Education program. This amounts to significant portion with respect to overall educational Budget. [xxviii]
  3. Some discrepancies are visible in the approval system for fund allocation. For these programs National Department of Education is considered as the state Education Agency. State Education Agency of multiple countries are in the Board of Directors. But SEA of FSM is not included in Boards of Directors of the pacific Resources for Education and Learning (PREL). This reduces the ability of the country to influence decision in these extremely important projects. [xxix]

 

 

Language and Cultural Disconnect

 

  1. FSM is amalgamation of various groups of islands. Every island resonates with different cultures and different enriching languages. Still, English is unofficially, an official language

of FSM. It is used for all governmental and business purposes among different states of FSM. However, less than 2% of the FSM student uses English as their first language. Most of the students lack English Proficiency. [xxx]

  1. FSM is based on American Education system, where free education is provided till 15 years of age or till the completion of 8th grade. Attendance for high school is not made mandatory. [xxxi]
  2. To assimilate students with English language, every FSM states are tasked with developing curriculum which is equally relevant in both local language and in English. Not only instructional materials are being developed but work on development of grammars and dictionaries are also in progress. But the development is on a slower progress. [xxxii]
  3. Lack of training for teachers and students in English proficiency also raises a concern. More emphasis to a foreign language has undermine the ability of the student to comprehend the curriculum and with lack of sources in local language has made them distant from their own roots spread through cultural stories. This even reduced the desirability in labour force market internationally and nationally. [xxxiii]

 

Recommendations

 

  1. Primary focus for country with such fragmented geography is connectivity. In terms of Physical connectivity through air services, increasing number of commutations sources through ocean. As recommended by Broken Chalk, to increase virtual connectivity Internet Projects conducted by World bank should be aimed to be completed sooner in time. The dependency on satellite communications should be reduced by creating infrastructure for sea cable link systems.
  • amenities like electricity, hygienic facilities for schools as a focus point. To provide for Higher education, a greater number of prestigious institutes needed to build up in all the 4 states of Federated States of Micronesia. This would not only increase strength of students in Higher Education institutions but also increase the accessibility of students of every state.
  1. More allocations of funds need to be done to provide for health especially against non-communicable and preventable diseases. This would increase the learning ability of the students.
  2. More standardisation of the curriculum is needed, emphasising on both local and English language. By giving less emphasis on local language, problem of identity crisis will tend to appear in future. Thus creating a gap between people and their cultural roots. But for uniformity, English language should also be in focus.
  3. Broken chalk also emphasises on increasing participation by NGOs and local communities in assimilating students with educational curriculum, especially concerning English language.
  4. Training opportunity should be provided for both teachers and students in English and local language. To increase school enrolment, more efficient rules regarding mandatory high school education should be in place.
  5. Broken Chalk focuses on increasing number of education institute both at primary, high school and further higher levels of education. This would reduce commuting time and charge and increase enrolment of students at all levels.
  6. Increase in the efficiency of education system, would increase desirability of FSM people in international labour market. Emphasis should be on increasing the avenue of employment at national level. This would increase financial resources of the country.
  • also focus on being the part of Board of Directors at prestigious projects at international levels regarding fund allocation for educational sectors.

 

 

XI.     References

[i] “Wikipedia The Free encyclopaedia- Article on Micronesia” – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Micronesia#Education

[ii] “UNESCO Micronesia, Federated States of Non-state actors in Education 2022” – https://education-profiles.org/oceania/micronesia-federated-states-of/~non-state-actors-in-education

[iii] “UNESCO Micronesia, Federated States of Non-state actors in Education 2022” – https://education-profiles.org/oceania/micronesia-federated-states-of/~non-state-actors-in-education

[iv] “UNESCO Micronesia, Federated States of Non-state actors in Education 2022” – https://education-profiles.org/oceania/micronesia-federated-states-of/~non-state-actors-in-education

[v] “ETH Reserch Collection – Factbook Education system of Micronesia 2022 report” https://www.research-collection.ethz.ch/bitstream/handle/20.500.11850/569623/X_CESFactbookEducationSystems_Micronesia_2022_final.pdf

[vi] “ETH Research Collection – Factbook Education system of Micronesia 2022 report” https://www.research-collection.ethz.ch/bitstream/handle/20.500.11850/569623/X_CESFactbookEducationSystems_Micronesia_2022_final.pdf

[vii] “ETH Research Collection – Factbook Education system of Micronesia 2022 report” https://www.research-collection.ethz.ch/bitstream/handle/20.500.11850/569623/X_CESFactbookEducationSystems_Micronesia_2022_final.pdf

[viii] “ETH Research Collection – Factbook Education system of Micronesia 2022 report” https://www.research-collection.ethz.ch/bitstream/handle/20.500.11850/569623/X_CESFactbookEducationSystems_Micronesia_2022_final.pdf

[ix] “ETH Reserch Collection – Factbook Education system of Micronesia 2022 report” https://www.research-collection.ethz.ch/bitstream/handle/20.500.11850/569623/X_CESFactbookEducationSystems_Micronesia_2022_final.pdf

[x] “UNESCO Micronesia, Federated States of Non-state actors in Education 2022” – https://education-profiles.org/oceania/micronesia-federated-states-of/~non-state-actors-in-education

[xi]“United Nations Human Rights- Office of the High Commissioner 37th Session – FSM” https://www.ohchr.org/sites/default/files/lib-docs/HRBodies/UPR/Documents/Session37/FM/InfographicsMICRONESIA_FEDERATED_STATES_OF.pdf

[xi]

[xii] “Human Rights Council Working Group on the universal periodic review thirty-seventh session 2021 – National Report” https://docs.un.org/en/A/HRC/WG.6/37/FSM/1

[xiii] “Human Rights Council Working Group on the universal periodic review thirty-seventh session 2021 – National Report” https://docs.un.org/en/A/HRC/WG.6/37/FSM/1

[xiv] “Human Rights Council Working Group on the universal periodic review thirty-seventh session 2021 – National Report” https://docs.un.org/en/A/HRC/WG.6/37/FSM/1

[xv] “Universal Periodic Review of the Federated States of Micronesia – 2023 report” file:///C:/Users/HP/Downloads/UNCT%20Pacific%20Region_UPR23_FSM_E_Main.pdf

[xvi]“Universal Periodic Review of the Federated States of Micronesia – 2023 report” file:///C:/Users/HP/Downloads/UNCT%20Pacific%20Region_UPR23_FSM_E_Main.pdf

[xvi]

[xvii] “World Bank- Micro Connections: Connecting the Federated States of micronesia report- June 11, 2018” -https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2018/06/11/micro-connections-connecting-the-federated-states-of-micronesia#:~:text=Yet%20despite%20the%20challenges%2C%20improved,the%20Federated%20States%20of%20Micronesia.

[xviii] “Strategic plan for Improvement of education in the Federated States of Micronesia report” https://www.national.doe.fm/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Strategic-Plan-for-Improvement-of-Education-in-FSM.pdf

[xix] “Strategic plan for Improvement of education in the Federated States of Micronesia report” https://www.national.doe.fm/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Strategic-Plan-for-Improvement-of-Education-in-FSM.pdf

[xix]

[xx] “UNICEF Micronesia Field Office Website” – https://www.unicef.org/pacificislands/micronesia-field-office#:~:text=At%2035%20per%20cent%2C%20FSM%20has%20one,in%20the%20world%20to%20remain%20COVID%2D19%20free.&text=Child%20abuse%2C%20trafficking%2C%20sexual%20exploitation%20of%20girls%2C,exaggerated%20by%20harmful%20social%20norms%20and%20practices

[xxi] “World Bank- Micro Connections: Connecting the Federated States of micronesia report- June 11, 2018” -https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2018/06/11/micro-connections-connecting-the-federated-states-of-micronesia#:~:text=Yet%20despite%20the%20challenges%2C%20improved,the%20Federated%20States%20of%20Micronesia.

[xxii] “Strategic plan for Improvement of education in the Federated States of Micronesia report” https://www.national.doe.fm/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Strategic-Plan-for-Improvement-of-Education-in-FSM.pdf

[xxiii]“UNICEF – The Situation of Children in FSM – Factsheet April 2024 report” https://www.unicef.org/pacificislands/media/5186/file?_gl=1%2A1waa2sd%2A_gcl_au%2ANTI3ODE3NzY0LjE3NDczNjE3MjMuMTA3OTc4NjY2LjE3NDk2ODU2NTEuMTc0OTY4NjYxMg..%2A_ga%2ANDc2OTIwNjE4LjE3Mzk1NzUwOTE.%2A_ga_P0DMSZ8KY6%2AczE3NTA4MjQ4MTYkbzMzMyRnMSR0MTc1MDgyNTQxMCRqNTAkbDAkaDA.%2A_ga_ZEPV2PX419%2AczE3NTA4MjQ4MTYkbzMyOCRnMSR0MTc1MDgyNTQwNyRqNTMkbDAkaDA.

[xxiii]

[xxiv] “UNICEF Micronesia Field Office Website” – https://www.unicef.org/pacificislands/micronesia-field-office#:~:text=At%2035%20per%20cent%2C%20FSM%20has%20one,in%20the%20world%20to%20remain%20COVID%2D19%20free.&text=Child%20abuse%2C%20trafficking%2C%20sexual%20exploitation%20of%20girls%2C,exaggerated%20by%20harmful%20social%20norms%20and%20practices

[xxv] “UNICEF Micronesia Field Office Website” – https://www.unicef.org/pacificislands/micronesia-field-office#:~:text=At%2035%20per%20cent%2C%20FSM%20has%20one,in%20the%20world%20to%20remain%20COVID%2D19%20free.&text=Child%20abuse%2C%20trafficking%2C%20sexual%20exploitation%20of%20girls%2C,exaggerated%20by%20harmful%20social%20norms%20and%20practices

[xxvi]“UNICEF – The Situation of Children in FSM – Factsheet April 2024 report” https://www.unicef.org/pacificislands/media/5186/file?_gl=1%2A1waa2sd%2A_gcl_au%2ANTI3ODE3NzY0LjE3NDczNjE3MjMuMTA3OTc4NjY2LjE3NDk2ODU2NTEuMTc0OTY4NjYxMg..%2A_ga%2ANDc2OTIwNjE4LjE3Mzk1NzUwOTE.%2A_ga_P0DMSZ8KY6%2AczE3NTA4MjQ4MTYkbzMzMyRnMSR0MTc1MDgyNTQxMCRqNTAkbDAkaDA.%2A_ga_ZEPV2PX419%2AczE3NTA4MjQ4MTYkbzMyOCRnMSR0MTc1MDgyNTQwNyRqNTMkbDAkaDA.

[xxvi]

[xxvii] “UNICEF Micronesia Field Office Website” – https://www.unicef.org/pacificislands/micronesia-field-office#:~:text=At%2035%20per%20cent%2C%20FSM%20has%20one,in%20the%20world%20to%20remain%20COVID%2D19%20free.&text=Child%20abuse%2C%20trafficking%2C%20sexual%20exploitation%20of%20girls%2C,exaggerated%20by%20harmful%20social%20norms%20and%20practices

[xxviii] “Strategic plan for Improvement of education in the Federated States of Micronesia report” https://www.national.doe.fm/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Strategic-Plan-for-Improvement-of-Education-in-FSM.pdf

[xxix] “Strategic plan for Improvement of education in the Federated States of Micronesia report” https://www.national.doe.fm/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Strategic-Plan-for-Improvement-of-Education-in-FSM.pdf

[xxx] “Strategic plan for Improvement of education in the Federated States of Micronesia report” https://www.national.doe.fm/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Strategic-Plan-for-Improvement-of-Education-in-FSM.pdf

[xxxi] “Strategic plan for Improvement of education in the Federated States of Micronesia report” https://www.national.doe.fm/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Strategic-Plan-for-Improvement-of-Education-in-FSM.pdf

[xxxii] “Strategic plan for Improvement of education in the Federated States of Micronesia report” https://www.national.doe.fm/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Strategic-Plan-for-Improvement-of-Education-in-FSM.pdf

[xxxiii] “Strategic plan for Improvement of education in the Federated States of Micronesia report” https://www.national.doe.fm/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Strategic-Plan-for-Improvement-of-Education-in-FSM.pdf

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

UNIVERSAL PERIODIC REVIEW OF MAURITANIA

UNIVERSAL PERIODIC REVIEW OF MAURITANIA

By Jonathan Murphy

Broken Chalk has drafted the following report as a stakeholder contribution to the fourth cycle of the Universal Periodic Review [UPR] for Mauritania. As Broken Chalk focuses on combating human rights violations in education, this report and the following recommendations focus on the Right to Education.

Introduction

 

The following report has been drafted by Broken Chalk as a stakeholder contribution to the fifth cycle of the Universal Periodic Review [UPR] for Mauritania. As Broken Chalk’s focus is to combat human rights violations within the educational sphere, the contents of this report and the following recommendations will focus on the Right to Education

The Islamic Republic of Mauritania is located on the northwest coast of Africa, with a population of 3,364,940 and a literacy rate of 51.2%. While the official spoken language of Mauritania is Arabic, other national languages include Pulaar, Soninke, and Wolof. Additionally, French is widely spoken, particularly among those who have pursued higher education. i

Historically, Mauritania maintained two parallel educational systems: one operating exclusively in Arabic and another bilingual system incorporating both Arabic and French. In 1999, a new curriculum was adopted, making Arabic the primary language of instruction, while French is taught as a foreign language. At the secondary level of education, science and mathematics are taught exclusively in French. ii

Mauritania, like many other African countries, is facing a learning crisis. While education is free and compulsory from the ages of 6 to 14, attendance enforcement is lax. This has led to most children completing only 5 years of education iii.

Primary school education begins at 6 years old and lasts for 6 years. Upon completion, students are awarded a Certificat d’Études Fondamentales. Subsequently, students attend Collège or Lower secondary school, which lasts for 3 years, and attain the Brevet d’Études du Premier Cycle (BEPC). Afterwards, students may choose between Lycée technique (a vocational upper secondary school) or Lycée (a general upper secondary school).iv

Vocational upper secondary school lasts for 3 years, with students targeting a certification of Brevet d’Enseignement Professionnel (BEP). Students who have completed at least 2 years of vocational upper secondary school can enter a further 2-year programme leading to the Brevet de Technicien (BT).v

General upper secondary school is also designed as a 3-year course. Upon completing the programme, students must pass the national examination to obtain the Diplôme du Baccalauréat de l’Enseignement du Secondaire.vi

Admission to university-level programmes in Mauritania remains highly competitive, owing to the restricted number of available places. Admission is based on Baccalauréat exam results, with some programmes requiring an additional entrance exam. After two years of study, students receive a Diplôme d’Études Universitaires Générales (DEUG). Students may opt to continue their studies for an additional two years to earn a Maîtrise certification, which is equivalent to a master’s degree. vii

 

Brief overview of the last UN-UPR cycle

The review of Mauritania was held at the 3rd meeting, on 19 January 2021, resulting in 266 recommendations having been made, with 201 of those recommendations supported by the Mauritanian government. Of those supported recommendations, eight were explicitly aimed at enhancing access to education, while an additional 30 recommendations concerned broader educational objectives.

Broken Chalk notes that all the education recommendations were supported. The Mauritanian government has focused its attention on broadening girls’ access to education, providing safer and more hygienic WASH facilities, and expanding access to students in poverty and those in rural areas.

These developments have been facilitated by Mauritania’s commitment to enacting the recommendations through domestic legislation. The Global Partnership has noted that access to education has improved with the construction of over 390 new, fully equipped classrooms to meet demandviii. Other measures include government policies that have established compulsory and free education for children from the ages of 6 to 15ix. Furthermore, while independent monitoring remains limited, the government has reported progress through initiatives such as expanding rural school access, increasing education funding, and providing conditional cash transfers to encourage girls’ enrolmentx.

 

Learning Poverty within the Mauritanian Education System

Firstly, as in many sub-Saharan countries, learning poverty remains a significant challenge. Learning poverty can be described as the inability to read and understand a simple text by the age of 10 xi. Even when compared to states with similar regional and developmental profiles, Mauritania’s education system struggles to meet expected standards, with test results for 4th-grade students in French alarmingly low. At the same time, Arabic and mathematics also show significant deficiencies xii. In a 2017 report, the World Bank noted that ”only a quarter of grade 6 students scored above 50 per cent on the end-of-primary-school national exam, while only 1.7 per cent of grade 4 students in public schools could read a simple eight-word sentence in French, and about 37 per cent could not add two single-digit numbers” xiii.

These figures are stark given that comparable neighbouring states’ literacy rates are almost 10 times higher than those in Mauritania. Senegal, for example, showed that French proficiency among students of the exact age had attained 15% proficiency in French and 35% according to a 2021 Monitoring Impacts on Learning Outcomes (MILO) study xiv.

The reasons for the ongoing learning poverty in Mauritania are multitudinous. Evidence suggests that a leading factor is the pedological (mis)management of schools. According to the UNESCO report on Mauritanian education, the average attainment level gained by students varied considerably within the same regions from one school to another, even when all other factors, such as gender and poverty, are consideredxv. This suggests an ongoing struggle to set and maintain widely adopted educational standards.

Compounding the lack of a structured pedological framework is the lack of quality teachers. A 2018 assessment of education service delivery in Mauritania found that no teacher met the required competency standards to teach French or Arabic, and only 3.6% of public-school teachers possessed the minimum skills necessary to teach mathematicsxvi. While teacher training programmes have since been implemented to improve the standard of education in the country, there appears to be a startling lack of competency from those in the education sector. Additionally, teacher absenteeism is extraordinarily high. The UNESCO report indicates that almost one-quarter of teachers were absent from schools during unannounced visitsxvii.

The combination of these factors has left the vast majority of Mauritanian students facing overwhelming challenges in their search to secure a quality education. The uncoordinated nature and implementation of the education they receive means that they initially require luck to attend one of the few effective schools in the country. Thereafter, students may face undertrained teachers who lack the required knowledge or skills to ensure proficiency in core subjects effectively.

Widespread Enrolment and Retention Gaps Across All Education Levels

The second major challenge confronting the Mauritanian education system is persistent low enrolment across all age groups, despite notable efforts by the government and its partners to improve access and coverage.

Mauritania has failed to meet its target for preschool enrolment. With current coverage reaching only 9%—well below the 16% target—Mauritania continues to have one of the lowest rates of pre-school enrolment in West and Central Africa xviii. Furthermore, the vast majority of students who attend pre-school education do so through private schools, with only 5% attending those provided by the state. This represents an education equity risk, as students from poorer backgrounds or less populous areas are unlikely to benefit from these institutions.

This is a significant challenge as disparities in educational outcomes emerge early in childhood. Once these gaps are in place, they tend to limit a child’s chances of upward mobility. Early differences in learning and development often shape key aspects of a child’s experience, such as their relationships with teachers and peers, the type of curriculum they are enrolled in, and the support they receive at home. Over time, these factors reinforce initial disadvantages, making them more challenging to overcome. As such, early childhood represents a critical period for addressing long-term educational inequality xix.

Likewise, despite commendable efforts by the Mauritanian government, primary school enrolments have failed to meet targets. Although the Gross Enrolment Rate in primary education has exceeded 100 per cent over the past decade, the Net Enrolment Rate for children aged 6 to 11 has remained below 75 per cent, significantly lower than the averages for both Sub-Saharan Africa and the Arab states xx.

The gap between gross and net enrolment suggests that many children in Mauritania either start school late, repeat grades, or drop out early. Although primary education is officially free and compulsory, this guarantee is not effectively upheld. As of 2019, an estimated 210,000 children aged 6 to 11 were not enrolled in any form of schooling, representing almost 40% of the age group. Among those who do enrol, only 68% complete primary education, and fewer than half do so without repeating a year. Dropout rates are particularly concentrated between Grades 4 and 6, reflecting structural inefficiencies and weak retention. These trends are exacerbated by the fact that only 40% of the country’s 3,500 schools allow students to complete the full cycle of basic education, limiting access in remote or under-resourced areas xxi.

Enrolment in secondary education in Mauritania remains extremely limited. According to the 2024 Education Sector Analysis, the gross enrolment rate (GER) in lower secondary education stands at just under 50%, while the GER in upper secondary education is only 30% xxii. These figures reflect a steep drop-off after the completion of primary school, with the transition to secondary education described in the report as a “bottleneck.” Only 63% of students who complete basic education proceed to lower secondary school, and even fewer advance to upper secondary education xxiii. Structural limitations—including insufficient school capacity, geographic barriers, and resource constraints—contribute to widespread exclusion from the upper levels of the education system. Despite small annual increases in enrolment, progress remains too slow to achieve universal secondary access.

Mauritania lags significantly behind its regional peers in tertiary education, with a gross enrolment rate of just 5.8%, among the lowest in West and Central Africa xxiv. In 2019, the gross enrolment rate for higher education was estimated at 5.8%, compared to an average of over 30% across Sub-Saharan Africa xxv. University admission is primarily restricted to students who pass the Diplôme du Baccalauréat; yet, the proportion of students achieving this qualification remains critically low. The system’s limited intake capacity and weak secondary completion rates mean that only a small elite can access higher education. While the government has committed to expanding tertiary institutions and diversifying programme offerings, access remains highly restricted, and enrolment growth has not kept pace with rising demand. Without a significant investment in secondary school completion and university preparation, higher education will remain inaccessible to the vast majority of Mauritanian youth.

Disruption of Education Due to Climate Shocks

Finally, the ongoing climate crisis has already begun to affect the education system in Mauritania critically. This is particularly true of rural and marginalised communities who are facing growing food insecurity due to droughts, floods, and other destabilising elements brought about by climate change. Between 1993 and 2022, Mauritania was ranked among the twenty countries most affected by climate-related disasters worldwide, when adjusted for its level of human development. The country faces increasingly severe environmental shocks as the climate crisis worsens. These events are especially disruptive for rural and marginalised communities, where weak infrastructure, food insecurity, and displacement already limit access to education. The frequency and intensity of these climate impacts have increased significantly in recent years, placing additional strain on schools, families, and public services that lack the capacity or resources to respond effectively xxvi.

Climate-related shocks increasingly disrupt Mauritania’s education system. According to UNESCO’s 2024 Education Sector Analysis, prolonged droughts, flash floods, and advancing desertification particularly affect rural wilayas—Guidimakha, Gorgol, Assaba, Hodh El Chargui, and Hodh El Gharbi—where educational indicators such as enrollment, retention, and completion are already significantly below national norms xxvii. These same regions, repeatedly hit by food insecurity and seasonal displacement, experience acute climate vulnerability that undermines schooling.

Despite the scale of these risks, the education sector in Mauritania lacks a clear strategy for climate adaptation. There is currently no national framework in place to ensure continuity of schooling during climate-related emergencies, nor is there formal guidance for schools or teachers on how to respond to disruptions caused by floods, droughts, or displacement xxviii. According to the 2024 Education Sector Analysis, data on climate-related school closures, infrastructure damage, or student displacement are not systematically collected or incorporated into national education planningxxix. This absence of climate-responsive policy leaves schools in high-risk areas without the support or tools needed to protect learners’ right to education during and after environmental shocks. Repeated cycles of disruption deepen exclusion for children already marginalised by geography, poverty, or gender, as confirmed in recent UNICEF emergency reporting xxx.

The Consequences of this policy gap are increasingly visible. When flooding damages schools or drought drives seasonal displacement, children often miss weeks or months of class. This phenomenon is particularly prevalent for students in poor and rural areas. Many children are unable to return. Climate shocks also intensify existing gendered risks: during crises, girls are more likely to be withdrawn from school to support household labour or are pushed into early marriage, both of which are particularly prevalent in Mauritania. xxxi. The absence of school continuity measures, catch-up programming, or flexible enrollment policies means that these disruptions frequently become permanent. In a system already marked by high dropout and low retention rates, climate-driven shocks are exacerbating exclusion for those least able to recover from interrupted schooling.

The failure to address these foreseeable risks reflects a broader gap in the state’s responsibility to protect the right to education. Under international law—including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights, and the Convention on the Rights of the Child—Mauritania is obligated to ensure continuous and equitable access to education, even in the face of climate-related shocks xxxii. As these environmental threats become more frequent and more severe, the urgency to build climate resilience into education planning cannot be overstated. This includes anticipating disruption, protecting displaced learners, and maintaining access through appropriate institutional and infrastructural responses. Without such measures, the right to education for many of Mauritania’s most vulnerable children remains unrealised.

Recommendations

In light of the persistent and emerging challenges described above, Broken Chalk offers the following recommendations to strengthen the realisation of the right to education in Mauritania.

  1. Broken Chalk urges the Government of Mauritania to develop and enforce national minimum standards for pedagogical practice, learning assessment, and curriculum delivery to ensure a coherent and equitable education experience across schools.
  2. Broken Chalk recommends increased investment in evidence-based teacher training programmes, with particular emphasis on subject-matter proficiency in Arabic, French, and mathematics.
  3. Broken Chalk encourages the establishment of an independent, transparent system to monitor teacher attendance and classroom performance, with remedial support provided where deficiencies are identified.
  4. Broken Chalk urges the Government of Mauritania to accelerate efforts to meet preschool enrolment targets by expanding public early childhood education, especially in rural and low-income areas.
  5. Broken Chalk recommends targeted interventions to reduce dropout rates between Grades 4 and 6, including school feeding programmes, family incentives, and expanded WASH facilities.
  6. Broken Chalk encourages the state to expand the number of schools offering complete primary cycles, particularly in underserved regions, to reduce structural barriers to completion.
  7. Broken Chalk recommends the expansion of secondary school infrastructure and the provision of transportation subsidies for students in remote areas to improve transition and retention.
  8. Broken Chalk recommends that the Government of Mauritania expand higher education opportunities by diversifying programme offerings, increasing institutional capacity, and investing in preparatory support for secondary students.
  9. Broken Chalk encourages the creation of targeted scholarship schemes and university bridging programmes to support access for students from marginalised communities.
  10. Broken Chalk urges the Government of Mauritania to develop and implement a national strategy for climate-resilient education, including infrastructure standards, school continuity plans, and teacher training in emergency response.
  11. Broken Chalk recommends the systematic collection of data on climate-related school closures, damage, and displacement, and its integration into education sector planning and emergency preparedness.
  12. Broken Chalk urges the Government to establish mobile or flexible education models to ensure continuity of learning for children affected by seasonal displacement, drought, or flooding.
  13. Broken Chalk recommends expanding school-based support services for girls at risk of early marriage or pregnancy during climate crises, including re-entry pathways and catch-up programmes.

 

References

References
i AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
ii AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
iii AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
iv AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
v AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
vi AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
vii AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
viii GPE Secretariat and World Bank, “Mauritania: Improving Primary Education and School Management | Global
Partnership for Education,” Global Partnership for Education, 2025, https://www.globalpartnership.org/blog/mauritaniaimproving-primary-education-and-school-management.
ix UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
x
Islamic Republic of Mauritania, National Report Submitted in Accordance with Paragraph 5 of the Annex to Human Rights
Council Resolution 16/21: Mauritania, A/HRC/WG.6/37/MRT/1 (Geneva: United Nations Human Rights Council, 2021),
https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G20/361/26/PDF/G2036126.pdf.
xi World Bank Group, “What Is Learning Poverty?“ Oclc.org, April 28, 2021, https://www-worldbank-org.vunl.idm.oclc.org/en/topic/education/brief/what-is-learning-poverty.
xii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xiii World Bank Group, Mauritania Country Economic Memorandum: Accelerating Growth through Diversification and
Productive Cities (Washington, DC: World Bank, 2020),
https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/652481590432527403/pdf/Mauritania-Country-Economic-MemorandumAccelerating-Growth-Through-Diversification-and-Productive-Cities.pdf.
xiv UNESCO Global Education Monitoring Report Team, “Spotlight on Basic Education Completion and Foundational Learning
in Senegal: Spotlight Advocacy Brief ,” UNESCO IIEP (UNESCO.org, 2023), https://www.unesco.org/gemreport/sites/default/files/medias/fichiers/2023/05/Spotlight_Advocacy_Senegal_EN.pdf.
xv UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xvi GPE Secretariat and World Bank, “Mauritania: Improving Primary Education and School Management | Global
Partnership for Education,” Global Partnership for Education, 2025, https://www.globalpartnership.org/blog/mauritaniaimproving-primary-education-and-school-management.
xvii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xviii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xix Arya Ansari, “The Persistence of Preschool Effects from Early Childhood through Adolescence.,” Journal of Educational
Psychology 110, no. 7 (October 2018): 952–73, https://doi.org/10.1037/edu0000255.
xx World Bank Group, “MAURITANIA Country Economic Memorandum: Accelerating Growth through Diversification and
Productive Cities,” Worldbank.org, 2020,
https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/652481590432527403/pdf/Mauritania-Country-Economic-MemorandumAccelerating-Growth-Through-Diversification-and-Productive-Cities.pdf.
xxi UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xxii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xxiii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xxiv Wachira Kigotho , “Small Island States Lead the Way in Tertiary Enrolments,” University World News, February 4, 2021,
https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=20210203120517283.
xxv Wachira Kigotho , “Small Island States Lead the Way in Tertiary Enrolments,” University World News, February 4, 2021,
https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=20210203120517283.
xxvi Lina Adil et al., “Climate Risk Index 2025” (GermanWatch, February 12, 2025).
xxvii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xxviii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xxix UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xxx UNICEF, “Mauritania Consolidated Emergency Report 2021,” UNICEF, March 22, 2022,
https://open.unicef.org/sites/transparency/files/2022-04/Mauritania%20CER%202021.pdf.
xxxi UNICEF EDUCATION, “Reimagine Education Case Study,” Unicef, December 23, 2021,
https://www.unicef.org/media/113696/file/Mauritania%E2%80%99s%20first%20digital%20learning%20program:%20Akeliu
s%20Digital%20French%20Course%20(Mauritania).pdf.
xxxii Olivia Gratton and Fiona Chiu, “How Climate Change Is Affecting the Right to Education,” Australian Institute of
International Affairs, June 27, 2022, https://www.internationalaffairs.org.au/australianoutlook/how-climate-change-isaffecting-the-right-to-educat

 

 

Educational Challenges in Dominica

Educational Challenges in Dominica

Written By Anis Mami 

 

Educational Challenges in Dominica

Portsmouth, Saint John Parish, Dominica. Credit: Pexels, Hiwa Ali.

Educational Challenges in Dominica:

A Small Island’s Educational Heritage

Dominica, also known as the Commonwealth of Dominica, is a mountainous Caribbean island with a population of just over 70,000, situated between Guadeloupe and Martinique, and is often confused with the Dominican Republic due to the similarity in their names. Formerly colonized by France and Great Britain, Dominica gained its independence in 1978. However, the education system still bears witness to this colonial heritage, as schools follow a structure modelled on the British system (with “forms” for secondary levels) combined with North American-style grade nomenclature (CountryStudies.us, n.d.; Education State University, n.d.-a).

As such, Englishis the official language of instruction, but the heritage of early French missionary schools lives on in local culture and language (CountryStudies.us, n.d.). Indeed, churches – particularly Roman Catholic and Methodist – had a pioneering role to play by initiating Dominica’s first formal schools during the 1800s (CountryStudies.us, n.d.). Nevertheless, the rough terrain of the island has historically limited access to education beyond the capital city. In fact, due to poor roads and schools being centralised in Roseau, only a few rural children attended secondary school before the 1960s (CountryStudies.us, n.d.).

Over the years, Dominica has succeeded in introducing free universal education for children aged 5 to 16, as enshrined in the Education Act of 1997, thereby establishing a solid legal framework for the education system (EPDC, 2018). Nevertheless, today, these foundations are being overshadowed by a series of shortcomings in the education system, which this article aims to outline.

Digital Divide and the Impact of COVID-19

Low levels of technology integration in schools were already a pressing issue in Dominica before 2020, but the COVID-19 pandemic starkly highlighted this digital divide. As a small island developing state, Dominica has an economy centred on tourism and agriculture, sectors that have not historically required high levels of technological capability, especially in education. The country therefore laggedbehind in terms of education technology infrastructure: numerous towns lacked stable internet access, and not all students or teachers possessed devices or the training to use them (UNESCO, 2021; Knight et al., 2021). When the pandemic finally forced schools to switch online, Dominica had neither the resources nor the capacity to make a complete shift to virtual classes nationwide (UNESCO, 2021; Dominica News Online, 2021). As a result, over12,300 learners and 1,178 educators suffered from pandemic school closures, yet they were unable to adequately participate in online learning due to unequal access to digital resources, poor internet connectivity, and a lack of readiness for online instruction (Knight et al., 2021). These disparities caused an enormous loss of instructional time during lockdowns.

The Ministry of Education attempted stopgap solutions. In 2021, Education Minister Octavia Alfred announced plans for “direct engagement” with students who had no internet access, providing worksheets and activity cards with explanatory notes and instructions. Students with internet access continued learning online, while those without access could collect or receive printed assignments and return their completed work for feedback (Dominica News Online, 2021). [ revised by Panashe Mlambo ] Educators also highlighted the wider digital challenges: Wanitta Eli, a primary and college teacher, said that most students lacked fundamental digital skills and training, and teachers also lacked the time and facilities to transfer these skills (UNESCO, 2021).

The government of Dominica and regional allies understand the imperative of bridging this digital divide. The Organisation of Eastern Caribbean States (OECS) identified technology in education as a priority area in a 2022 regional education roundtable (OECS, 2022). The country’s new Partnership Compact 2024 also underscores this commitment: it calls for integrating technology into the curriculum as part of developing a more resilient and relevant education system (Government of the Commonwealth of Dominica, 2024).

Inclusion of Special Needs Children

Access to education for children with disabilities has been limited in the past, yet there has been evidence of gradual improvement (World Bank, 2023). Dominica ratified the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) in 2012 and committed to offering inclusive education (World Bank, 2023). Domestic law is catching up: Special educational needs are not defined as such in the Education Act 1997; however, the Act does provide certain guarantees that plans for compulsory education shall be adjusted for pupils with “intellectual, communicative, behavioural, physical or multiple exceptionalities” (World Bank, 2023).

In practice, however, education for everybody remains a work in progress. There are few facilities accommodating children with special needs, and integration into mainstream schools is still low (UNICEF, 2017a). The Achievement Learning Centre (ALC), established in 2011, is one of the key centres – a legally recognised school that provides adapted learning and vocational training for disabled children (CPDC, n.d.). The ALC was founded specifically to fill the “lack of access to special education services for children whose needs were not met in the mainstream system” and stands as a milestone toward inclusion (CPDC, n.d.). Another long-standing institution is the Alpha Centre in Goodwill, which, since 1974, has educated children with moderate to severe developmental disabilities (Government Information Service, n.d.). Alpha Centre began as a Catholic mission project and later became an independent school, sustained over the years by charitable donations and government subventions. These two centres, along with the smaller Isulukati Special Education School in the Kalinago Territory, are the main avenues for special-needs education on the island (Dominica News Online, 2017).

In spite of these initiatives, there are few trained special education teachers, and regular teachers lack the training or resources to accommodate students with disabilities in regular classrooms (EPDC, 2018). Education specialists point to an “inadequate number of teachers trained in special education” as well as slow integration of special-needs children in regular classroom environments, keeping many such children out of mainstream learning classes (Knight et al., 2021). Economic deprivation compounds the issue: families of children with disabilities often lack transport and struggle with medical costs, and during disasters (such as hurricanes and floods), these children are among the most affected (UNICEF, 2017b).

A 2023 investigative article reported that since Tropical Storm Erika in 2015 and Hurricane Maria in 2017, children with disabilities in Dominica “suffered and were further marginalised” – damaged special schools and disrupted transport left them with even fewer chances of education and support (Ferrol, 2023). In fact, the Isulukati School in the Kalinago Territory is still trying to recover years after Maria’s devastation, which is hampering educational progress among the indigenous children it serves (Ferrol, 2023).

Strains on the Teaching Profession

Dominica’s teachers are the backbone of its education system, yet the teaching profession faces multiple challenges – from low pay and limited training opportunities to a persistent gender imbalance. It is widely recognized that teacher quality needs strengthening. As far back as the early 2000s, analyses noted that although the government created a Teacher Training College and occasionally organised short-term training projects, “the majorityof teachers are not certified” in Dominica (Education State University, n.d.-b). Many entered classrooms with only an associate degree or high school diploma and minimal formal pedagogical training. Professional development was limited, especially at the secondary level, where there was no policy for continuing training (Education State University, n.d.-b). Turnover is another symptom of the disease: untrained, fill-in teachers often leave the profession at high rates, leading to a revolving door of instructors in schools. This instability undermines teaching quality and student success (Education State University, n.d.-b).

Salary is one key issue. Starting salaries for teachers in Dominica are relatively low, and it is challenging to attract and retain top-class professionals in the teaching profession. Better-paying jobs in the private sector or abroad attract many of the brightest graduates who could otherwise have pursued teaching (Knight et al., 2021). This leaves staffing gaps, as some subject areas (especially science and technology) struggle to find qualified teachers. This issue was underscored in the OECS Education Strategy 2012–2026, and recent reports have urged Dominica’s government to raise teacher salaries and incentives to render the work more appealing (OECS, 2022; Knight et al., 2021). Beyond salaries, there have been calls to raise entry standards – for example, to require all new teachers to have at least a bachelor’s degree – and to introduce formal mentorship programmes for new teachers. These measures aim to professionalise teaching and ensure educators are well prepared (Knight et al., 2021).

The second issue is the gender imbalance among teachers. Teaching in Dominica (and most Caribbean countries) is a female-dominated profession, especially at the primary level. Only 20% of primary teachers are men, and that is a statistic that education officials find alarming (Knight et al., 2021). With too few male teachers, young boys do not have male role models to look up to within the classroom, something some research suggests affects boys’ engagement and achievement. In order to address this, the KIX Dominica country review advocated for “a recruitment drive to attract male teachers and break the perception that teaching is a feminized profession” (Knight et al., 2021).

Furthermore, there are even fewer teachers with specialised skills, e.g., special education teachers for disabled children. Since there are only a few such experts in the entire country, mainstream teachers typically find it challenging to mainstream students who need additional support (Knight et al., 2021). The government has acknowledged such gaps and, in recent years, has resorted to outside support to upskill its teachers. For example, with a 2014 Global Partnership for Education grant, Dominica implemented programmes to enhance teaching practices, school leadership, and monitoring and evaluation in schools (Global Partnership for Education, n.d.). This helped improve quality, but the scale of need remains significant.

Encouragingly, the Dominica Partnership Compact 2024 recognizes teacher training as a building block to education reform.Although not explicitly about salaries, the Compact’s reform agenda – creating an inclusive and equitable curriculum that integrates technology, life skills, and resilience – implicitly requires well-trained, motivated teachers to carry it out (Government of the Commonwealth of Dominica, 2024). Thus, the government is committing to sustained investment in teacher preparation and ongoing training. As Dominica aims to enhance learning outcomes, prioritising the status of and support for the teaching profession will be paramount. Higher standards for new teachers, continuous professional development (specifically in technology and special-needs instruction), and targeted recruitment of under-represented groups (e.g., male teachers) are among the actions being pursued. By empowering teachers, it is hoped that the system will deliver better education for everyone.

Child-Centred Disaster Risk Education

Dominica’s education system has been repeatedly affected by natural hazards in the past decade, and, in response, the country has embraced child-led disaster risk reduction (DRR) in schools (Parham, 2022). In August 2015, Tropical Storm Erika caused devastating floods and landslides, and just two years later, in September 2017, Hurricane Maria devastated the island with winds of 160 mph (NPR, 2023). Maria in particular was a cataclysm for education: roughly 90% of Dominica’s buildings were damaged or destroyed, with schools among those affected (UNICEF, 2017b). [ revised by Panashe Mlambo ] Thousands of children saw their schools closed for months. This one-two punch of disasters between 2015 and 2017 made Dominica a case study in why climate resilience in the education sector is imperative.

In response, Dominica joined regional efforts under the Comprehensive School Safety Framework (CSSF), which was adopted across the Caribbean in 2015 to protect education from hazards (Parham, 2022). After Maria, the government launched national initiatives dubbed “Safer Schools” and “Smart Schools” to “build back better” in the education system (Parham, 2022). These programmes, funded by UNICEF and other international partners, aimed both to rebuild infrastructure to more resilient standards and to integrate disaster preparedness into everyday schooling (UNICEF, 2017b). By 2018, Dominica had established a climate resilience curriculum programme that included nationwide teacher training in disaster risk management and the development of school disaster response plans (Parham, 2022). This child-oriented DRR approach empowers students with information on hurricanes, floods, earthquakes, and climate change in an effort to make them less vulnerable and their communities more resilient. It also recognizes children as agents of change: students who learn can help disseminate disaster preparedness messages to their families and communities (Parham, 2022).

However, the DRR work of the government was plagued by security concerns and constraints. The COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 forced schools to focus on distance learning and the recovery of foundational learning, moving away from disaster preparedness curricula and reducing the window of implementation (Parham, 2022). Further, limited teacher knowledge of specialised DRR content has been a problem. Some educators did not have a background in climate science or risk reduction pedagogy to start with, and training and support must be ongoing if momentum is to be maintained (Parham, 2022). As a 2022 paper in the journal Disasters noted, Dominica’s DRR education efforts had “limited successes” in the short term, and sustainability in the long term will require institutionalising the programmes and addressing remaining knowledge gaps (Parham, 2022).

The push for green, resilient schools is now integrated into Dominica’s broader vision of becoming the world’s “first climate-resilient nation” (Parham, 2022; Government of the Commonwealth of Dominica, 2024). In educational terms, this involves not only rebuilding structures to be more resilient but also building resilience into curricula. The 2024 Partnership Compact enshrines this by making “resilience education” an explicit pillar of the new curriculum. The Compact’s programmes encourage the integration of environmental stewardship, climate adaptation, and emergency response into the teaching of essential life skills to students (Government of the Commonwealth of Dominica, 2024). Disaster preparedness is thus made a permanent part of Dominican education. With climate models predicting worse storms as the new norm for the Eastern Caribbean (NPR, 2023), Dominica’s experience underscores the critical role of education in protecting children and their future. By raising a generation of citizens who are climate-aware and disaster-ready, the country is turning Erika and Maria’s lessons into a blueprint for resilience.

Conclusion

Dominica’s education system stands at a crossroads of challenge and opportunity. Its unique history – from colonial-era church schools to post-independence expansion – has built a foundation of strong social value for education but also left disparities that modern policies must address (CountryStudies.us, n.d.; Education State University, n.d.-b). The digital divide, laid bare by COVID-19, highlighted the need for urgent investment in technology and infrastructure so that every child can benefit from digital learning (Dominica News Online, 2021; UNESCO, 2021). The slow but steady progress in inclusive education for children with disabilities and the indigenous Kalinago community shows that commitment and community efforts can broaden access, yet more trained specialists and resources are needed to truly leave no child behind (CPDC, n.d.; Government Information Service, n.d.). The teaching workforce, underpaid and under-supported, requires continuous development and greater incentives to deliver quality instruction and mentor the next generation (Knight et al., 2021; Education State University, n.d.-b). As the climate crisis intensifies, integrating disaster risk education has proven vital for safeguarding students and schools against future shocks (Parham, 2022; Government of the Commonwealth of Dominica, 2024).

These challenges are complex and interlinked, but Dominica is not navigating them alone. The government, in partnership with regional bodies and global organizations, has charted a path forward through frameworks like the OECS Education Sector Strategy and the new Dominica Partnership Compact (OECS, 2022; Government of the Commonwealth of Dominica, 2024). Notably, the 2024 Partnership Compact encapsulates a vision for a more inclusive, technologically adept, and resilient education system. It prioritises curriculum reform that integrates digital skills, technical/vocational training, life skills, and climate resilience, and caters to all learners – from the most privileged to the most vulnerable (Government of the Commonwealth of Dominica, 2024). This reflects a formal acknowledgment of the very issues discussed: the need to prepare students for a changing world, whether that means a digital economy or a hurricane-prone environment.

Despite repeated natural disasters and economic challenges, Dominica has consistently demonstrated a strong commitment to ensuring access to education for all children, as emphasized in national reports and international development partnerships (UNICEF, 2017a; Parham, 2022). Indeed, over the past decade, Dominica has weathered hurricanes, a pandemic, and economic strains, yet schools have reopened, curricula have evolved, and students continue to strive (Parham, 2022; NPR, 2023; Knight et al., 2021). The road ahead requires converting plans into sustained action – ensuring that every school has internet and power, every classroom can accommodate children with different needs, every teacher is equipped and valued, and every child knows how to stay safe and keep learning when disaster strikes (Dominica News Online, 2021; Global Partnership for Education, n.d.). The tone from the top is hopeful and determined. As one Dominican student optimistically said amid the wreckage of Hurricane Maria, “we rebuild… we can do it again; rebuild stronger” (UNICEF, 2017b). The same spirit applies to education: the aim is not just to regain what was lost, but to “build back better” (Parham, 2022).

References

CountryStudies.us. (n.d.). Education. Retrieved from https://countrystudies.us/caribbean-islands/62.htm

CPDC. (n.d.). Achievement Learning Centre – Dominica. Caribbean Policy Development Centre. Retrieved from https://cpdcngo.org/ngo-resource-hub/ngo-country-overview/achievement-learning-centre-dominica

Dominica News Online. (2017). Chief highlights education achievements of Kalinago territory. Retrieved from https://dominicanewsonline.com/news/homepage/news/general/chief-highlights-education-achievements-of-kalinago-territory/

Dominica News Online. (2021). Ministry of Education to directly engage students with no internet access this academic year. Retrieved from https://dominicanewsonline.com/news/homepage/news/ministry-of-education-to-directly-engage-students-with-no-internet-access-this-academic-year/

Education State University. (n.d.-a). Dominica – Educational System Overview. Retrieved from https://education.stateuniversity.com/pages/378/Dominica-EDUCATIONAL-SYSTEM-OVERVIEW.html

Education State University. (n.d.-b). Dominica – Summary: Education, teachers, development, and… Retrieved from. https://education.stateuniversity.com/pages/384/Dominica-SUMMARY.html

EPDC. (2018). Dominica: National Education Profile. Education Policy and Data Center. Retrieved from https://www.epdc.org/sites/default/files/documents/EPDC_NEP_2018_Dominica.pdf

Ferrol, Richie. (2023)“The Impact Of Climate Change On Children With Disabilities – Climate Tracker”. Climate Tracker, Retrieved from. https://climatetrackercaribbean.org/climate-justice/the-impact-of-climate-change-on-children-with-disabilities/

Global Partnership for Education. (n.d.). Education in Dominica. Retrieved from https://www.globalpartnership.org/where-we-work/dominica

Government of the Commonwealth of Dominica. (2024). Dominica Partnership Compact 2024. Ministry of Finance, Economic Development, Climate Resilience and Social Security. https://www.globalpartnership.org/content/dominica-partnership-compact-2024

Government Information Service. (2014). President visits schools within the Kalinago territory. Retrieved from https://news.gov.dm/news/news-items/president-visits-schools-within-the-kalinago-territory

Government Information Service. (n.d.). Donations from Charity Organizations keep Alpha Centre afloat. Retrieved from https://news.gov.dm/news/news-items/donations-from-charity-organizations-keep-alpha-centre-afloat

Knight, V., Marshall, J., Depradine, K., & Moody-Marshall, R. (2021). Country review. Challenges and opportunities in the education system of Dominica. Serie Working Papers SUMMA. N° 9. Published by SUMMA. Santiago de Chile. Retrieved from. https://summaedu.org/recurso/investigacion/challenges-and-opportunities-in-the-education-system-of-dominica/

NPR. (2023). Hurricane Maria was a once-in-a-lifetime storm for Dominica. It might be the norm. Retrieved from https://www.npr.org/2023/06/14/1180477017/dominica-recovers-hurricane-maria-2017

OECS. (2022). OECS Declaration on Education Statement (Academic Recovery Programme Phase II No. 6). https://doi.org/10.53832/opendeved.0261

Parham, M. (2022). Returning to normal? ‘Building back better’ in the Dominican education system after Tropical Storm Erika and Hurricane Maria. Disasters, 46(S1), S128–S150. Retrieved from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/disa.12536

UNESCO. (2000). EFA 2000 country report: The Commonwealth of Dominica. UNESCO. Retrieved from https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000219392

UNESCO. (2021). Digital Empowerment for Distance Education – Teacher Story from Dominica. Retrieved from https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/digital-empowerment-distance-education-teacher-story-dominica

UNICEF. (2017a). Situation Analysis of Children: Commonwealth of Dominica. Retrieved from https://www.unicef.org/easterncaribbean/media/891/file/Situation-Analysis-of-Children-2017.pdf

UNICEF. (2017b). Hurricane Maria aftermath: Children’s education on hold in Dominica. UNICEF Stories. Retrieved from https://www.unicef.org/stories/hurricane-maria-aftermath-dominica

The Borgen Project. (2017). Education in Dominica: The Fight for Accessibility. Retrieved from https://borgenproject.org/education-in-dominica-fight-for-accessibility/

World Bank. (2023). Disability Inclusion in Latin America and the Caribbean. World Bank Group. Retrieved From. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/099061024112026984/pdf/P1712561cb605f0bc1b414176b029286096.pdf

 

 

 

 

How AI-Powered Monitoring and Filtering in Schools Affect Freedom of Expression: A Comparative Look at Italy and Spain

How AI-Powered Monitoring and Filtering in Schools Affect Freedom of Expression: A Comparative Look at Italy and Spain

By Elena Pajardi

Introduction

From 2020 onwards, classrooms across Europe transformed almost overnight. The pandemic forced a rapid shift towards digital learning platforms and remote learning environments, accelerating the adoption of educational technologies. AI tools offer real potential: supporting students and teachers through personalised learning, efficient administration and improved online safety. However, these systems also pose serious risks, including reinforcing societal biases through filtering or profiling, compromising privacy and, from the perspective of this article, undermining freedom of expression for both students and teachers.

Although many European countries have developed broad AI strategies, education-specific policies remain uneven. The pandemic placed digital education under a magnifying glass: it showed both how quickly technology could be adopted and how poorly prepared some school systems were to do so responsibly. When monitoring and filtering systems enter classrooms, questions arise: do students still feel free to express themselves? Can teachers use diverse materials without being constrained by algorithms or automated filters?

This article focuses on Italy and Spain to explore the implications of AI-powered monitoring for freedom of expression and consider possible responses. It also draws on international research to illustrate risks that warrant attention in both countries. Not all monitoring and filtering systems use AI, but both conventional and AI-powered systems can affect access to information and opportunities for expression.

Italy: Monitoring, Risks and Educational Rights

In Italy, the rapid adoption of digital tools during the pandemic prompted concerns about student monitoring and privacy. International research provides useful context, although its findings should not be presented as evidence of the prevalence or effects of monitoring in Italian schools.

An Italian article by Carmelina Maurizio, published in Agenda Digitale in 2022, discusses US research by the Center for Democracy & Technology (CDT). The research found that students with learning difficulties or physical disabilities reported greater effects from monitoring. Parents and teachers also expressed concern: approximately 71% of parents and 66% of teachers agreed that students were less likely to share their personal thoughts or ideas openly online if their schools used monitoring systems. Moreover, 66% of teachers feared that students would avoid websites or resources offering support, such as information about coming out or accessing mental health services. These figures relate to the US research discussed in the article, rather than a survey of Italian schools.

The research also highlights a troubling equity dimension. Previous US data cited in the article indicated that approximately six in ten Black students, six in ten Hispanic students, seven in ten rural students and seven in ten students from low-income families relied on school-provided computers or tablets. Students dependent on school-issued devices faced greater exposure to monitoring than peers using personal devices. These findings raise questions relevant to Italy, but further research is needed to establish whether comparable disparities exist in Italian schools.

On the regulatory front, Italy’s 2025 national AI law includes protections for freedom of expression and media pluralism in its provisions on information. Italy is also subject to the EU AI Act, which prohibits the use of AI to infer emotions in educational institutions, except for specified medical or safety purposes. This prohibition has applied since February 2025. Attention monitoring should not automatically be treated as equivalent to prohibited emotion recognition.

However, legal protections must be translated into institutional practice. Educational institutions need to consider how content filtering, device monitoring and remote examination supervision, commonly known as proctoring, can be used without creating an atmosphere of suspicion, self-censorship or restricted speech. The Italian data protection authority’s 2021 action against Bocconi University over its use of proctoring software illustrates the privacy risks associated with educational surveillance.

From the perspective of freedom of expression, the concern is clear: when students and teachers know that their online activity, device use or communications may be watched or analysed by algorithms, they may become less willing to experiment, ask critical questions or explore controversial topics. Teachers may avoid sensitive materials for fear of filters blocking them, while students may hesitate to seek personal support. If monitoring becomes the norm, learning risks turning into compliance.

Spain: Digitisation, Privacy and Expression

Spain faces a similar tension, alongside regional initiatives that offer possible alternatives. The pandemic drove Spanish schools towards online learning, increasing their reliance on digital platforms. Civil society organisations warned that outsourcing educational infrastructure to large technology companies could reduce schools’ control over students’ and teachers’ data and communications.

In 2020, EDRi reported that the Catalan Department of Education had accepted a plan proposed by the digital rights organisation Xnet, titled ‘Privacy and Democratic Digitization of Educational Centers’. The proposal advocated secure servers that respect human rights, auditable tools and training programmes to support a digital culture grounded in rights protection.

The agreement should not be treated as evidence of comprehensive implementation across Catalonia. Nevertheless, subsequent work offers a practical example: Xnet’s DD educational infrastructure brings together free and auditable software tools intended to support schools’ control over data and protect the educational community’s digital rights.

Spain is also subject to the EU AI Act. The Act identifies certain educational applications, including systems used to determine admission or assess learning outcomes, as high-risk uses. These categories should be distinguished from prohibited practices, such as emotion recognition in educational institutions, subject to the limited exceptions described above.

These developments have implications for freedom of expression. Auditable platforms and stronger institutional control over data may help schools explain how information is processed and how restrictions are applied. However, open-source software or public control does not, by itself, guarantee freedom from monitoring or filtering. Transparent policies, appropriate configuration and accessible complaints procedures remain essential.

Where schools use internet filters, classroom management platforms or device monitoring systems, restrictions may prevent access to legitimate resources, particularly when systems are misconfigured or lack transparent review mechanisms. Establishing the extent of these effects in Spanish schools requires evidence about their actual deployment and use.

Effects on Speech, Learning and Rights

The examples from Italy and Spain, considered alongside international research, identify several ways in which monitoring and filtering may affect freedom of expression:

  • Self-censorship: Knowing that device use, searches or communications might be monitored can reduce students’ willingness to explore sensitive topics or ask critical questions.
  • Restricted access to resources: Overzealous filters may block legitimate academic or personal support content, including mental health information, LGBTQ+ resources and politically or socially sensitive materials.
  • Teacher inhibition: Educators may avoid contentious subjects or diverse materials if they believe that algorithms will misinterpret or block them, limiting pedagogical freedom and classroom discussion.
  • Unequal impact: Students who depend on school-issued devices may face greater exposure to monitoring. US research documents this concern, but comparable evidence is needed before drawing firm conclusions about its extent in Italy or Spain.

There are also positive developments. Initiatives in Catalonia illustrate how alternative digital infrastructure can support rights protection, while Italy’s AI legislation provides an explicit legal reference point for freedom of expression. However, these examples do not establish that either country has resolved the practical risks associated with educational monitoring.

Policy Recommendations

What can be done to align AI use in schools with freedom of expression? Drawing on the reports and research discussed above, several steps merit consideration:

  1. Develop education-specific AI policies. General AI strategies should be supported by policies tailored to educational settings, with clear standards for data protection, ethical use and evidence-based decision-making.
  2. Ensure transparency and participation. Schools should explain which systems they use, what data are collected and how those data are processed. Students and teachers should have meaningful opportunities to shape monitoring policies.
  3. Adopt minimally intrusive technologies and auditable tools. Prioritise platforms that minimise unnecessary monitoring and allow schools to scrutinise their operation. Open-source tools may support these aims when accompanied by appropriate governance and safeguards.
  4. Strengthen digital and AI literacy. Educators, students and administrators need to understand how monitoring systems work, what their rights are and what trade-offs are involved. Teacher training should address AI ethics and freedom of expression.
  5. Implement human oversight, appeals and redress mechanisms. Algorithmic flags should be subject to meaningful human review. Students and teachers should have accessible ways to challenge filtering and monitoring decisions.
  6. Collect and publish evidence on impacts. European countries should invest in research on how AI affects learning, expression and equality in schools. Country-specific evidence is essential to avoid treating findings from other jurisdictions as proof of local conditions.
  7. Encourage public–private collaboration with rights safeguards. Where schools work with educational technology providers, agreements should incorporate ethical safeguards, rights-respecting design and public accountability.

By taking these steps, Italy, Spain and other European countries can help ensure that AI’s potential to support learning, improve access and enable innovation does not come at the expense of students’ or teachers’ freedom to express themselves, explore ideas and challenge assumptions. As education becomes increasingly digital, protecting that freedom remains fundamental.

References

Atabey, A. (2025, 20 February). Learning and teaching with AI. Ada Lovelace Institute.
https://www.adalovelaceinstitute.org/blog/learning-and-teaching-with-ai/

Calderini, B. (2020, 24 February). Riconoscimento facciale anche nelle scuole: ecco com’è usato e i problemi di privacy. Agenda Digitale.
Read the article

Center for Democracy & Technology. (2022, 3 August). Hidden harms: The misleading promise of monitoring students online.
Read the report

Council of Europe. (2024). The state of artificial intelligence and education across Europe: Results of a survey of Council of Europe member states.
Publication page

Dimalta, D. (2021, 30 September). Controllo remoto degli studenti, vizio di tanti: il Garante non sanzioni solo Bocconi. Agenda Digitale.
Read the article

European Commission. (2022). Ethical guidelines on the use of artificial intelligence (AI) and data in teaching and learning for educators. Publications Office of the European Union.
https://doi.org/10.2766/153756

European Commission. (n.d.). AI Act.
Policy overview

European Commission. (n.d.). Article 5: Prohibited AI practices. AI Act Service Desk.
Article 5

European Parliament. (2020). The impact of algorithms for online content filtering or moderation: Upload filters (PE 657.101).
Download the study

Italian Republic. (2025, 23 September). Legge 23 settembre 2025, n. 132: Disposizioni e deleghe al Governo in materia di intelligenza artificiale. Gazzetta Ufficiale.
Official legislation

Maurizio, C. (2022, 14 September). Studenti sempre più sorvegliati, non solo a scuola: l’impatto su privacy e salute mentale. Agenda Digitale.
Read the article

UNESCO. (2021). Recommendation on the ethics of artificial intelligence.
UNESCO record

Xnet. (2020, 8 July). Spain: Catalan government agrees to improve privacy in schools. European Digital Rights.
Read the article

Xnet. (n.d.). Introducing DD: A tool for the democratic digitalisation of education.
Project information

Crossing Borders, Not Classroom Doors: Migration and Education in Mayotte

Crossing Borders, Not Classroom Doors: Migration and Education in Mayotte

Note: This work is part of our new interns program. 

Visit Mayotte: 2026 Travel Guide for Mayotte, Africa | Expedia

Written by Capucine Robilliard

Mayotte, a French overseas department in the Comoros archipelago in the Indian Ocean, is marked by deep social inequality, rapid demographic growth, and sustained migration. These pressures, combined with shortages in school infrastructure, have placed the education system under severe strain. However, structural pressure alone does not explain why thousands of children remain excluded from education. The exclusion of migrant children is not accidental; it is produced through legal, administrative, and political choices at both national and local levels.

French policies on nationality, immigration, and housing have progressively restricted migrants’ rights, with indirect but serious consequences for schooling. At the municipal level, discriminatory enrolment practices and reluctance to expand infrastructure have further reinforced exclusion. Public rhetoric that frames migration as the main cause of Mayotte’s difficulties has also contributed to a hostile environment in which migrants’ rights are more easily undermined. This article argues that restrictive national policies and local administrative barriers have created a self-reinforcing system in which migrant children are denied effective access to education despite formal legal protections.

The exclusion of migrant children is not merely a by-product of the island’s structural inequalities. Mayotte has long been governed through differentiated legal regimes, particularly in relation to immigration and nationality. The 1995 Balladur visa attempted to restrict movement from the neighbouring Comoros, which had become independent in 1975, and it remains central to debates about migration in the archipelago (Tchokothe 2018). Despite this policy, Mayotte’s population continued to grow, placing further pressure on public infrastructure.

The French state later introduced measures that limited the effects of birthright citizenship in Mayotte. In 2006, specific mechanisms were established to limit paternity declarations by French fathers of children born to irregular Comorian mothers (Collectif Migrants Mayotte 2008). More recent reforms have further tightened access to French nationality for children born in Mayotte by imposing stricter residence requirements on parents (Human Rights Watch 2025a). These measures do not directly concern school enrolment, but they contribute to a wider climate of insecurity for migrant families.

This insecurity has significant consequences for education. Parents without regular status may fear enrolling their children when immigration controls and arrests are reported near municipal offices or schools (Human Rights Watch 2025a). Children who grow up with uncertain legal status may also experience anxiety about their future, especially as access to higher education and adult life becomes more complicated once they reach the age of majority (Human Rights Watch 2025a). Although schooling should be accessible to all children regardless of their parents’ administrative situation, legal precarity can make families less likely to approach public institutions.

Housing and migration-control policies have further disrupted children’s access to education. The state has used laws facilitating the evacuation and demolition of informal and unsanitary housing, and Operation Wuambushu in 2023 intensified the vulnerability of already fragile children (UNICEF 2023). Some families with regular status were offered temporary emergency accommodation, but this was often located far from their children’s schools. Families were therefore forced to choose between rehousing and continuity of schooling. Families in an irregular situation often received no rehousing or support for re-enrolment, and some were reportedly apprehended or placed in detention during these operations. The destruction of homes had serious consequences for children’s stability, schooling, and mental health (UNICEF 2023).

The Défenseur des droits has argued that measures undertaken by the French state have failed to reduce immigration while disproportionately restricting children’s rights. It also stressed that children living in Mayotte, regardless of nationality, residence, living conditions, origin, or their parents’ administrative status, have the same rights under the Convention on the Rights of the Child as children in mainland France (Défenseur des droits 2020).

Restrictive national policies have been accompanied by exclusion at the municipal level, particularly through school enrolment procedures. Child protection services have argued that municipalities use arbitrary administrative barriers to justify their inability to provide schooling to all children (Human Rights Watch 2025a). Although the French education system requires a specific set of documents for school enrolment, municipalities in Mayotte have reportedly requested additional documentation (Human Rights Watch 2025a). Local officials have acknowledged that these practices were used to manage enrolment numbers (Human Rights Watch 2025a).

These administrative barriers have disproportionately affected migrant families and asylum seekers. The Chambre régionale des comptes found that some excessive documentation requirements were imposed only on children whose parents were not EU nationals. It concluded that “most municipalities impose highly discriminatory enrolment conditions” and that these conditions, while helping to regulate capacity constraints, contributed to between 3,000 and 5,000 children not benefiting from compulsory education (Chambre régionale des comptes 2025).

Infrastructure shortages are often explained through poverty, underinvestment, or demographic pressure. However, the president of the Chambre régionale des comptes stated that the crisis was “not a problem of public funding” (Lauret 2025). Since 2016, €207 million had reportedly been allocated by the state for the construction and rehabilitation of schools in Mayotte, yet only around half of that funding had been used by mayors (Lauret 2025). While local authorities have faced technical and engineering difficulties, the Cour des comptes has also pointed to reluctance to invest in infrastructure perceived as primarily benefiting migrants or encouraging further migration (Cour des comptes 2022).

As a result, local authorities have relied on alternating school schedules, overcrowded classrooms, itinerant classes, and restrictive enrolment practices. Migration has often served as a scapegoat, obscuring the role of both state and local authorities in producing and maintaining the education crisis. According to the Défenseur des droits, social tensions in Mayotte are so intense that discussions about strengthening the rights of foreign nationals who are likely to remain on the island often receive little support (Défenseur des droits 2020). What emerges is a cycle of political deflection and public hostility: migration is blamed for underinvestment, while this blame reinforces the very inaction that deepens exclusion.

This hostile environment has also affected the safety of migrants and asylum seekers. Human Rights Watch reported that asylum seekers in Mayotte may face physical violence, including serious assaults after release from detention (Human Rights Watch 2025c). Some residents’ collectives have also obstructed access to administrative offices. From October 2024 to May 2025, members of the Collectif pour la Défense des Intérêts de Mayotte 2018 blockaded entrances to the prefecture’s offices in Mamoudzou, preventing people from accessing procedures for residence permits and asylum claims (Human Rights Watch 2025c). The prefecture did not immediately remove the blockade, reportedly because of its symbolic weight and concerns about backlash if force were used (Human Rights Watch 2025c).

The blockade had serious consequences for migrants and their families. People who could not lodge asylum claims or submit regularisation requests were left in prolonged administrative uncertainty (Human Rights Watch 2025c). For children, this meant greater vulnerability, increased instability, and further barriers to regular school attendance. The right to education was therefore affected not only by formal school policy, but also by the wider political and administrative environment surrounding migrant families.

The exclusion of migrant children from education in Mayotte is not accidental. It is the result of an interaction between restrictive national policies, exclusionary local governance, and public narratives that frame migration as the source of the island’s difficulties. National laws on nationality, migration control, and housing generate precarity and fear, while municipal practices turn enrolment procedures into instruments of selection and exclusion. These responsibilities are then obscured through narratives that place the blame on migrants themselves.

The consequences are both immediate and long-term. Children lose access to schooling, families become trapped in administrative insecurity, and social tensions deepen. Mayotte’s education crisis therefore reflects more than a shortage of classrooms. It reveals a broader contradiction: France presents itself as a defender of human rights, yet within one of its own overseas departments, migrant children continue to face serious barriers to one of the most fundamental rights of all — the right to education.

Reference List

Chambre régionale des comptes. 2025. L’école primaire : d’immenses défis pour les communes de Mayotte. Chambre régionale des comptes. https://program-evaluation.ccomptes.fr/sites/default/files/2025-06/ROD2-RPT—cole-primaire—-Mayotte-et-ses-r–ponses.pdf

Collectif Migrants Mayotte. 2008. La nationalité française à Mayotte. Collectif Migrants Outre-mer. https://www.migrantsoutremer.org/IMG/pdf/cahier-mom-1_natio-mayotte.pdf

Cour des comptes. 2022. Quel développement pour Mayotte? Mieux répondre aux défis de la démographique, de la départementalisation et des attentes des Mahorais. Cour des comptes. https://www.ccomptes.fr/fr/documents/60490

Défenseur des droits. 2020. Établir Mayotte dans ses droits: Constats et recommandations du Défenseur des droits faisant suite au déplacement d’une délégation de ses services à Mayotte les 2 et 3 octobre 2019. Défenseur des droits. https://www.defenseurdesdroits.fr/sites/default/files/2023-07/ddd_rapport_mayotte_2020_20200211.pdf

Human Rights Watch. 2025a. Exceptional Failure: France’s Persistent Education Shortcomings in Mayotte. Human Rights Watch. https://www.hrw.org/report/2025/11/18/exceptional-failure/frances-persistent-education-shortcomings-in-mayotte

Human Rights Watch. 2025b. “France: Many Children in Overseas Territory Lack Education.” Human Rights Watch. https://www.hrw.org/news/2025/06/19/france-many-children-in-overseas-territory-lack-education/

Human Rights Watch. 2025c. “France: Overseas Territory’s Education Barriers.” Human Rights Watch. https://www.hrw.org/news/2025/11/18/france-overseas-territorys-education-barriers/

Lauret, T. 2025. “École à Mayotte: ‘pas un problème d’argent public’ selon la CRC.” Zinfos974. https://www.zinfos974.com/ecole-a-mayotte-pas-un-probleme-dargent-public-selon-la-crc/

Tchokothe, R. A. 2018. “‘Balladur Visa’ or ‘Visa of Death’? Questioning ‘Migration’ to Europe via the Comoros Archipelago.” University of Vienna. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/342561986_Balladur_Visa_or_Visa_of_Death_Questioning_’Migration’_to_Europe_via_the_Comoros_Archipelago

UNICEF. 2023. Synthèse du rapport: Grandir dans les Outre-mer: État des lieux des droits de l’enfant. UNICEF. https://www.unicef.fr/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Synthese-du-rapport-Grandir-dans-les-Outre-mer.pdf

 

The Inequalities of Quality of Education in South African Schools

The Inequalities of Quality of Education in South African Schools

Written by Daniel Tsang

The Inequalities of Quality of Education in South African Schools

The South African education system is frequently discussed alongside education inequalities. While the country possesses a world-class private and semi-private sector that produces high-achieving graduates, the vast majority of the population relies on a public system that sometimes struggles to provide. And although the national government often celebrates high graduation rates at the end of high school, these statistics frequently mask a deeper crisis in the quality of education provided to the average learner. The significance of this issue lies in its direct impact on the lives of millions of young South Africans; it restricts a student’s ability to learn, grow, and pursue their desired future. This article examines the core quality issues within primary and secondary education, and by investigating these challenges, the article seeks to explain how these systemic failures in the classroom directly hinder student development.

The most significant quality hurdle in South African education occurs during the earliest years of schooling, known as the Foundation Phase (Grades R to 3). This period is intended to equip children with the basic literacy and numeracy skills required for all future learning. However, current data suggests a “generational catastrophe” in primary education. Approximately 81 per cent of Grade 4 learners in South Africa cannot “read for meaning” in any language (World Bank 2025, 36). This means that while many children can converse with others, they do not understand the information or the narrative of words being presented to them.

For the student, this literacy gap is not just a temporary delay; it is a permanent academic setback. When a child cannot read to learn by the age of ten, every subsequent subject, from history to science, becomes significantly more difficult to master as age increases. Because the curriculum shifts in Grade 4 from teaching reading to using reading as a tool for knowledge, students who have not mastered comprehension are left behind. Research indicates that students of schools that did not enrol in an additional early grade reading programme struggle to meet basic literacy benchmarks in English, compared to their counterparts (Long and Bowles 2024, 5). While the study has also demonstrated to some extent that a lack of funding is not the primary reason for this discrepancy, in many rural classrooms the quality of learning is indeed compromised by a lack of age-appropriate books, forcing teachers to rely on less efficient methods of teaching.

The quality of a student’s education is absolutely tied to the physical environment in which they are expected to learn. It is profoundly difficult for a learner to tackle complex mathematical or scientific concepts when their school lacks basic infrastructure. Reports have consistently highlighted the “infrastructure gap” in South African schools, particularly in rural provinces such as the Eastern Cape and KwaZulu-Natal. National data reveals that over 22 per cent of pre-primary, primary, and secondary schools did not have toilets that met minimum standards, 10 per cent of schools did not have clean water, and 9 per cent of schools did not have access to adequate electricity (World Bank 2025, 32). Despite the Department of Basic Education introducing tighter regulations in 2024 to address these issues, many learners continue to attend schools that are physically unsuited for a modern education.

The highly stratified South African schooling system, governed by a socio-economic ranking framework known as the “Quintile” system, does not make it easy to fund these “unsuited” schools. Under this model, schools are categorised from Quintile 1 (the poorest 20 per cent) to Quintile 5 (the wealthiest 20 per cent). This ranking dictates the level of state funding a school receives. Schools in Quintiles 1 to 3 are designated as “no-fee” institutions, meaning they rely entirely on government subsidies. Conversely, schools in Quintiles 4 and 5 receive less state funding but are legally permitted to charge tuition fees (Dyk and White 2019, S1).

This system, while intended to be pro-poor, has institutionalised a divide that punishes the student for their family’s economic status. Wealthy Quintile 5 schools leverage private fees to hire extra teachers and maintain smaller class sizes, ensuring that students receive much more individual attention (Dyk and White 2019, S2–S7). In contrast, students in “no-fee” schools often find themselves in overcrowded classrooms where a single teacher may be responsible for many more learners. Additionally, a student in a private or Quintile 5 school may have access to a personal tablet and high-speed internet, digitalised and much more accessible learning materials, but a student in a rural “no-fee” school may rarely interact with a computer or tablet during their entire schooling journey.

The experience of a student in South Africa is further defined by an intense academic routine and several significant constraints. An interview with a student enrolled in the private sector reveals that students are typically required to take 15 different subjects, covering everything from multiple languages and sciences to arts and business-related subjects (Student 2026). A typical school day begins at 07:30 a.m., with as many as eight classes a day, each lasting near or above 45 minutes (Student 2026). The teaching style is largely traditional and lecture-based, where the teacher delivers information and students are expected to learn it to pass national assessments coming later during their schooling years.

For students in urban centres like Johannesburg, life is further complicated by safety concerns. High crime rates in the city mean that students cannot walk home or socialise freely on the streets (Student 2026). Consequently, student life is usually confined within the school perimeter. Socialisation often occurs during school breaks, related events, or through sports and extracurricular activities like field hockey, rugby, and drama (Student 2026). Despite its diversity, this creates an environment where the school becomes the centre of a student’s social life as well. And while this provides safety, it also increases the pressure to perform, blurring the lines between the student’s demanding study expectations and personal life. Later during a student’s schooling, during Grades 11 and 12, the focus shifts towards the National Senior Certificate (NSC) and the National Benchmark Tests (NBTs), which determine university entrances (Student 2026). For many students, this results in an intense lack of “work-life balance,” as they are constantly pushed to achieve the high marks required to advance their education.

The quality of education in South African schools remains a complex challenge defined by historical socio-economic challenges and modern structural failures. While the country has expanded access to schooling, the standard of that education is often insufficient to fulfil its large population. To improve the quality of learning, the education system must understand the importance of quality of instruction in the early grades. Ensuring foundational literacy, closing the divide of academic quality between the quintiles, and fixing school infrastructure are essential steps toward a more equitable system. Only by addressing these core quality issues can South Africa ensure that a student’s future is determined by their potential, rather than the socio-economic status of the school they attended.

Endnotes

  1. World Bank. South Africa Economic Update, Edition 15: Learning – Overdue Reforms and Emerging Priorities in Basic Education. 36, Washington, DC: World Bank Group, 2025.
  2. Long, Kathleen and Bowles, Thomas. No-fee school consistently outperforms Progress in International Reading and Literacy benchmarks: Presenting early grade reading data from a case in Makhanda, Eastern Cape. 5, Johannesburg: South African Journal of Childhood Education, 2024.
  3. World Bank. South Africa Economic Update, Edition 15: Learning – Overdue Reforms and Emerging Priorities in Basic Education. 32, Washington, DC: World Bank Group, 2025.
  4. Dyk, H. and White, C. J. Theory and Practice of the Quintile Ranking of Schools in South Africa: A Financial Management Perspective. S1, Pretoria: South African Journal of Education, 2019.
  5. Dyk, H. and White, C. J. Theory and Practice of the Quintile Ranking of Schools in South Africa: A Financial Management Perspective. S2–S7, Pretoria: South African Journal of Education, 2019.
  6. Student. Interview Regarding Student Life and Education Quality in South Africa.: Broken Chalk, 2026.
  7. Student. Interview Regarding Student Life and Education Quality in South Africa.: Broken Chalk, 2026.
  8. Student. Interview Regarding Student Life and Education Quality in South Africa.: Broken Chalk, 2026.
  9. Student. Interview Regarding Student Life and Education Quality in South Africa.: Broken Chalk, 2026.
  10. Student. Interview Regarding Student Life and Education Quality in South Africa.: Broken Chalk, 2026.

References

Dyk, H., and C. J. White. 2019. “Theory and Practice of the Quintile Ranking of Schools in South Africa: A Financial Management Perspective.” South African Journal of Education 39 (S1): S1–S9. https://doi.org/10.15700/saje.v39ns1a1820.

Long, K. A., & Bowles, T. N. (2024). “No-fee school consistently outperforms Progress in International Reading and Literacy benchmarks: Presenting early grade reading data from a case in Makhanda, Eastern Cape.” South African Journal of Childhood Education, 14(1), 1–12. https://doi.org/10.4102/sajce.v14i1.1376

World Bank. (2025). South Africa Economic Update, Edition 15: Learning – Overdue Reforms and Emerging Priorities in Basic Education. World Bank Group. https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/bitstreams/3a8db70e-afeb-4831-87a0-589ff5011a4c/download

The Paradox of Choice: Free School Systems and Educational Segregation in Sweden.

The Paradox of Choice: Free School Systems and Educational Segregation in Sweden.

Author: Connor J. Urquhart

 

“Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world”

(Mandela 2003).1

 

The sentiments provided by Nelson Mandela, highlight the transformative role education can play in society. Across the world, education is widely viewed as a key tool for promoting equal opportunities, social mobility, and integration (Mandahu 2025, 21).2 Yet despite significant global progress in expanding access to schooling, achieving genuine equality within education systems remains a challenge. Even within some of the most well-resourced societies, disparities in educational opportunity persist. In a high-income country like Sweden, a society often recognised for its strong welfare state and its commitment to social equality, challenges persist within educational equality. In the early 1990s, Sweden introduced a major educational reform known as the ‘free school’ or friskola system, allowing parents to choose between municipal schools and public funded independent schools aiming to improve educational quality through competition (Alexiadou and Lundahl 2016, 66).3 While the reform was intended to increase efficiency and opportunity within the education system it has also sparked debate about its broader implications or “unintended consequences” as one mother and educator in Sweden articulated (Interview with author, Broken Chalk 2026).

Among the most significant concerns is the argument that increased school choice may contribute to segregation between schools and unequal educational opportunities for students from different socioeconomic and immigrant backgrounds (University of Gothenburg 2026).4 To better understand these concerns, this article examines how Sweden’s free school system influences student’s educational experiences. It will explore the intended outcomes of school choice as well as the system’s potential impact on educational equality, academic outcomes, and overall access to these opportunities to different groups of students.

 

The Intention Behind Free School Systems:

 

Prior to the early 1990s, the Swedish educational system was largely centralized and students would attend their local municipal school. While this model was designed to promote equality and universal access, critics argued that it limited parental choice and reduced incentives for schools to innovate or improve performance (Riksrevisionen 2022).5 In 1992, the Swedish government introduced a voucher-based reform that would allow publicly funded independent schools or ‘free schools’ to operate alongside municipal schools. Under this system, funding follows the student, meaning each child is allocated a publicly financed voucher that can be used at either a municipal school or an independent school (Frontier Centre for Public Policy 2005, 2).6 The reform aimed to create greater flexibility within the education system while maintaining universal public funding.

Policymakers at the time believed that increased competition between schools would lead to improvements in educational quality (Frontier Centre for Public Policy 2005, 3).7 Many described it as a ‘window being opened’ by giving parents greater freedom to choose schools, the reform sought to empower families and encourage schools to respond more directly to students’ needs (Sjöman 2022).8 For the most part these reforms have been quite successful, both Sweden’s investment in education and its study outcomes are above the average for The Organisation for Economic Co-Operation (OECD), (European Commission 2025).9 Meaning the Swedish government puts sufficient focus on education and that the financial input and educational output align, placing Sweden in the top 10 countries with the highest score in rights to education (Schleicher 2019).9

However, as an educator in Sweden explains “Sweden has some very equality-based policies and really aims to create equality, but I don’t think it is an equity that extends to all” (Interview with author, Broken Chalk 2026). An excellent representation that while the system generally creates equal access to education, sometimes it can render certain individuals invisible in the process. A burden mostly felt by students from different socioeconomic and immigrant backgrounds (Hansen, Patsis, and Gustafsson 2025, 15).10 The next section will demonstrate how a reform intended to create equality and opportunity, especially for those who were previously barred from access, can also have unintended effects of marginalisation.

 

The Unintended Consequences

 

(1) Segregation and Educational Inequality

School choice allows families to select schools based on factors such as academic reputation, location, or social environment. However not all families have the same ability to navigate the system (Böhlmark and Lindahl 2015).11 In Sweden, families who are more established in the country with greater financial resources, educational backgrounds, and access to information are often better positioned to choose schools (Hansen, Patsis, and Gustafsson 2025, 3).12

This is exemplified in one mother’s experience, where she explains that the system can create fewer opportunities for newly arrived families. As she notes, “it really does create less opportunities for families that have newly arrived and don’t have a corporate backing that helps them get into an international school.” Access can also be limited by the queue-based admission system used by many free schools. According to them, families may have to wait “two or three years” before a place becomes available. For newly arrived families, the barriers can be even greater: “When you newly arrived in Sweden and you haven’t got your personal number yet, you can’t get on the queue system, and you didn’t know that you were supposed to put your child on the queue when they were six months old” (Interview with author, Broken Chalk 2026).

Together, these structural barriers illustrate how navigating school choice may be easier for some families than others, raising concern that the system may unintentionally deepen educational inequality.

(2) Differences in Academic Performance

Segregation between schools can also influence academic performance. Schools with a higher concentration of disadvantaged students often face greater challenges with research frequently showing that they tend to have lower average test scores compared with schools that enroll more advantaged students. For example, only 49% of immigrant students reach proficiency benchmarks in reading, mathematics, and science, compared to 76% of native students (Cerna et al. 2019).13 However, these differences are shaped by a range of complex and interconnected factors, including socioeconomic conditions, language barriers, and differences in access to educational resources.

The point is not to suggest that students from disadvantaged backgrounds are less capable of achieving strong academic outcomes. Rather, it highlights how the broader educational environment can influence learning opportunities. At the same time, schools that attract higher-performing or more advantaged students may benefit from stronger academic cultures and higher expectations.

In this way, segregation between schools can contribute to widening achievement gaps, where academic outcomes are shaped not only by individual ability or effort, but also by the learning environments and opportunities available within different schools. As a result, a student’s academic prospects may increasingly depend on the school they attend.

 

(3) Differences in Educational Opportunities

Limited accessibility to the free school system can also affect the range of educational opportunities available to students. Some schools are better able to attract experienced teachers, offer specialized programs, provide stronger preparation for higher education, and have greater access to educational resources (Hansen, Patsis, and Gustafsson 2025, 16).14

For some students, attending a well-resourced school may provide clearer pathways toward higher education and broader academic possibilities. For others, opportunities may be more limited due to fewer resources or language barriers. As a result, the structure of the school system itself can influence students’ long-term educational prospects (Cerna et al. 2019 23).15

This perspective reflects an important reality that while education is broadly available, the quality and range of opportunities within different schools may vary. Understanding how these differences shape students’ experiences is therefore essential when examining the broader impacts of the free school system.

 

Conclusion

 

The introduction of the free school system in the early 1990s was intended to strengthen the commitment to educational equality by expanding parental choice and improving educational quality through competition. In many respects, these reforms have contributed to a dynamic education system that performs well internationally and continues to prioritise education. However, as this article has explored, policies designed to expand opportunity can also produce unintended consequences. While the free school system provides families with greater flexibility, it can also contribute to patterns of segregation between schools, differences in academic performance, and unequal access to educational opportunities.

At the same time, the debate surrounding Sweden’s free school system should not be framed as a simple question of whether school choice should exist. As an educator in Sweden, reflects, “there is a question that we should have a choice of schools. Absolutely. And I think that also acts as a checks and balances on the school” (Interview with author, Broken Chalk 2026). Rather, the challenge lies in ensuring that the benefits of choice are accessible to all students, not only to those families best positioned to navigate the system. Addressing these challenges requires policies that strengthen both equity and quality across schools. This includes fostering effective strategies that prioritise: improving instructional quality, promoting inclusive school composition and positive learning environments, and addressing the specific needs of disadvantaged students (Cerna et al. 2019, 17).16 By focusing on these areas, policymakers can help ensure that educational reforms continue to support both excellence and fairness.

Ultimately, Sweden’s experience illustrates the complexity of balancing choice, competition, and equality within education systems. If education is indeed a ‘powerful weapon’ for social change, then ensuring that all students have meaningful access to high-quality learning environments remains one of the most important challenges for policymakers, educators, and communities alike.

 

 

Endnotes

 

  1. Nelson Mandela. “Lighting Your Way to a Better Future: Speech Delivered at the Launch of Mindset Network.” July 16, 2003. http://www.mandela.gov.za/mandela_speeches/2003/030716_mindset.htm
  2. Mandahu, Teresa. Education and Social Mobility in Emerging Economies: A Review of Barriers and Opportunities. International Journal of Social Science and Applied Technology 1, no. 2 (2025): 21-28. doi:10.64391/ijssat.v1i1.003.
  3. Alexiadou, Nafsika, and Lisbeth Lundahl. “Reforming Swedish Education by Introduction of Quasimarkets and Competition.” In New Public Management and the Reform of Education: European Lessons for Policy and Practice, edited by Helen Gunter, Emiliano Grimaldi, David Hall, and Roberto Serpieri, 66–80. London and New York: Routledge, Taylor & Francis, 2016.
  4. University of Gothenburg. “School Segregation in Sweden: Challenges, Opportunities and Interventions.” Last modified February 6, 2026. https://www.gu.se/en/research/schoolsegregation-in-sweden-challenges-opportunities-and-interventions.
  5. Riksrevisionen. The School Voucher System – Efficiency and Consequences (RiR 2022:17), Summary. Stockholm: Swedish National Audit Office, 2022. https://www.riksrevisionen.se/download/18.2008b69c18bd0f6ed3f24583/1671632014607/RiR_2022_17_summary.pdf
  6. Frontier Centre for Public Policy. School Vouchers in Sweden. Winnipeg: Frontier Centre for Public Policy, May 16, 2005. https://frontiercentre.org/wp-content/uploads/FB034Swedish-school-vouchers.pdf.
  7. Frontier Centre for Public Policy. School Vouchers in Sweden. Winnipeg. 6
  8. Sjöman, Anders. 2022. “New Book: 30 Years since the Swedish Free School Reform.” Centre for Business History (Näringslivshistoria). June 8, 2022. https://naringslivshistoria.se/en/news/new-book-30-years-since-the-swedish-free-school-reform/.
  9. European Commission. Education and Training Monitor 2025: Country Report — Sweden. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union, 2025. https://op.europa.eu/webpub/eac/education-and-training-monitor/en/country-reports/sweden.html.
  10. Hansen, Kajsa Yang, Panagiotis Patsis, and Jan-Eric Gustafsson. “How does school composition mitigate socioeconomic and ethnic gaps in students’ achievement in Sweden: A long-term trend between 1988 and 2020.” (2025).
  11. Böhlmark, Anders, and Mikael Lindahl. “Independent schools and long‐run educational outcomes: Evidence from Sweden’s large‐scale voucher reform.” Economica 82, no. 327 (2015): 508-551.
  12. Hansen, Kajsa Yang, Panagiotis Patsis, and Jan-Eric Gustafsson. “How does school composition mitigate socioeconomic problems? 3
  13. Cerna, L., Andersson, H., Bannon, M., & Borgonovi, F. (2019). Strength through diversity’s Spotlight Report for Sweden. OECD Education Working Papers, No. 194, OECD Publishing.
  14. Hansen, Kajsa Yang, Panagiotis Patsis, and Jan-Eric Gustafsson. “How does school composition mitigate. 16
  15. Cerna, L., Andersson, H., Bannon, M., & Borgonovi, F. (2019). Strength through diversity. 23

 

 

Bibliography

 

Alexiadou, Nafsika, and Lisbeth Lundahl. (2016). “Reforming Swedish Education by Introduction of Quasimarkets and Competition.” In New Public Management and the Reform of Education: European Lessons for Policy and Practice, edited by Helen Gunter, Emiliano Grimaldi, David Hall, and Roberto Serpieri, 66–80. London and New York: Routledge, Taylor & Francis,

Böhlmark, Anders, and Mikael Lindahl. “Independent schools and long‐run educational outcomes: Evidence from Sweden’s large‐scale voucher reform.” Economica 82, no. 327 (2015): 508-551.

Cerna, L., Andersson, H., Bannon, M., & Borgonovi, F. (2019). Strength through diversity’s Spotlight Report for Sweden. OECD Education Working Papers, No. 194, OECD Publishing.

European Commission. Education and Training Monitor 2025: Country Report — Sweden. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union, 2025. https://op.europa.eu/webpub/eac/education-and-training-monitor/en/country-reports/sweden.html.

Frontier Centre for Public Policy. School Vouchers in Sweden. Winnipeg: Frontier Centre for Public Policy, May 16, 2005. https://frontiercentre.org/wp-content/uploads/FB034Swedish-school-vouchers.pdf.

Hansen, Kajsa Yang, Panagiotis Patsis, and Jan-Eric Gustafsson. (2025). “How does school composition mitigate socioeconomic and ethnic gaps in students’ achievement in Sweden: A long-term trend between 1988 and 2020.”

Mandahu, Teresa. Education and Social Mobility in Emerging Economies: A Review of Barriers and Opportunities. International Journal of Social Science and Applied Technology 1, no. 2 (2025): 21-28. doi:10.64391/ijssat.v1i1.003.

Nelson Mandela. “Lighting Your Way to a Better Future: Speech Delivered at the Launch of Mindset Network.” July 16, 2003. http://www.mandela.gov.za/mandela_speeches/2003/030716_mindset.htm

Riksrevisionen. The School Voucher System – Efficiency and Consequences (RiR 2022:17), Summary. Stockholm: Swedish National Audit Office, 2022. https://www.riksrevisionen.se/download/18.2008b69c18bd0f6ed3f24583/1671632014607/RiR_2022_17_summary.pdf

Schleicher, Andreas. 2019. PISA 2018: Insights and Interpretations. Paris: OECD Publishing.

Sjöman, Anders. 2022. “New Book: 30 Years since the Swedish Free School Reform.” Centre for Business History (Näringslivshistoria). June 8, 2022. https://naringslivshistoria.se/en/news/new-book-30-years-since-the-swedish-free-school-reform/.

University of Gothenburg. “School Segregation in Sweden: Challenges, Opportunities and Interventions.” Last modified February 6, 2026. https://www.gu.se/en/research/schoolsegregation-in-sweden-challenges-opportunities-and-interventions.

 

Education Under Pressure: Global Challenges to Safety, Equity, and Access

Education Under Pressure: Global Challenges to Safety, Equity, and Access

Written by Panashe Mlambo

 


Introduction

Between 16 and 31 July 2025, education systems across the globe experienced a series of developments that highlight both persistent inequalities and emerging reform efforts. From infrastructure failures and violent conflict to economic pressures and gender inequality, the events of this period demonstrate the complex challenges shaping access to education worldwide.

At the same time, governments, international organisations, and local communities continue to introduce policies and initiatives aimed at strengthening education systems. Examining these developments together provides insight into the structural forces affecting global education today and the urgent need for coordinated responses to safeguard the right to education.

Safety Risks and Infrastructure Failures

Several incidents during this period exposed serious vulnerabilities in school safety and infrastructure. On 21 July 2025, a Bangladesh Air Force training jet crashed into the campus of Milestone School and College in Dhaka’s Uttara district shortly after take-off from Kurmitola Air Base. The crash killed at least 31 people, including 25 students, and injured more than 160 others (Reuters 2025). The tragedy triggered protests among students and community members who demanded accountability, compensation for victims’ families, and stricter regulations governing military training flights over populated areas.

Concerns about school safety also emerged in India, where the roof of a government school building in Rajasthan’s Jhalawar district collapsed during heavy monsoon rains, killing four children and injuring several others (Al Jazeera 2025). The incident renewed scrutiny of ageing school infrastructure, particularly in rural areas that frequently face extreme weather conditions.

In the United Kingdom, a school bus carrying children overturned on a rural road in Somerset on 17 July 2025, killing one child and injuring several others (Reuters 2025). The accident prompted renewed calls for stronger safety standards in school transport and clearer emergency protocols for school trips.

These incidents underscore the importance of consistent infrastructure maintenance, climate-resilient school construction, and effective safety protocols to protect students in educational environments.

Education in Contexts of Conflict and Displacement

Conflict and political instability continue to disrupt schooling for millions of children worldwide. In Haiti, escalating gang violence has forced schools such as Anténor Firmin in Hinche to serve as shelters for displaced families instead of functioning as learning spaces (United Nations News 2025). Teachers attempt to continue lessons through improvised classes, but shortages of food, sanitation, and educational materials make regular schooling nearly impossible.

Similarly, the growing number of Sudanese refugees in Libya has created an urgent education crisis. Many children living in Tripoli face homelessness and exploitation, while economic hardship and tuition costs have forced numerous students to drop out of school (Radio Dabanga 2025). Without sustained support, thousands of displaced children risk long-term educational loss.

Education access is even more restricted in Afghanistan, where girls remain banned from attending secondary schools and universities under Taliban policies. Many girls have therefore turned to religious madrassas, where the curriculum focuses primarily on religious instruction with limited exposure to modern subjects (Associated Press 2025). International organisations warn that millions of girls may permanently lose access to secondary education if these restrictions continue.

In Colombia, conflict and poverty continue to undermine education in regions such as Putumayo. The opening of a new branch of the Universidad de la Amazonia in Puerto Asís aims to provide young people with alternatives to illicit economies and armed group recruitment, although insecurity and economic hardship continue to threaten students’ ability to complete their studies (The New Humanitarian 2025).

These cases highlight how conflict and displacement not only interrupt schooling but also deepen long-term educational inequalities.

Gender Inequality and Social Barriers in Education

Gender inequality remains a major barrier to equitable education. In Canada, teachers have reported an increase in misogynistic attitudes among male students influenced by online content and social media personalities. Female teachers have described situations in which students refuse to acknowledge their authority, creating difficult classroom environments (CBC News 2025). Researchers argue that schools must actively address harmful gender stereotypes and promote healthier models of masculinity.

Gender disparities are also evident in Japan’s higher education system, where women remain underrepresented in academic positions and leadership roles despite decades of policy efforts to improve gender equality (Times Higher Education 2025). Experts argue that structural barriers continue to limit women’s participation and advancement within academia.

In Benin, health and sanitation challenges continue to affect girls’ ability to attend school. Menstrual poverty, combined with the absence of appropriate sanitation facilities in many schools, contributes to absenteeism and school dropout among girls. In response, the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS) and the West African Health Organisation (WAHO) distributed 5,000 reusable menstrual hygiene kits to schools as part of a regional initiative to address menstrual insecurity (News Ghana 2025). While the programme represents an important step, long-term solutions will require improved sanitation infrastructure and comprehensive menstrual health education.

These examples illustrate how social norms, gender inequality, and health-related challenges continue to shape educational experiences and access.

Economic Pressures and Structural Challenges

Financial pressures also influence education systems across the globe. In Portugal, the cost of student housing has risen sharply, with the national average rent for a private room exceeding €415 per month. The rising cost of living has made it increasingly difficult for students to afford higher education, particularly in major cities such as Lisbon and Porto (Euronews 2025).

In Egypt, overcrowded classrooms and teacher shortages continue to strain the public education system. Some classrooms reportedly accommodate more than forty students, and in extreme cases up to two hundred (Human Rights Watch 2025). Although the government has introduced pilot initiatives such as preschool programmes in mosques to expand educational capacity, education spending as a proportion of GDP remains below international benchmarks.

Policy debates in the United States also highlight concerns about education funding. Advocacy organisations warn that proposed changes to federal education programmes could affect services for vulnerable groups, including students with disabilities and adult learners.

These cases demonstrate how financial constraints and policy decisions influence both the accessibility and quality of education.

Reform Efforts and Educational Innovation

Despite these challenges, several countries are pursuing reforms aimed at strengthening education systems. In Sri Lanka, the government has proposed transitioning from an exam-centred education system to a module-based model beginning in 2026. The reform aims to encourage continuous assessment and more diverse learning methods.

Technological innovation is also shaping education policy. Rwanda’s Digital Acceleration Project, part of the Smart Rwanda Master Plan, has electrified hundreds of rural schools using off-grid solar power and expanded access to digital learning tools (The Borgen Project 2025). Similarly, Nigeria has approved solar hybrid power systems for several universities in an effort to stabilise electricity supply and support academic activities.

Early childhood education initiatives are also gaining attention. In Bosnia and Herzegovina, a new Early Childhood Development Centre has been established through cooperation between UNICEF, the European Union, and national authorities. The centre aims to identify developmental challenges early and coordinate support across the education, health, and social protection sectors (UNICEF 2025).

Community-driven initiatives are also emerging. In Malaysia, the proposed “Siswa Balik Sekolah” programme seeks to connect university students with rural primary schools, allowing them to mentor younger students in key subjects such as mathematics and science.

Together, these initiatives demonstrate the diverse strategies countries are adopting to improve access to education and strengthen learning outcomes.


Conclusion

The developments observed between 16 and 31 July 2025 reveal a global education landscape marked by both urgent challenges and ongoing reform efforts. Safety incidents in Bangladesh, India, and the United Kingdom highlight the need for stronger infrastructure and protection measures. Meanwhile, conflict and displacement continue to undermine education access in Haiti, Libya, Afghanistan, and Colombia.

At the same time, structural challenges—including gender inequality, economic pressures, and teacher shortages—affect education systems across both developed and developing countries. Nevertheless, reforms such as Sri Lanka’s curriculum changes, Rwanda’s digital infrastructure expansion, and early childhood initiatives in Bosnia and Herzegovina demonstrate that progress remains possible through sustained investment and policy innovation.

Ensuring that every child has access to safe, inclusive, and quality education will require long-term commitment from governments, international organisations, and civil society. Addressing both immediate crises and structural inequalities is essential to safeguarding the right to education worldwide.


Endnotes

  1. Reuters. “Students protest in Bangladesh after air force jet crash kills 31, mostly children.” 2025.
  2. Reuters. “One child killed in UK school bus crash.” 2025.
  3. Al Jazeera. “At least four children dead in school roof collapse in India.” 2025.
  4. United Nations News. “Schools in Haiti shelter displaced families amid violence.” 2025.
  5. Radio Dabanga. “Sudanese children on the streets of Tripoli face homelessness and exploitation.” 2025.
  6. Associated Press. “Afghanistan girls turn to madrassas amid education ban.” 2025.
  7. CBC News. “Misogyny and online influencers affecting boys in classrooms.” 2025.
  8. Times Higher Education. “Gender equality challenges in Japan’s higher education sector.” 2025.
  9. News Ghana. “ECOWAS distributes reusable sanitary kits to Benin schools.” 2025.
  10. Euronews. “Rising rents: Which is the cheapest city in Portugal for students to live in.” 2025.
  11. The New Humanitarian. “Colombia’s new university aims to break the cycle of conflict.” 2025.
  12. The Borgen Project. “The impacts of the Smart Rwanda Master Plan.” 2025.
  13. UNICEF. “Early childhood development centre opened in Doboj.” 2025.

Reference List

Al Jazeera. (2025). At least four children dead in school roof collapse in India. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/7/25/at-least-four-children-dead-in-school-roof-collapse-in-india

Associated Press. (2025). Afghanistan girls turn to madrassas amid education ban. https://apnews.com/article/afghanistan-taliban-education-girls-madrassa-7cdaf68896e8ccfda2abd71a07a02b99

CBC News. (2025). Misogyny and online influencers affecting boys in classrooms. https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/misogyny-online-influencers-boys-classrooms-1.7587571

Euronews. (2025). Rising rents: Which is the cheapest city in Portugal for students to live in. https://www.euronews.com/business/2025/07/29/rising-rents-which-is-the-cheapest-city-in-portugal-for-students-to-live-in

News Ghana. (2025). ECOWAS distributes reusable sanitary kits to Benin schools. https://www.newsghana.com.gh/ecowas-distributes-reusable-sanitary-kits-to-benin-schools

Radio Dabanga. (2025). Sudanese children on the streets of Tripoli face homelessness and exploitation. https://www.dabangasudan.org/en/all-news/article/sudanese-children-on-the-streets-of-tripoli-face-homelessness-and-exploitation

Reuters. (2025). Students protest in Bangladesh after air force jet crash kills 31. https://www.reuters.com

Reuters. (2025). One child killed in UK school bus crash. https://www.reuters.com

The Borgen Project. (2025). The impacts of the Smart Rwanda Master Plan. https://borgenproject.org

The New Humanitarian. (2025). Colombia’s new university aims to break the cycle of conflict. https://www.thenewhumanitarian.org

Times Higher Education. (2025). Gender equality challenges in Japan’s higher education sector. https://www.timeshighereducation.com

UNICEF. (2025). Early childhood development centre opened in Doboj. https://www.unicef.org

United Nations News. (2025). Schools in Haiti shelter displaced families amid violence. https://news.un.org/en/story/2025/07/1165414

 

Education Monitor: Around The Globe between July 16th and 31st, 2025 Edition

Education Monitor: Around The Globe between July 16th and 31st, 2025 Edition

Broken Chalk proudly presents a new edition of “Education Monitor: Around the Globe” between July 16th and 31st, 2025 Broken Chalk aims with this letter to increase public awareness of educational problems, challenges, and violations in the scope of the world. This newsletter is unique. This is a weekly newsletter in which we attempt to monitor and convey educational news from around the world in a concise manner. This monitor will be published biweekly with the effort of our young and enthusiastic team.

You can contribute to our work if you like. If you witness any violations in the scope of education, you can write the comment part of this post. Broken Chalk will try to address the issue in its next monitor edition.

Broken Chalk Platform, in March 2019, was founded by a group of educators abroad who experienced and have been experiencing severe human rights violations in Turkey and had to ask for asylum in several countries.

These education volunteers also suffered greatly and started their new lives in their new countries without human rights violations. They gained respect just because they were considered human beings in those countries. However, they left one part of their minds and hearts in their homeland. They assigned themselves a new duty, and the human rights violations they left behind had to be announced to the World. A group of education volunteers who came together for this purpose started their activities under the Broken Chalk platform’s umbrella. However, the Broken Chalk platform was not enough to serve their aims. Therefore, they completed their official establishment as a Human Rights Foundation in October 2020.

Broken Chalk is now much more than a platform, and we have reviewed and enlarged our vision and mission within this framework. Violations of rights would be the first in our agenda in the field of Education all over the World. At the point we reached today, Broken Chalk opened its door to all individuals from all across the globe, from all professions, and to all individuals who say or can say ‘I also want to stand against violations of human rights in Education for our future and whole humanity, where our generations grow up together.’

Education is essential because it can help us eliminate the evils from society, introduce, and increase the good. We want to draw the public’s and stakeholders’ attention to the fact that Education is in danger in several different parts of the World. The attacks are wide-reaching, from the bombing of schools to the murder of students and teachers. Raping and sexual violence, arbitrary arrests, and forced recruitment also occurred, instigated by armed groups. Attacks on Education harm the students and teachers but also affect the communities in the short and long term.

We invite all individuals who want to stop human rights violations in Education to become Volunteers at Broken Chalk.

 

Education Monitor: Around The Globe between July 1st and July 15th, 2025 Edition

Education Monitor: Around The Globe between July 16th and 31st, 2025 Edition

Broken Chalk proudly presents a new edition of “Education Monitor: Around the Globe” between July 1st and July 15th, 2025 Broken Chalk aims with this letter to increase public awareness of educational problems, challenges, and violations in the scope of the world. This newsletter is unique. This is a weekly newsletter in which we attempt to monitor and convey educational news from around the world in a concise manner. This monitor will be published biweekly with the effort of our young and enthusiastic team.

You can contribute to our work if you like. If you witness any violations in the scope of education, you can write the comment part of this post. Broken Chalk will try to address the issue in its next monitor edition.

Broken Chalk Platform, in March 2019, was founded by a group of educators abroad who experienced and have been experiencing severe human rights violations in Turkey and had to ask for asylum in several countries.

These education volunteers also suffered greatly and started their new lives in their new countries without human rights violations. They gained respect just because they were considered human beings in those countries. However, they left one part of their minds and hearts in their homeland. They assigned themselves a new duty, and the human rights violations they left behind had to be announced to the World. A group of education volunteers who came together for this purpose started their activities under the Broken Chalk platform’s umbrella. However, the Broken Chalk platform was not enough to serve their aims. Therefore, they completed their official establishment as a Human Rights Foundation in October 2020.

Broken Chalk is now much more than a platform, and we have reviewed and enlarged our vision and mission within this framework. Violations of rights would be the first in our agenda in the field of Education all over the World. At the point we reached today, Broken Chalk opened its door to all individuals from all across the globe, from all professions, and to all individuals who say or can say ‘I also want to stand against violations of human rights in Education for our future and whole humanity, where our generations grow up together.’

Education is essential because it can help us eliminate the evils from society, introduce, and increase the good. We want to draw the public’s and stakeholders’ attention to the fact that Education is in danger in several different parts of the World. The attacks are wide-reaching, from the bombing of schools to the murder of students and teachers. Raping and sexual violence, arbitrary arrests, and forced recruitment also occurred, instigated by armed groups. Attacks on Education harm the students and teachers but also affect the communities in the short and long term.

We invite all individuals who want to stop human rights violations in Education to become Volunteers at Broken Chalk.