शिक्षा व्यक्तियों और समाज के भविष्य को आकार देने में महत्वपूर्ण भूमिका निभाती है। एक जटिल इतिहास और प्रगति की प्रबल इच्छा वाले देश इरिट्रिया के मामले में, शैक्षिक परिदृश्य अतीत से विरासत में मिली चुनौतियों और इसकी शिक्षा प्रणाली द्वारा सामना किए जाने वाले समकालीन मुद्दों दोनों को दर्शाता है। ऐतिहासिक संदर्भ और वर्तमान चुनौतियों का परीक्षण करके, हम उन बाधाओं की व्यापक समझ प्राप्त करते हैं जिन्हें इरिट्रिया को अपनी आबादी के लिए न्यायसंगत और गुणवत्तापूर्ण शिक्षा सुनिश्चित करने के लिए दूर करना चाहिए।
बच्चे कक्षा में जाने का इंतजार कर रहे हैं। मेरहावी147 द्वारा फोटो
ऐतिहासिक पृष्ठभूमि
इरिट्रिया की शिक्षा प्रणाली समय के साथ विकसित हुई है, जो इसके औपनिवेशिक इतिहास और स्वतंत्रता के लिए संघर्ष से गहराई से प्रभावित है। 19वीं सदी के अंत और 20वीं सदी की शुरुआत में इतालवी औपनिवेशिक शासन के तहत, शिक्षा कुछ विशेषाधिकार प्राप्त लोगों तक ही सीमित थी, जिसका मुख्य उद्देश्य औपनिवेशिक प्रशासन के हितों की सेवा करना था। इस दृष्टिकोण ने एरिट्रिया के अधिकांश लोगों को गुणवत्तापूर्ण शिक्षा तक पहुँच से बाहर कर दिया, जिससे असमानताएँ बनी रहीं।
द्वितीय विश्व युद्ध के बाद, इरिट्रिया ब्रिटिश प्रशासन के अधीन आ गया और बाद में 1952 में इथियोपिया के साथ संघबद्ध हो गया। इस अवधि के दौरान, शिक्षा के अवसर सीमित रहे और व्यापक आबादी के लिए काफी हद तक दुर्गम रहे। हालाँकि, इरिट्रियन पीपुल्स लिबरेशन फ्रंट (ई. पी. एल. एफ.) के नेतृत्व में स्वतंत्रता के लिए सशस्त्र संघर्ष ने महत्वपूर्ण बदलाव लाए। ई. पी. एल. एफ. ने भूमिगत स्कूलों की स्थापना की, जिन्हें “माहोट” के नाम से जाना जाता है, जो इरिट्रिया की पहचान, संस्कृति और भाषा के संरक्षण पर केंद्रित थे। इस आंदोलन ने एक अधिक समावेशी और सांस्कृतिक रूप से प्रासंगिक शिक्षा प्रणाली की नींव रखी।
मौजूदा चुनौतियां
शिक्षा के लिए असमान पहुंच
इरिट्रिया में सबसे अधिक दबाव वाली चुनौतियों में से एक शिक्षा तक असमान पहुंच है। भौगोलिक कारक विशेष रूप से दूरदराज के और ग्रामीण क्षेत्रों में महत्वपूर्ण बाधाएं पैदा करते हैं। सीमित बुनियादी ढांचा और परिवहन स्कूलों की स्थापना और रखरखाव में बाधा डालते हैं, जिससे बच्चों के लिए शिक्षा प्राप्त करना मुश्किल हो जाता है। उदाहरण के लिए, देश के पश्चिमी भाग में स्थित गश बरका क्षेत्र में, स्कूलों की कमी और छात्रों को स्कूल जाने के लिए लंबी दूरी की यात्रा करनी पड़ती है, जो कई बच्चों को नियमित रूप से कक्षाओं में जाने से रोकती है। इसी तरह, दक्षिणी क्षेत्र में, खानाबदोश समुदायों के बच्चों को उनकी अस्थायी जीवन शैली और उनके प्रवासी मार्गों में शैक्षिक सुविधाओं के अभाव के कारण औपचारिक शिक्षा प्राप्त करने में कठिनाइयों का सामना करना पड़ता है।
आर्थिक बाधाएं और किफायती
आर्थिक कारक शिक्षा प्रणाली में चुनौतियों को और बढ़ा देते हैं। गरीबी, विशेष रूप से ग्रामीण क्षेत्रों में प्रचलित, परिवारों के लिए वर्दी, किताबें और परिवहन लागत जैसे स्कूल से संबंधित खर्चों को वहन करना चुनौतीपूर्ण बनाता है। वित्तीय बोझ शिक्षा तक पहुंच को प्रतिबंधित करता है, कमजोर आबादी को असमान रूप से प्रभावित करता है और गरीबी और असमानता के चक्र को बनाए रखता है। उदाहरण के लिए, अंसेबा क्षेत्र में, गरीब परिवार आवश्यक शैक्षिक खर्चों को पूरा करने के लिए संघर्ष करते हैं, जिससे कम आय वाले पृष्ठभूमि के बच्चों में स्कूल छोड़ने की दर अधिक हो जाती है। इसी तरह, असमारा जैसे शहरी क्षेत्रों में, उच्च जीवन लागत परिवारों के लिए शिक्षा के लिए पर्याप्त संसाधन आवंटित करना मुश्किल बनाती है, जिससे गुणवत्तापूर्ण स्कूली शिक्षा तक पहुंच बाधित होती है।
लैंगिक असमानताएँ
इरिट्रिया को शिक्षा तक पहुंच में लैंगिक असमानताओं का सामना करना पड़ता है। गहरे जड़ वाले सांस्कृतिक मानदंड और अपेक्षाएं अक्सर लड़कियों की तुलना में लड़कों की शिक्षा को प्राथमिकता देती हैं, जिससे लड़कियों के लिए नामांकन दर कम हो जाती है। जल्दी शादी और घरेलू जिम्मेदारियां लड़कियों के शैक्षिक अवसरों को सीमित करती हैं। कुछ क्षेत्रों में प्रारंभिक विवाह प्रचलित है, जैसे कि देबब क्षेत्र, और लड़कियों को अक्सर कम उम्र में स्कूल छोड़ने के लिए मजबूर किया जाता है, जिससे उनकी शैक्षिक उन्नति में बाधा आती है। इसके अलावा, पारंपरिक लिंग भूमिकाओं की सामाजिक धारणाएं लड़कियों के सीमित शैक्षिक और कैरियर के अवसरों में योगदान करती हैं, उनकी पूरी क्षमता को बाधित करती हैं और शिक्षा में लैंगिक समानता प्राप्त करने के प्रयासों को कमजोर करती हैं।
अस्मारा में कैथोलिक कैथेड्रल का मठ एक बड़े स्कूल की मेजबानी करता है। डेविड स्टेनली द्वारा फोटो
शिक्षा की गुणवत्ता
इरिट्रिया में शिक्षा की गुणवत्ता एक महत्वपूर्ण चिंता का विषय है। योग्य शिक्षकों की अपर्याप्त संख्या, विशेष रूप से ग्रामीण क्षेत्रों में, अपर्याप्त सीखने के अनुभवों में योगदान करती है। शिक्षकों के व्यावसायिक विकास के अवसरों की कमी गुणवत्तापूर्ण निर्देश देने की उनकी क्षमता को और बाधित करती है। पाठ्यपुस्तकों, शिक्षण सामग्री और उचित बुनियादी ढांचे जैसे आवश्यक संसाधनों की अनुपस्थिति भी समग्र शिक्षण वातावरण को प्रभावित करती है। उदाहरण के लिए, मैकेल क्षेत्र में, भीड़भाड़ वाली कक्षाएं और प्रशिक्षित शिक्षकों की कमी शिक्षा की गुणवत्ता से समझौता करती है और छात्रों के सीखने के परिणामों में बाधा डालती है।
उच्च शिक्षा तक सीमित पहुंच
इरिट्रिया में उच्च शिक्षा तक पहुंच सीमित है। विश्वविद्यालयों की कमी और अत्यधिक प्रतिस्पर्धी प्रवेश प्रक्रियाएँ उन छात्रों की संख्या को सीमित करती हैं जो तृतीयक शिक्षा प्राप्त कर सकते हैं। यह सीमा एक कुशल कार्यबल के विकास को बाधित करती है और ज्ञान-आधारित अर्थव्यवस्था की दिशा में देश की प्रगति को बाधित करती है। उदाहरण के लिए, मध्य क्षेत्र में, जहां राजधानी शहर अस्मारा स्थित है, विश्वविद्यालयों में कुछ उपलब्ध स्थान उच्च शिक्षा की मांग करने वाले योग्य छात्रों की बढ़ती संख्या को समायोजित नहीं कर सकते हैं, जिससे तृतीयक शिक्षा के अवसरों की मांग और आपूर्ति के बीच एक महत्वपूर्ण अंतर पैदा हो जाता है।
निष्कर्ष
इरिट्रिया में शैक्षिक चुनौतियां ऐतिहासिक कारकों में गहराई से निहित हैं और वर्तमान मुद्दों से जटिल हैं। असमान पहुंच, आर्थिक बाधाएं, लैंगिक असमानताएं, शिक्षा की खराब गुणवत्ता और उच्च शिक्षा तक सीमित पहुंच देश की शिक्षा प्रणाली के विकास और प्रगति में बाधा बनी हुई है। इन चुनौतियों पर तत्काल ध्यान देने और व्यापक समाधान की आवश्यकता है। अंतर्निहित कारणों को संबोधित करके, बुनियादी ढांचे में निवेश करके, लैंगिक समानता को बढ़ावा देकर और शिक्षा की गुणवत्ता में सुधार करके, इरिट्रिया एक अधिक समावेशी और प्रभावी शिक्षा प्रणाली का मार्ग प्रशस्त कर सकता है जो अपने नागरिकों को सशक्त बनाता है और देश के दीर्घकालिक विकास लक्ष्यों का समर्थन करता है।
अफगानिस्तान के दुर्गम और सांस्कृतिक रूप से विविध परिदृश्य में, शिक्षा हमेशा दृढ़ता, संकल्प और आशा के धागों से बुनी एक जटिल संरचना रही है। दशकों के संघर्ष, राजनीतिक उथल-पुथल, और आर्थिक अस्थिरता के बावजूद, ज्ञान की तलाश अफगान लोगों के दिलों में संभावनाओं की एक ज्योति प्रज्वलित करती रहती है। हालाँकि, अफगानिस्तान में शिक्षा की राह कई चुनौतियों से भरी हुई है, जो इसे साकार करने में गंभीर बाधाएँ उत्पन्न करती हैं। इस लेख में, हम उन गहन शैक्षिक चुनौतियों पर प्रकाश डालते हैं जिन्होंने अफगानिस्तान को त्रस्त किया है, उन प्रणालीगत मुद्दों पर प्रकाश डालते हुए जिन्होंने प्रगति में बाधा डाली है और देश के भविष्य के लिए दूरगामी परिणामों की जांच की है। शैक्षिक परिदृश्य की जटिलताओं को समझकर, हम अफगान छात्रों के लिए एक उज्जवल भविष्य की दिशा में मार्ग प्रशस्त करने के लिए आवश्यक संभावित समाधानों और हस्तक्षेपों को उजागर कर सकते हैं।
ऐतिहासिक पृष्ठभूमि अफगानिस्तान में शिक्षा का इतिहास देश की समृद्ध सांस्कृतिक विरासत और सदियों से इसके संघर्षों के साथ गहराई से जुड़ा हुआ है। शिक्षा को लंबे समय से अफगान समाज की आधारशिला के रूप में महत्व दिया गया है, प्रारंभिक रिकॉर्ड 11वीं शताब्दी तक शैक्षणिक संस्थानों के अस्तित्व का संकेत देते हैं। इस्लामी स्कूल, जिन्हें मदरसों के रूप में जाना जाता है, ने धार्मिक अध्ययन और अरबी भाषा पढ़ाने में महत्वपूर्ण भूमिका निभाई। 20वीं शताब्दी के दौरान, आधुनिकीकरण और सुधारों की एक लहर ने एक औपचारिक शिक्षा प्रणाली स्थापित करने की मांग की, जिसमें धर्मनिरपेक्ष स्कूलों और विश्वविद्यालयों की शुरुआत की गई।[1] हालाँकि, सोवियत आक्रमण, गृह युद्ध और तालिबान शासन सहित दशकों के संघर्ष ने शैक्षिक परिदृश्य को गंभीर रूप से बाधित कर दिया। स्कूलों को नष्ट कर दिया गया, शिक्षकों को विस्थापित कर दिया गया और शिक्षा तक पहुंच सीमित हो गई, विशेष रूप से लड़कियों के लिए।[2] शैक्षिक कठिनाइयाँ
लैंगिक विषमता जैसा कि ऊपर उल्लेख किया गया है, अफगानिस्तान में शिक्षा क्षेत्र के सामने सबसे अधिक दबाव वाली चुनौतियों में से एक व्यापक लैंगिक असमानता है। सांस्कृतिक मानदंडों और गहरी सामाजिक बाधाओं के कारण लड़कियों को स्कूलों से बाहर कर दिया गया है, जिससे उन्हें शिक्षा की परिवर्तनकारी शक्ति तक पहुंच से वंचित कर दिया गया है।[3]
अफगानिस्तान में तालिबान शासन के दौरान, जो 1996 से 2001 तक चला, लड़कियों के लिए शिक्षा तक पहुंच गंभीर रूप से प्रतिबंधित थी और कई मामलों में, पूरी तरह से इनकार कर दिया गया था। तालिबान ने इस्लामी कानून की एक सख्त व्याख्या लागू की, जिसमें लड़कियों की शिक्षा को लक्षित करने वाली दमनकारी नीतियों की एक श्रृंखला लागू की गई। लड़कियों को स्कूलों में जाने से मना किया गया था, और लड़कियों के लिए शैक्षणिक संस्थानों को व्यवस्थित रूप से बंद कर दिया गया था या अन्य उपयोगों के लिए पुनर्निर्मित किया गया था। शिक्षा से वंचित होने से लड़कियां अपने मौलिक अधिकारों से वंचित हो गईं और निरक्षरता और उनके भविष्य के लिए सीमित अवसरों का एक चक्र बना रहा। तालिबान की प्रतिबंधात्मक नीतियों ने औपचारिक स्कूली शिक्षा को प्रभावित किया और व्यावसायिक प्रशिक्षण और उच्च शिक्षा तक महिलाओं की पहुंच को सीमित कर दिया। तालिबान शासन के दौरान लड़कियों की शिक्षा पर इन प्रतिबंधों का हानिकारक प्रभाव सभी अफगान बच्चों के लिए शैक्षिक अवसरों और लैंगिक समानता सुनिश्चित करने के लिए चल रहे प्रयासों की तत्काल आवश्यकता को रेखांकित करता है।[4]
तालिबान शासन के पतन के बाद, लड़कियों की शिक्षा में सुधार करने में महत्वपूर्ण प्रगति हुई है। एक नई सरकार की स्थापना और अंतर्राष्ट्रीय संगठनों के समर्थन से लैंगिक समानता को बढ़ावा देने और शिक्षा तक पहुंच बढ़ाने के लिए एक ठोस प्रयास किया गया है। जो स्कूल पहले बंद कर दिए गए थे या नष्ट कर दिए गए थे, उन्हें फिर से खोल दिया गया है और देश भर में नए शैक्षणिक संस्थान स्थापित किए गए हैं। कई पहलों ने लड़कियों के नामांकन और प्रतिधारण दर को बढ़ाने, सुरक्षित सीखने का वातावरण सुनिश्चित करने और संसाधन और बुनियादी ढांचा प्रदान करने पर ध्यान केंद्रित किया है। गैर सरकारी संगठनों और अंतर्राष्ट्रीय भागीदारों के सहयोग से, अफगान सरकार ने लड़कियों की शिक्षा में बाधा डालने वाली सांस्कृतिक बाधाओं और भेदभावपूर्ण प्रथाओं को दूर करने के लिए नीतियों को लागू किया है। इसके परिणामस्वरूप, लाखों लड़कियों को स्कूल जाने, उच्च शिक्षा प्राप्त करने और अपने क्षितिज को व्यापक बनाने का अवसर मिला है। तालिबान शासन के पतन के बाद से अफगानिस्तान में लड़कियों के लिए शिक्षा तक बेहतर पहुंच महिलाओं को सशक्त बनाने, लैंगिक समानता बढ़ाने और देश के सामाजिक और आर्थिक विकास को बढ़ावा देने की दिशा में एक महत्वपूर्ण कदम है।[5]
हालाँकि, तालिबान के अधिग्रहण के बाद अफगानिस्तान में लड़कियों के लिए वर्तमान स्थिति गहरी चिंता और अनिश्चितता का विषय है। तालिबान की सत्ता में वापसी ने लड़कियों की शिक्षा में कड़ी मेहनत से प्राप्त लाभ के संभावित रोलबैक के बारे में आशंकाओं को बढ़ा दिया है। जबकि तालिबान नेतृत्व ने संकेत देते हुए बयान दिए हैं कि वे इस्लामी कानून की अपनी व्याख्या के ढांचे के भीतर लड़कियों को शिक्षा प्राप्त करने की अनुमति देंगे, इसे किस हद तक बरकरार रखा जाएगा, यह अनिश्चित है। विभिन्न क्षेत्रों की रिपोर्टों से संकेत मिलता है कि लड़कियों को शिक्षा में बाधाओं का सामना करना पड़ता है, स्कूलों के बंद होने या इस्लामी शिक्षा केंद्रों में परिवर्तित होने की रिपोर्ट के साथ। इसके अतिरिक्त, महिला छात्रों की सुरक्षा के बारे में चिंताएं हैं, क्योंकि तालिबान का पिछला शासन महिलाओं के अधिकारों और शिक्षा पर प्रतिबंधों के लिए कुख्यात था। अंतर्राष्ट्रीय समुदाय, स्थानीय कार्यकर्ताओं और संगठनों के साथ, स्थिति की बारीकी से निगरानी कर रहा है और लड़कियों के शिक्षा के अधिकारों की रक्षा की वकालत कर रहा है, जो पहले से ही काफी प्रतिबंधित है।[6]
गरीबी से जुड़े मुद्दे
इसके अलावा, गरीबी और सीमित संसाधन अफगानिस्तान में शैक्षिक चुनौतियों को और बढ़ा देते हैं। अपर्याप्त धन, बुनियादी ढांचे की कमी और अपर्याप्त शिक्षक प्रशिक्षण प्रदान की जाने वाली शिक्षा की गुणवत्ता में बाधा डालते हैं। कई स्कूल भीड़भाड़ वाली कक्षाओं में काम करते हैं, जिनमें बुनियादी सुविधाओं और सीखने की सामग्री की कमी होती है। इसके अतिरिक्त, बाल श्रम की व्यापक व्यापकता और बच्चों को अपने परिवार की आय में योगदान करने की आवश्यकता शिक्षा तक उनकी पहुंच को और बाधित करती है।
गुणवत्तापूर्ण स्कूलों और शैक्षिक संसाधनों तक सीमित पहुंच एक महत्वपूर्ण बाधा है जिसका सामना गरीब समुदायों को करना पड़ता है। कई परिवार अपने बच्चों की शिक्षा में निवेश करने की तो बात ही छोड़िए, जरूरतों को पूरा करने के लिए संघर्ष करते हैं। नतीजतन, बाल श्रम और प्रारंभिक विवाह अक्सर स्कूली शिक्षा के विकल्प बन जाते हैं। इसके अतिरिक्त, देश के कुछ क्षेत्रों में व्यापक असुरक्षा और संघर्ष से शैक्षिक सुविधाओं को खतरा है और उपस्थिति को हतोत्साहित किया जाता है। ये चुनौतियां उच्च निरक्षरता दर में योगदान करती हैं और गरीबी के चक्र को बनाए रखती हैं, जिससे सामाजिक-आर्थिक उन्नति के अवसर सीमित हो जाते हैं। अफगानिस्तान में गरीबी से संबंधित अकादमिक चुनौतियों का समाधान करने के लिए एक व्यापक दृष्टिकोण की आवश्यकता है जिसमें लक्षित हस्तक्षेप, शिक्षा में निवेश में वृद्धि और कमजोर समुदायों को सामाजिक सहायता का प्रावधान शामिल है।[7]
अंत में, अफगानिस्तान में लैंगिक असमानता और गरीबी से संबंधित शैक्षिक चुनौतियां गहराई से जुड़ी हुई हैं और एक अधिक न्यायसंगत और समृद्ध समाज प्राप्त करने में महत्वपूर्ण बाधाएं पैदा करती हैं। गरीबी और लैंगिक भेदभाव का प्रतिच्छेदन एक दुष्चक्र को कायम रखता है जहाँ गरीब पृष्ठभूमि की लड़कियों और महिलाओं को गुणवत्तापूर्ण शिक्षा तक पहुँचने में कई बाधाओं का सामना करना पड़ता है। ये चुनौतियां न केवल उनके व्यक्तिगत विकास में बाधा डालती हैं बल्कि राष्ट्र की समग्र प्रगति और विकास को भी बाधित करती हैं। इन चुनौतियों से निपटने के प्रयासों के लिए एक समग्र दृष्टिकोण की आवश्यकता होती है जो गरीबी, लैंगिक असमानता और शैक्षिक बाधाओं से एक साथ निपटता है। समावेशी और सुलभ शिक्षा में निवेश करके, लड़कियों और महिलाओं को सशक्त बनाकर और हाशिए पर पड़े समुदायों को सामाजिक-आर्थिक सहायता प्रदान करके, अफगानिस्तान अपने सभी नागरिकों के लिए एक उज्जवल भविष्य को बढ़ावा देते हुए गरीबी और लैंगिक असमानता के चक्र को तोड़ सकता है। ठोस और निरंतर प्रयासों के माध्यम से, अफगानिस्तान इन चुनौतियों को दूर कर सकता है और यह सुनिश्चित कर सकता है कि लिंग या सामाजिक-आर्थिक पृष्ठभूमि की परवाह किए बिना प्रत्येक बच्चे को गुणवत्तापूर्ण शिक्षा प्राप्त करने और अपनी क्षमता को पूरा करने का समान अवसर मिले।
संदर्भ सूची
बैज़ा, वाई. (2013). अफगानिस्तान में शिक्षा: 1901 से विकास, प्रभाव और विरासत. रूटलेज.
ख्वाजामीर, एम. (2016). अफगानिस्तान में शिक्षा का इतिहास और समस्याएं. SHS वेब ऑफ कॉन्फ्रेंस (वॉल्यूम 26, पृष्ठ 01124). EDP साइंसेज.
मशवानी, एच. यू. (2017). अफगानिस्तान में महिला शिक्षा: अवसर और चुनौतियां. इंटरनेशनल जर्नल फॉर इनोवेटिव रिसर्च इन मल्टीडिसिप्लिनरी फील्ड, 3(11).
अहमद, एस. (2012). तालिबान और पाकिस्तान तथा अफगानिस्तान में लड़कियों की शिक्षा – स्वात जिला पर एक केस स्टडी के साथ.
अल्वी-अज़ीज़, एच. (2008). पोस्ट-तालिबान अफगानिस्तान में महिलाओं की शिक्षा पर एक प्रगति रिपोर्ट. इंटरनेशनल जर्नल ऑफ लाइफलॉन्ग एजुकेशन, 27(2), 169-178.
अमीरी, आर., और जैक्सन, ए. (2021). तालिबान के दृष्टिकोण और नीतियां शिक्षा के प्रति. ODI सेंटर फॉर द स्टडी ऑफ आर्म्ड ग्रुप्स.
ओचिलोव, ए. ओ., और नजीबुल्लाह, ई. (2021, अप्रैल). अफगानिस्तान में गरीबी कैसे कम करें. ई-कॉन्फ्रेंस ग्लोब (पृष्ठ 114-117).
[1] ख्वाजामीर, एम. (2016). अफगानिस्तान में शिक्षा का इतिहास और समस्याएं. SHS वेब ऑफ कॉन्फ्रेंस (वॉल्यूम 26, पृष्ठ 01124). EDP साइंसेज।
[2] बैज़ा, वाई. (2013). अफगानिस्तान में शिक्षा: 1901 से विकास, प्रभाव और विरासत. रूटलेज।
[3] मशवानी, एच. यू. (2017). अफगानिस्तान में महिला शिक्षा: अवसर और चुनौतियां. इंटरनेशनल जर्नल फॉर इनोवेटिव रिसर्च इन मल्टीडिसिप्लिनरी फील्ड, 3(11)।
[4] अहमद, एस. (2012). तालिबान और पाकिस्तान तथा अफगानिस्तान में लड़कियों की शिक्षा – स्वात जिला पर एक केस स्टडी के साथ।
[5] अल्वी-अज़ीज़, एच. (2008). पोस्ट-तालिबान अफगानिस्तान में महिलाओं की शिक्षा पर एक प्रगति रिपोर्ट. इंटरनेशनल जर्नल ऑफ लाइफलॉन्ग एजुकेशन, 27(2), 169-178।
Academic freedom in Zimbabwe is currently at one of its lowest levels in history. Regionally, the country also ranks as having one of the lowest academic freedom index in sub-Saharan Africa (Academic Freedom Index, 2024). As a cornerstone for democratic and free societies, it is essential that students and scholars can pursue education, research and knowledge without the fear of repercussion. However, in Zimbabwe, academic freedom remains precarious, constrained by political interference, economic hardships, and legal ambiguities. This has profound implications for both human rights and education, as the suppression of academic freedom not only limits individual expression but also undermines the development of a society that values knowledge, critical thinking, and innovation.
A Historical Context of Suppression
Zimbabwe’s struggle with academic freedom has deep historical roots, tracing back to its colonial past. During the era of British colonial rule, the government employed various strategies to control academic discourse, including surveillance and deportation of academics deemed subversive (Mushawatu, 2023). This tactic continued post-independence, with the government of Robert Mugabe using similar methods to silence critics and maintain control. A major way in which Mugabe curtailed academic freedom was though the University of Zimbabwe Amendment Act of 1990, which reduced democratic freedom within universities, and made Mugabe officially the chancellor of all state universities in the country (Mashininga and Mukeredzi, 2019).
Since Mugabe’s ousting in the 2017 coup, academic freedom has continued to decline. In the last 7 years, deportation has resurfaced as a tool for stifling academic inquiry. This can be seen in case of the Good Governance in Africa (GGA) researchers being deported in 2023. These researchers, intending to study the political landscape around the critical August elections, were barred entry into the country (Mushawatu, 2023). This example illustrates a broader trend of how the current Zimbabwean government considers academic scrutiny as a threat, and not as an opportunity for greater societal freedom. This alarming use state power to limit academic freedom has far reaching consequences and without change, will continue to tarnish the right to education and freedom of opinion in Zimbabwe.
Legal and Constitutional Ambiguities
Zimbabwe’s constitution, which was adopted in 2013, clearly outlines fundamental rights regarding education and its protection as well as academic freedom. Section 75 of the constitution explicitly mentions the right to education, and that every citizen and permanent resident of Zimbabwe should have access to it (Zimbabwe Lawyers for Human Rights, 2019). Section 61 enshrines the right to freedom of expression, including the freedom of scientific research and creativity, however, Section 62 conversely restricts the right to access information for citizens and permanent residents only (Zimbabwe 2013 Constitution, 2013). This contradictory legal framework creates a loophole that allows the government to restrict foreign researchers’ activities under the guise of legal compliance (Mushawatu, 2023).
This legal ambiguity poses a significant threat to academic freedom, as it gives the government power to exclude foreign academics from participating in research on public institutions. This therefore restricts diverse opinion and discourse, and greater research on governance, human rights, and development in Zimbabwe. By limiting access to information and deporting researchers, the government not only contravenes the spirit of academic freedom but also undermines the pursuit of transparency and accountability.
Impact on Education and Human Rights
The suppression of academic freedom in Zimbabwe extends beyond the academic community, affecting the broader education system and society at large. Education is a fundamental human right, essential for the fruition of other rights and for the empowerment of individuals and communities. When academic freedom is curtailed, the quality of education suffers, as does the ability of students and scholars to engage critically with societal issues.
In Zimbabwe, the interference in academia illustrates a broader symptom of a culture of government suppression of opinion. In 2020, the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) voiced concern over allegations that the authorities in Zimbabwe may have used the COVID-19 pandemic to limit freedom of expression and the right to peacefully assemble (UN News, 2020). While health workers were protesting for better working conditions and salaries, violent force was used against them, with many being arbitrarily arrested, including some journalists and members of the opposition party (UN News, 2020).
The recent elections further highlight a system that is suppressing human rights, political opposition and a peaceful democratic process. Although there were 11 candidates for the presidential campaign, the competition was seen as a contest between two main leaders. The first being Coalition of Change (CCC) leader Nelson Chamisa, and the second being Emmerson Mnangagwa, from the governing Zimbabwe African National Union – Patriotic Front (Zanu-PF) party (Nyoka, 2023). The Zanu-PF party has been in power since Zimbabwe’s independence and while they did oust Mugabe in 2017, many human rights advocates, such as Amnesty International and Human Rights watch have argued that little has changed politically (Nyoka, 2023). During the campaigning, CCC activist, Tapfumaneyi Masaya was kidnapped and murdered while another member of the party, lawmaker Takudzwa Ngadziore, was abducted and tortured (The Guardian, 2023). Chamisa later resigned, citing Zanu-PF infiltration of the CCC and corruption as the reason for his decision, ultimately leading Mnangagwa and the Zanu-PF party to victory (BBC News, 2024).
Parallels with Broader Human Rights Issues
The situation of academic freedom in Zimbabwe is reflective of broader human rights challenges in the country. Freedom House classifies Zimbabwe as “not free”, highlighting issues such as restrictions on freedom of speech, assembly, and the press (Freedom House, 2024). The suppression of academic freedom is part of this broader pattern of limiting civil liberties, which is characteristic of authoritarian regimes that prioritise control and power over openness and accountability. Therefore, Zimbabwe’s repression of academic freedom represents an assault on the right to education. In these contexts, education is not merely a victim of conflict and authoritarianism but a critical battleground where the struggle for rights, justice, and democracy plays out.
The Way Forward
To improve academic freedom in Zimbabwe, there must be a commitment to broader political and legal reforms. This includes revising the constitution and Zimbabwe’s legal framework, to provide unequivocal protection for academic freedom, including the rights of foreign researchers. Furthermore, the Zanu-PF government must recognise the value of academic freedom as a vital component of a thriving, democratic society and take steps to ensure that universities can operate free from political interference. If that is not possible, then the international community, including academic institutions, human rights organisations, and governments, should continue to condemn and act against infringements on academic freedom. By advocating for academic freedom in Zimbabwe, the global fight for the protection of education and human rights will be strengthened.
Escrito por Joan Vilalta Flo, traduzido por Juliana Campos.
Cabo Verde é um país localizado a 500 quilômetros da costa do Senegal, na África. Trata-se de um arquipélago de dez ilhas, a maioria das quais é habitada, com a maior parte da população concentrada na capital, Praia. Sua língua oficial é o Português, herança da colonização pelos portugueses. Entretanto, embora Cabo Verde tenha obtido sua independência em 1975, muitos habitantes falam o crioulo cabo-verdiano como língua principal. O país está situado em um cenário geográfico desafiador: seu território fragmentado torna a prestação de serviços básicos complicada, é uma área propensa à seca e há poucos recursos naturais. No entanto, Cabo Verde tem sido elogiado mundialmente por sua notável estabilidade política e estratégias de redução da pobreza, o que também possibilitou melhorias na prestação de serviços, incluindo a educação.
Crianças fazem fila em escola Cabo-verdiana. Foto por: Duncan CV via Wikimedia Commons.
As mais recentes melhorias na educação cabo-verdiana foram alcançadas graças ao Plano Estratégico da Educação 2017-2021, que visa atingir o 4º Objetivo de Desenvolvimento Sustentável da ONU (Educação de Qualidade) e concentra-se nos seguintes pilares: (i) acesso universal à educação pré-primária (pré-escola) para todas as crianças com idades entre 4 e 5 anos, incluindo aquelas com necessidades especiais; (ii) melhor articulação da educação pré-primária com a educação básica, de modo que todos os alunos recebam dois anos de educação pré-primária; e (iii) acesso igualitário à educação universal gratuita até o 8º ano por meio da implementação de planos de ação social para escolas, visando grupos prioritários e fornecendo educação especial para todos.i
Assim, Cabo Verde tem progressivamente melhorado o acesso à educação primária e secundária. A taxa de escolarização atingiu 92,4% em 2021, e a taxa de alfabetização alcançou 88,5% em 2019, com a maioria dos habitantes acima dos 15 anos alfabetizados.ii Os gastos do governo com educação passaram de 23,3% do orçamento total em 2020 para 24,09% em 2021.iii Em termos de infraestrutura, 97,6% das escolas primárias e secundárias em Cabo Verde têm acesso à água, e 89% estão conectadas à rede elétrica pública. O Plano Estratégico da Educação 2017-2021 permitiu a implementação de programas de aprimoramento, como o programa Educação de Excelência, para o qual foram alocados cerca de 93,2 milhões de dólares americanos em 2020; enquanto 6,4 milhões de dólares foram destinados a bolsas de estudo..iv
A pandemia de Covid-19 trouxe muitas dificuldades para a economia centrada no turismo de Cabo Verde. No entanto, o país foi bastante ágil e eficaz na gestão da crise e na vacinação da maioria da população.v Na área da educação, o país também agiu prontamente. Em 2020, Cabo Verde recebeu um subsídio de 750.000 dólares do GPE (Parceria Global para a Educação), o que contribuiu substancialmente para a formação de professores em ensino à distância, fornecimento de material didático, acesso à televisão em áreas remotas e instalações sanitárias adequadas.vi Após o fechamento das escolas, o Ministério da Educação implementou o programa “Aprender e Estudar em Casa”, com o objetivo de possibilitar aulas dadas através do rádio, da televisão e de tablets, tendo em vista que entre 30% a 40% das famílias ainda não tinham acesso a essas tecnologias. O programa também possibilitou a ampliação da área de cobertura da televisão digital e melhorou a qualidade do sinal.vii Apesar de tudo isso, é importante observar que, atualmente, não há evidências da existência de uma estratégia abrangente de adaptação ao contexto pós-Covid-19 em Cabo Verde.
Vale mencionar um recente avanço na educação cabo-verdiana: a ratificação da Convenção Contra a Discriminação na Educação, determinada em 5 de outubro de 2022 e oficialmente implementada em 5 de janeiro de 2023. Embora os efeitos da aplicação da Convenção ainda estejam por ser vistos, a aprovação do documento alinha o país às recomendações feitas na última sessão da Revisão Periódica Universal (RPU) das Nações Unidas.viii
Entretanto, apesar dos avanços mencionados, a desigualdade, a discriminação nas escolas, a falta de infraestrutura e de qualidade de ensino continuam visíveis em Cabo Verde. Esses são alguns dos problemas que o arquipélago precisará enfrentar e resolver nos próximos anos. As seções a seguir tratam das principais áreas a serem alvo de intervenção.
Desigualdades na Educação
Cabo Verde enfrenta um grande desafio relacionado aos custos “ocultos” da educação, pois, embora o Ensino Fundamental (até o 8º ano) seja gratuito e obrigatório,ix há uma série de custos adicionais como transporte, refeições e materiais escolares, custos que são significativos para famílias de baixa renda.x Este fator é um dos causadores da desigualdade no acesso à educação de qualidade para famílias pobres. Além disso, o Ensino Médio e o Ensino Superior ainda requerem mensalidades (embora autoridades tenham manifestado a intenção de tornar gratuito Ensino Médio, do 9º ao 12º ano),xi perpetuando a desigualdade educacional com base no nível econômico de cada família. Adiciona-se a isso a desigualdade entre famílias que vivem em áreas rurais e as que vivem em espaços urbanos.xii As famílias de áreas rurais têm menos acesso à educação devido ao poder econômico geralmente mais baixo e à falta de acesso às tecnologias e à internet, dado o seu alto custo (especialmente relevante durante a pandemia de Covid-19)..xiii
Quanto ao Ensino Superior, embora tenham sido feitos esforços para um fornecimento mais amplo, a taxa de escolarização entre 2019-2020 foi de 23,5%, 37 pontos percentuais abaixo dos anos finais do Ensino Fundamental, indicando uma barreira no acesso ao Ensino Superior.xiv Um dos desafios que contribuem para essa realidade é o cenário geográfico de Cabo Verde; tratando-se de um arquipélago, proporcionar um Ensino Superior acessível a todas as áreas é uma tarefa extremamente complexa. Apenas as ilhas de Santiago e São Vicente xv possuem instituições de Ensino Superior. A dificuldade de acesso à essas instituições, juntamente ao fato de o Ensino Superior não ser gratuito, gera pouco incentivo para estudantes que vivem em áreas remotas e têm menor poder econômico..xvi
Há também desigualdade linguística. Enquanto para a maioria população cabo-verdiana a primeira língua é o Crioulo Cabo-verdiano (CCV), o Português ainda é a única língua oficial e a língua de ensino, fato que afeta os estudantes que têm exposição limitada a essa língua, especialmente aqueles que vivem em áreas rurais e locais remotos, geralmente membros de famílias de baixa renda. Esses alunos enfrentam maiores dificuldades e uma desvantagem de aprendizado. Embora alguns programas de educação bilíngue tenham sido redigidos, a implementação dessas iniciativas é insuficiente, frágil e carece de respaldo político e econômico. Essa desigualdade também representa uma desconexão entre os sistemas formais de educação e a sociedade; políticas direcionadas para preencher essa lacuna inevitavelmente contribuirão também para a construção de identidade e coesão social.xvii
Finalmente, apesar dos objetivos expressos no Plano Estratégico de Educação 2017-2021, como melhorar o acesso e a qualidade da educação para estudantes com deficiência (17,5% da população possui pelo menos um tipo de deficiência),xviii e ampliar a capacitação de profissionais com o auxílio da UNICEF, xix a implementação prática de estratégias inclusivas para esses estudantes tem sido insatisfatória. Muitas pessoas com deficiência não têm acesso à educação, não recebem os benefícios necessários para frequentar a escola e as infraestruturas e tecnologias educacionais, em grande parte, não são adaptadas a elas..xx
No que diz respeito à igualdade de gênero, bons resultados foram alcançados na educação pré-escolar e no ensino fundamental: o índice de paridade foi de 0,98 e 0,93, respectivamente, demonstrando uma presença ligeiramente maior de meninos nas escolas. No entanto, o desafio permanece nos níveis de ensino médio e superior, nos quais a representação feminina é significativamente maior, com índices de paridade de 1,2 para o ensino médio e 1,5 para o ensino superior. Incentivos para atrair meninos e homens nesses setores são necessários para garantir a igualdade..xxi E, embora haja uma maior presença feminina no Ensino Médio e Superior, a taxa de alfabetização de homens é atualmente quase 10% maior do que a taxa feminina, o que evidencia uma defasagem de ensino de meninas e mulheres também. xxii
Apesar da melhoria significativa graças à introdução de um módulo dedicado aos estudos de gênero no currículo do ensino médio, os currículos ainda contêm estereótipos discriminatórios em relação às mulheres, o que é refletido na sub-representação feminina em campos de estudo normalmente dominados por homens, como na área tecnológica.xxiii Além disso, embora as questões de gênero estejam presentes nos currículos, a educação sexual deixa a desejar. Apesar de ser reconhecido como importante para o desenvolvimento e segurança dos estudantes, o Guia de Orientação Sexual nas Escolas, desenvolvido com a ajuda do UNFPA (Fundo de População das Nações Unidas), beneficiou poucos estudantes devido a falta de interesse público e a à sensibilidade do tema. Um módulo mais abrangente de educação sexual ainda está para ser implementado de forma eficaz em Cabo Vede.xxiv
É importante observar que não foi possível encontrar dados sobre minorias com base na orientação sexual ou identificação de gênero em Cabo Verde; da mesma forma, não foram encontrados mecanismos de proteção para tais minorias ou estratégias de educação sobre o assunto. Apesar de ser um tópico sensível e atualmente invisível estatisticamente, avanços nessa área podem ser positivos para garantir que todos os estudantes sejam livres e desfrutem de tratamento igualitário por parte de colegas e equipe.
A Qualidade de Ensino
É necessário realizar melhorias não apenas na oferta de Ensino Superior, mas também em sua qualidade. O Ensino Superior em Cabo Verde é relativamente recente, criado nos últimos 20 anos. Considerando que ainda está em seus estágios iniciais, o setor carece de níveis mínimos de qualidade: embora a recém-criada Agência Reguladora do Ensino Superior (ARES) esteja começando a realizar avaliações para melhorar o desempenho do setor, xxv autoridades ainda precisam construir um sistema abrangente de medição da qualidade do ensino e mecanismos para alinhar o conteúdo com os objetivos e necessidades nacionais, e garantir o acesso a material educacional, bem como o acesso às tecnologias.xxvi
Adicionalmente, embora cerca de 76% das crianças atualmente tenham acesso à pré-escola, existem diferenças regionais, com áreas que apresentam percentagens ainda mais baixas. A educação na primeira infância e na pré-escola foram focos do Plano Estratégico de Educação 2017-2021, mas, na prática, foram amplamente negligenciadas. Ainda falta a implementação de mecanismos legais adequados para garantir o acesso universal, obrigatório e gratuito à pré-escola. O orçamento atual é de cerca de 0,3% do capital do Estado e a qualificação profissional dos professores de pré-escola é insuficiente (apenas 30% possuem a qualificação necessária).xxvii Além disso, não há acesso suficiente à ferramentas tecnológicas nessas instituições, adicionado à falta de capacitação dos professores em TIC (Tecnologias da Informação e Comunicação).xxviii
Um dos principais problemas do setor educacional de Cabo Verde é a qualidade de ensino, refletida nas baixas taxas de desempenho no ensino fundamental. Na área de linguagem, 6 em cada 10 crianças demonstraram grande dificuldade ou incapacidade de interpretar as regras básicas de funcionamento da língua xxix, e na área de matemática, uma média de apenas 2,85% das crianças obteve sucesso nos principais assuntos abordados.xxx Apesar dessas estatísticas, o país ainda não implementou um sistema nacional abrangente para medir os resultados de aprendizagem em qualquer nível de educação. xxxi
Quanto ao acesso à tecnologia, embora a maioria das escolas esteja conectada à rede elétrica pública e o Plano Estratégico de Educação de 2017-2021 tenha permitido a incorporação de mais ferramentas tecnológicas e um currículo mais robusto em habilidades de TIC, apenas 17% das escolas têm acesso à internet.xxxi Isso ocorre mesmo considerando que Cabo Verde possui uma das maiores taxas de acesso na África. O problema está no custo para se conectar, um dos mais altos do mundo. O acesso à internet ainda é considerado caro para grande parte da população, especialmente para aqueles com menor renda, gerando desigualdades também nesse aspecto. xxxiii
Conclusão e Recomendações
Como conclusão, algumas recomendações tendo em mente os principais desafios do sistema educacional em Cabo Verde são oferecidas em nome da Broken Chalk.
Quanto aos custos ocultos da educação, o governo poderia reduzi-los fornecendo acesso gratuito (ou de baixo custo) a transporte, material e serviços nutricionais, com atenção especial às famílias de baixa renda e aos estudantes que vivem em áreas rurais remotas.
Sobre a cobertura educacional e a oferta universal, o governo deve agir de acordo com os objetivos traçados e continuar a estender a educação gratuita, acessível e obrigatória para os anos pré-escolares e para o ensino superior, com atenção especial às famílias de baixa renda. Mais especificamente em relação ao Ensino Superior, seria positivo gerar campanhas de incentivo para aumentar a taxa de escolarização, especialmente para os homens; juntamente com a expansão da presença de instituições de ensino superior em todos os territórios, garantindo melhor acesso à universidade para aqueles em áreas mais isoladas.
Seria desejável implementar programas nacionais para superar a desigualdade gerada pela barreira linguística. A Língua Cabo-verdiana deve estar presente em todas as etapas da educação e deve-se garantir que alunos com menor exposição ao Português não fiquem para trás. As iniciativas de educação bilíngue devem ser aprimoradas por meio de equipes multidisciplinares que incluam membros da comunidade local que compreendam as necessidades específicas de linguagem da região.
Para promover uma maior inclusão, o governo e demais autoridades deveriam considerar tornar a infraestrutura educacional, os currículos e o corpo docente mais sensíveis e adaptáveis aos estudantes com deficiência ou com necessidades especiais. Deve-se fornecer acesso adequado a edifícios, material educacional inclusivo e treinamento voltado a todos os educadores, com o objetivo de garantir o acesso e a igualdade para esses alunos.
Quando a questões de gênero, os programas e políticas educacionais devem continuar a assegurar o acesso de meninas e mulheres à educação em todos os níveis. Assim, buscar alcançar uma maior igualdade nas taxas de alfabetização, trabalhando continuamente para eliminar estereótipos de gênero e incentivando a presença de mulheres em campos de estudo tradicionalmente dominados por homens. Adicionalmente, seria positivo implementar um programa sobre sexualidade no Ensino Fundamental, para garantir a segurança e saúde dos estudantes e eliminar estereótipos prejudiciais à diversidade com base na orientação sexual.
Uma maneira eficaz de melhorar a qualidade da educação poderia ser a implementação de um sistema nacional de avaliação e análise da qualidade do ensino para garantir uma oferta adequada de conteúdo em todas as etapas educacionais e identificar deficiências na qualidade do ensino, especialmente nas áreas de linguagem e matemática no Ensino Fundamental. Juntamente com a avaliação adequada e análise do desempenho dos alunos, modos ineficazes de ensino seriam mais facilmente identificados, permitindo inovações e o alinhamento dos currículos às necessidades da sociedade cabo-verdiana, preparando melhor os alunos para o mercado de trabalho. Da mesma forma, o governo e as instituições educacionais devem continuar garantindo que todos os professores sejam qualificados para fornecer uma educação adequada ao nível que lhes é atribuído. Isso deve ser aplicado especialmente nos anos pré-escolares, nos quais a maioria dos professores não possui a devida qualificação.
Por fim, diante dos eventos recentes e em vista dos desenvolvimentos globais futuros, é essencial garantir um maior acesso a ferramentas tecnológicas para fins educacionais, tanto para escolas quanto para famílias, além de facilitar o acesso à internet. Essa democratização é crucial considerando o papel das tecnologias no mercado de trabalho global. É igualmente importante criar metodologias de educação flexíveis e adaptáveis, especialmente em um país onde a acessibilidade geográfica ao ambiente escolar é tão complexa.
xiii Patrício, M. R., & Moreno, C. (2021). Digital technologies in preschool education: a study with Cape Verdean educators. In Proceedings of the 14th annual International Conference of Education, Research and Innovation (ICERI2021) (pp. 8403-8407). IATED. ; Cabo Verde National Commission for UNESCO. (2022). National Review of the Implementation of SDG 4. Retrieved from: https://transformingeducationsummit.sdg4education2030.org/system/files/2022-09/CaboVerde-NC%20report%20.pdf
xv Ferreira, E. S., & Loureiro, S. M. C. (2021). Challenges of a small insular developing state: Cape Verde. Revista de Estudios e Investigación en Psicología y Educación, (1), 125-134.
xvi Resende-Santos, J. (2021). Education for development in Africa: Rethinking higher education in Cabo Verde. Journal of International and Comparative Education, 10(1), 22-38. doi: 10.14425/jice.2021.10.1.22
xvii Bermingham, N., DePalma, R., & Oca, L. (2022). The “Access Paradox” in Bilingual Education in Cabo Verde. Modern Languages Open, 1 ; Bail, J. (2020, September 8). Cape Verde. Humanium. Retrieved April 5, 2023, from: https://www.humanium.org/en/cape-verde/
xxvi Resende-Santos, J. (2021). Education for development in Africa: Rethinking higher education in Cabo Verde. Journal of International and Comparative Education, 10(1), 22-38. doi: 10.14425/jice.2021.10.1.22
xxviii Patrício, M. R., & Moreno, C. (2021). Digital technologies in preschool education: a study with Cape Verdean educators. In Proceedings of the 14th annual International Conference of Education, Research and Innovation (ICERI2021) (pp. 8403-8407). IATED.
xxxi Resende-Santos, J. (2021). Education for development in Africa: Rethinking higher education in Cabo Verde. Journal of International and Comparative Education, 10(1), 22-38. doi: 10.14425/jice.2021.10.1.22 ; Global Partnership for Education. (n.d.). Cabo Verde. Retrieved April 5, 2023, from: https://www.globalpartnership.org/where-we-work/cabo-verde
Cape Verde is a country located 500 kilometers away from the coast of Senegal, Africa. It is an archipelago of ten islands, most of which are inhabited, with most of the population concentrating in the capital Praia. The official language is Portuguese, given that it is a former Portuguese colony that obtained its independence in 1975, many speak Cape-Verdean Creole as their main language. It is a country placed in a challenging geographical setting: its fragmented territory makes the provision of services complicated, it is an area prone to draught and there are few natural resources to benefit from. However, Cape Verde has been praised worldwide for its salient political stability and poverty reduction strategies, which has also enabled improvements in service provision, including that of education.
Children line up in a school in Cape Verde. Photo by Duncan CV in Wikimedia Commons.
The most recent improvements in Cape Verdean education have been made thanks to the 2017-2021 Strategic Education Plan, aiming at accomplishing the 4th SDG of Quality Education, and focused on the following pillars: (i) universal access to pre-primary education for all children aged 4 to 5 years, including those with special needs; (ii) better articulation of pre-primary education with basic education so that all students receive two years of pre-primary education; and (iii) equal access to free universal education up to Grade 8 through the implementation of social action plans for schools, targeting priority groups and providing special education for all.i
Hence, Cape Verde has progressively improved access to primary and secondary education. The schooling rate scored 92.4% in 2021, and the literacy rate reached a 88.5% in 2019, with most over 15-years-old knowing how to read and write.ii Government expenditure on education shifted from 23.3% of the total budget in 2020 to 24.09% in 2021.iii In terms of infrastructure, 97.6% of elementary and secondary schools in Cape Verde have access to water, and 89% are connected to the public electricity grid.The 2017-2021 Strategic Education Plan allowed for the implementation of education enhancement programs such as Education of Excellence, to which some 93.2 million US$ were allocated in 2020; while 6.4 million US$ were allocated to scholarships.iv
The Covid-19 pandemic caused much struggle to the tourism-centered economy of Cape Verde. However, the country was quite timely and effective in managing the crisis and providing vaccination to most of the population.v In the area of education, it also acted promptly. In 2020, Cape Verde received a grant of 750.000$ from the GPE (Global Partnership in Education) which substantially contributed to teacher training in distance teaching, provision of learning material, as well as TV access to remote areas, and sufficient sanitary facilities.vi After the closure of schools, the Ministry of education implemented the “Learning and Studying at Home” program, which enhanced lesson delivery through radio, television and the use of tablets, in view of the fact that 30% to 40% of the families did not have access to such technology. The program also allowed for the extension of the digital television coverage area and improved signal quality.vii Despite all of this, it should be noted that there is currently no evidence of the existence of a comprehensive strategy to adapt to the post-Covid19 context in Cape Verde.
It is worth mentioning that a significant development in Cape Verdean education is the recent ratification of the Convention Against Discrimination in Education by Cape Verde on the 5th of October 2022, which has entered into force on the 5th of January 2023. Although its effective application is yet to be seen, this action alone has fully implemented several recommendations made in the last United Nations Universal Periodic Review session.viii
Despite the previously mentioned developments in the Cape Verdean educational sector, several situations of inequality, discrimination, lack of educational infrastructure and quality education in education have been reported up to this point. These are the problems that the archipelago will need to face and solve in the years to come, and the following sections will outline the main areas that need to be targeted.
Inequalities in Education
Cape Verde currently faces a challenge regarding the hidden costs of education. Although Primary Education and Secondary Education (up to 8th grade) is free and mandatory,ix,there is a range of extra costs, including transportation, meals, or certain school material, that is significant for low-income families. This represents an inequality in access to quality education for poor families.x Moreover, secondary Education and Higher Education (university) remain subject to fees (although authorities have stated the intention to make education free from 9th to 12th grade),xi allowing for inequality based on the economic level of each family. This also intersects with the existing inequality between families who live in rural areas and families that live in urban spaces,xii where the former have less access due to general lower economic capacity, and lack of technology and internet connectivity due to its high cost (especially relevant during Covid-19).xiii
As regards Higher Education, although there have been great efforts to supply it widely, it must be noted that the schooling rate for the 2019-2020 period is of 23.5%, 37 points lower than that of secondary school, indicating an obstacle in its access.xiv One of the difficulties in this area is the geographical setting of Cape Verde; being an archipelago the mission of providing accessible higher education to all areas is deeply complex and has not been achieved. There are only Higher Education institutions in the islands of Santiago and São Vicente.xv This, together with the fact that Higher Education is not free, generates little incentive for students who live in remote areas and possess a low economic level to enter Higher Education.xvi
There is also inequality around language. While for most of the Cape Verdean population the first language is Cape Verdean Language (CVL), Portuguese is still the only official language as well as the schooling language. This continues to produce evident inequalities for students who have limited exposure to Portuguese, namely those who live in rural areas and remote locations, usually from low-income families too. Such students will have a learning disadvantage and increased difficulty when learning. Although some bilingual education programs have been reportedly launched, the implementation of such initiatives is insufficient, weak and lacks political and economic backup. This inequality is also representative of a disconnection between the formal education systems and society; policies directed at filling this gap will inevitably also contribute to identity building and social cohesion.xvii
Finally, despite the political will expressed in the Education Strategic Plan 2017–2021 to improve access and quality of education to disabled students (17,5% of the population have at least 1 handicap),xviii and increased staff capacitation aided by UNICEF,xix it has been reported that practical implementation of inclusive strategies for such students has been deficient. Many disabled people do not attend education and do not receive the necessary benefits in order to do so, and the infrastructures and educational technologies have not adapted to them for the most part.xx
With respect to gender parity, good results have been achieved in preschool and primary education: the parity index scored 0.98 and 0.93 respectively, both cases showing a slightly higher male representation. However, the challenge remains in secondary and higher education levels where female representation is significantly and increasingly higher, the parity index scores 1.2 for secondary education and 1.5 for higher education. Incentives to attract males in those sectors is necessary to ensure equality.xxi And while there is a significantly higher female presence in secondary and higher education, the literacy rate for men in currently almost 10% higher than for women, which displays an access inequality for women too.xxii
Despite significant improvement through the introduction of a gender module in the secondary education curriculum, the curricula reportedly still contain discriminatory stereotypes towards women, which is also reflected in the fact that women are poorly represented in the fields of study typically dominated by men, such as in the technological field.xxiii Moreover, although gender matters are beginning to be present in the curricula, education on sexuality is deficient. It has been acknowledged as important for the development and safety of students by the government, and a Sexual Guidance in Schools guide has been developed with the aid of UNFPA (United Nations Population Fund), but due to limited political will and the sensitivity of the topic, very few students have benefited from such education. A comprehensive module on sexuality education is yet to be implemented effectively.xxiv
It should be noted that the figure regarding minorities based on sexual orientation or gender identification in Cape Verde could not be found; and similarly, no mechanisms of protection of such minorities or education on the matter could be found. Despite it being a potentially sensitive topic that is now invisible to the sector, advances on this area could be positive to ensure that all students are free and enjoy equal treatment by peers and staff.
Deficiencies in Education
Firstly, there need to be improvements not only in the provision of Higher Education but also in the quality of it. Higher Education in Cape Verde is a relatively new sector emerged in the span of the last 20 years. Considering that it is still at its infancy, the sector lacks quality: although the newly formed Higher Education Regulatory Agency (Agência Reguladora do Ensino Superior – ARES) is beginning to conduct evaluations and checks in order to improve performance,xxv the sector still needs to build a comprehensive system of teaching quality evaluation, mechanisms to better align tertiary education content to the national goals and needs, and ensure access to educational material and technologies, as well as connectivity.xxvi
Secondly, although around 76% of children currently have access to preschool education, there are regional differences with areas that display even lower percentages. Early Childhood education and Preschool was formally one of the foci of the 2017-2021 Education Strategic Plan, but in practice it has been largely neglected. There still is a lack of adequate legal mechanisms to ensure universal preschool mandatory and free access, the preschool budget is around 0.3% of the state budget, and there is a lack of professional qualification of preschool teachers (only 30% have the necessary qualification).xxvii Moreover, technological access and tools have been notably missing in preschools, together with a lack of teacher training in ICT.xxviii
Thirdly, one of the most significant problems in Cape Verde’s education sector is the quality of the education, reflected in low performance rates in primary school. In the area of language, 6 out of every 10 children demonstrated great difficulty or inability to interpret the basic rules of functioning of languagexxix, and in the area of mathematics an average of only 2.85% of children were able to successfully deal with the main areas of study.xxx Furthermore, Cape Verde still does not have to this date a comprehensive national system to measure learning outcomes at any level of education.xxxi
Regarding technological access, it should be noted that although most schools are connected to the public electricity grid, and that the 2017-2021 Strategic Education Plan has allowed for the incorporation of more technological tools and a stronger curriculum on ICT skills, only the 17% of schools have access to internet.xxxii This is even though Cabo Verde has one of the highest rates of internet access in Africa. The cost of internet is the problem, as it is among the highest is the world; it is still too high for many to obtain, especially for those with lower income, generating a situation of inequality as well.xxxiii
Conclusion and Recommendations
By way of conclusion, some recommendations highlighting the main challenges of the educational system in Cape Verde will be offered on behalf of Broken Chalk.
As regards the hidden costs of education, the government should try to reduce them by providing free (or low-cost) access to transportation, material, and nutritional services with special attention to low-income families and students who live in remote rural areas which might increase the economic cost of education.
Regarding educational coverage and universal provision, the government should act in accordance with their own stated intentions, and continue to extend free, accessible, and mandatory education to the preschool years and to higher education, with special attention to poor families. More specifically regarding Higher Education, it could be positive to generate incentive campaigns to increase the schooling rate, particularly for males; together with expanding the presence of higher education institutions to all territories or better ensuring affordable access to university from remote places.
It would be desirable to implement comprehensive national programs to overcome the inequality around language. Cabo Verdean Language should be significantly more present in all stages of education; particular attention should be paid to students with lower exposure to Portuguese to ensure they do not fall behind, and bilingual education initiatives should be enhanced through multidisciplinary teams that include local community members that understand the specific language needs of the area.
To promote greater inclusion, the government and educational entities should consider making education infrastructure, curricula, and staff more sensitive and adaptable to disabled or special needs students. Proper access to buildings, inclusive educational material and a comprehensive disability-oriented training module for all educators should be provided to ensure the access and equality of such students.
Also as regards inclusivity and equality, educational programs and policies should continue to ensure girls and women’s access to education at all levels to achieve greater equality in literacy rates, to continue to work towards the elimination of gender stereotypes and to incentivize the presence of women in male dominated study fields. Additionally, it could be positive to implement a comprehensive educational program in secondary school regarding sexuality to guarantee the safety and health of students and to eliminate diversity-damaging stereotypes on the basis of sexual orientation.
An effective way to improve the quality of education could be to implement a comprehensive national system of evaluation and assessment of teaching quality to ensure an adequate provision of content at all educational stages and to identify deficiencies in teaching quality, particularly in the area of language and mathematics in primary school. Together with proper evaluation and analysis of student performance, this could overcome ineffective modes of teaching that result in low performance, allow for educational innovation, and better align curricula to the needs and goals of Cape Verde’s society, better preparing students to face the labor market. Similarly, the government and educational institutions should continue ensuring that all teachers are qualified to provide adequate education to the level they are assigned to. This should be particularly applied to the preschool levels, where most teachers do not have the proper qualification, which could hinder the development of students.
Lastly, in view of recent events and in view of the future global developments, it is essential to ensure greater access to technological tools for educational purposes both for schools and families, as well as facilitating internet access. Again, this seems especially important considering the introduction of technologies in the global labor market, and it is also important to provide flexible and adaptable modes of education, particularly in a country where geographical accessibility to education might be complicated.
xiii Patrício, M. R., & Moreno, C. (2021). Digital technologies in preschool education: a study with Cape Verdean educators. In Proceedings of the 14th annual International Conference of Education, Research and Innovation (ICERI2021) (pp. 8403-8407). IATED. ; Cabo Verde National Commission for UNESCO. (2022). National Review of the Implementation of SDG 4. Retrieved from: https://transformingeducationsummit.sdg4education2030.org/system/files/2022-09/CaboVerde-NC%20report%20.pdf
xv Ferreira, E. S., & Loureiro, S. M. C. (2021). Challenges of a small insular developing state: Cape Verde. Revista de Estudios e Investigación en Psicología y Educación, (1), 125-134.
xvi Resende-Santos, J. (2021). Education for development in Africa: Rethinking higher education in Cabo Verde. Journal of International and Comparative Education, 10(1), 22-38. doi: 10.14425/jice.2021.10.1.22
xvii Bermingham, N., DePalma, R., & Oca, L. (2022). The “Access Paradox” in Bilingual Education in Cabo Verde. Modern Languages Open, 1 ; Bail, J. (2020, September 8). Cape Verde. Humanium. Retrieved April 5, 2023, from: https://www.humanium.org/en/cape-verde/
xxvi Resende-Santos, J. (2021). Education for development in Africa: Rethinking higher education in Cabo Verde. Journal of International and Comparative Education, 10(1), 22-38. doi: 10.14425/jice.2021.10.1.22
xxviii Patrício, M. R., & Moreno, C. (2021). Digital technologies in preschool education: a study with Cape Verdean educators. In Proceedings of the 14th annual International Conference of Education, Research and Innovation (ICERI2021) (pp. 8403-8407). IATED.
xxxi Resende-Santos, J. (2021). Education for development in Africa: Rethinking higher education in Cabo Verde. Journal of International and Comparative Education, 10(1), 22-38. doi: 10.14425/jice.2021.10.1.22 ; Global Partnership for Education. (n.d.). Cabo Verde. Retrieved April 5, 2023, from: https://www.globalpartnership.org/where-we-work/cabo-verde
Located in West Africa, and on the coast of the Atlantic Ocean, The Republic of Benin (French: République du Bénin), gained independence in 1960, from the French rule. Benin, is part of the 15 member states that make up Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS), a Regional Bloc aimed at promoting economic corporation among member states, to raise living standards and promote economic development.
Education System in Benin
Benin education system follows the French education model, which is Six years in primary, four years in Junior High, three years in Senior High and three years in University, which constitutes to the 6-4-3-3 system (UNESCO, 2023). Education in Benin has been free for 17 years. The provision of the constitution under Rights and Duties of the Individual, Article 13, states that primary education shall be obligatory and the government shall progressively offer free education to its schools (Constitution of Benin (COB), 1990).
Problems in Benin Education
Benin strategy to increasing student enrollment by introducing free education at the Primary level, increased the enrollment rate, from a net enrollment rate of 82% in 2005 before free primary education, to 97% in 2018, 12 years after free primary education was introduced (Data World Bank, 2018).
The rapid increase of students at the foundation level of education due to free education, has however, not translated, in the progressive levels of education, of Secondary and University. According to World Bank Data, 54% of Beninese children enrolled in the 1st grade of Primary school eventually reaches the last grade of Primary education. The low number of students progressing to Secondary and University schools has significantly been attributed to child labor, early marriages, early pregnancy and poverty.
Teacher Léandre Benon and student Mariam at the blackboard. Photo by GPE/Chantal Rigaud in Flickr.
The high dropout rates are particularly evident to Benin gender gaps, which have seen more girls drop out than boys. In Benin, gaps between women and men stem from structural social disparities that start earlier in life. According to World Bank, (Nathalie, 2022) the male literacy rate between 15-24 years is about 55 percent while the female literacy rate in the same age group is about 30 percent. Only one in ten girls aged 21-24 have completed secondary school. Moreover, one third of 20–24-year-olds are married by the age of 18, and 15 percent are already mothers at the age of 15-19 (Nathalie, 2022).
Since 2015, Benin has not yet closed the gap. Also, the drop in lower secondary completion rate from 45% in 2015 to 33% and 2020 (UN Sustainable Development Solutions Network, 2022) echoes the need to focus on the pursuit of education and ensure 100% transition from one level of education to the next, in both genders.
These gender gaps have translated to the larger community whereby the gender parity index which measures the steps a country has made towards gender parity in participation and/or educational opportunities for females is low at 0.79% (World Bank, 2022). Young girls in Benin are at risk of not completing education as a result of societal norms automatically decreasing women participation of women in Benin’s formal sector. The Government has increased its efforts in ensuring Girls education is addressed with Benin agreeing to introduce the AU Campaign to End Child Marriage in Africa which is part of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development for Children in Africa (Forwerk, 2017).
Child labor
Children in Benin engage in the worst forms of child labor, including in the production of cotton and crushed granite. Children also perform dangerous tasks in domestic work and street vending. According to International Labor Organization (ILO, 2021), 20% of children under the age of 14yrs, experience child labor.
Children are trafficked mostly within Benin but also to neighboring countries such as Gabon, Nigeria, and the Republic of the Congo, for domestic work and commercial sexual exploitation, and to work in vending, farming, and stone quarrying (ILO, 2021). Children living in the northern regions of Benin are the most vulnerable to trafficking owing to being a rural area. According to the International Labor Organization, a practice locally known as vidomégon (Child placement), where children most girls, are sent to live with other families for domestic work in exchange for educational opportunities, which in most cases, lead to many children becoming victims of labor exploitation and sexual abuse.
In 2013, the Government implemented a nationwide anti-child labor awareness campaign and signed a bi-partite agreement with a Beninese worker association to reduce child labor through increased collaboration (Refworld, 2021). That year, the Government officials handled 62 child trafficking cases and 11 exploitive child labor cases, referred 23 suspects to the court system on child labor and trafficking charges, and provided shelter to 173 victims of trafficking (ILO, 2021). In another effort to end child labor, Benin’s government through its Social Affairs docket, removed 400 children from child labor as a result of Social Services inspection (ILO, 2021).
Lack of official documentation
A 12th grade math class at Collège d’enseignement général of Sô-Ava. Photo by GPE/Chantal Rigaud in Flickr.
The Beninese Government offers free registration to a new born before 10 days, after which, the parent/ guardian incurs a fee of $30 (ILO, 2021). Cultural practices such as naming a baby, takes 10 days after birth, which therefore gives the parents little time to register and obtain a birth certificate. While in other households, 2 in 10 children in Benin, are born at home, giving children little or no hopes in acquiring official documentation (ILO, 2021).
Lack of official documentation in any country, presents a challenge in accessing basic rights such as access to health and education. In Benin, 4 out of 10 children are not registered at birth and do not receive a birth certificate. As a consequence, they are often denied the right to an education and lack access to other essential services, hence leading to an increase in the informal sector and an increase in child labor.
Since January 2012, UNICEF has been involved in the distribution of more than 140,000 birth certificates that were pulled up in civil status registration centers. Through this initiative, children have access to the services they are entitled to such as health and education. According to UNHCR, a National forum on civil registration is aiming to address the hadles that prevent universal access to birth registration in Benin (UNICEF,2012).
Conclusion
Benin is a country with a growing economy, whose efforts such as free primary education, increase of teachers and facilities, have showed a slight increase, there is still the need for the Government to increase its efforts in ensuring 100% transition in all levels of education in both genders, this will increase the literacy rate, and eventually the economic situation to improve the lives of Beninese people.
A few recommendations would be to increase Government spending on the education sector, especially following the Government 5 years plan through its Program Action that began from 2021-2026, which sorts to increase development in various Governments sectors such as; Education challenges, Development challenges, Economic challenges. Also, Government needs to up its efforts in ensuring no child is left behind as a result of lack of identification, child labor and early marriages. The Government and its Education stakeholders need to encourage the communities especially in the rural areas that Education is an asset, and through it, an entire community benefits from new ideas, leaders and increased standards of living. Through this, the literacy rate of Benin, will increase adding to Benin workforce, that mostly depends on Agriculture, can eventually expand to other sectors such as Technology and Professional and business services hence increase Benin’s GDP.
References
Constitution of Benin (1990) Art 13, Compulsory Education
Education plays a pivotal role in shaping the future of individuals and societies. In the case of Eritrea, a country with a complex history and a strong desire for progress, the educational landscape reflects both the challenges inherited from the past and the contemporary issues faced by its education system. By examining the historical context and the current challenges, we gain a comprehensive understanding of the obstacles that Eritrea must overcome to ensure equitable and quality education for its population.
Children waiting to go to class. Photo by Merhawi147
Historical Background
Eritrea’s educational system has evolved over time, deeply influenced by its colonial history and the struggle for independence. Under Italian colonial rule in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, education was limited to a privileged few, primarily aimed at serving the interests of the colonial administration. This approach excluded the majority of Eritreans from accessing quality education, perpetuating inequities.
After World War II, Eritrea came under British administration and later federated with Ethiopia in 1952. During this period, educational opportunities remained limited and largely inaccessible to the broader population. However, the armed struggle for independence led by the Eritrean People’s Liberation Front (EPLF) brought about significant changes. The EPLF established underground schools, known as “ma’htot,” which focused on preserving Eritrean identity, culture, and language. This movement laid the foundation for a more inclusive and culturally relevant education system.
Current Challenges
Inequitable Access to Education
One of the most pressing challenges in Eritrea is inequitable access to education. Geographical factors pose significant barriers, particularly in remote and rural areas. Limited infrastructure and transportation hinder the establishment and maintenance of schools, making it difficult for children to access education. For example, in the Gash Barka region, located in the western part of the country, the lack of schools and the long distances students have to travel to get to school prevent many children from attending classes regularly. Similarly, in the Southern region, children from nomadic communities face difficulties in accessing formal education due to their transient lifestyle and the absence of educational facilities in their migratory routes.
Economic Constraints and Affordability
Economic factors further exacerbate the challenges in the education system. Poverty, particularly prevalent in rural areas, makes it challenging for families to afford school-related expenses such as uniforms, books, and transportation costs. The financial burden restricts access to education, disproportionately affecting vulnerable populations and perpetuating cycles of poverty and inequality. For instance, in the Anseba region, impoverished families struggle to cover essential educational expenses, leading to higher dropout rates among children from low-income backgrounds. Similarly, in urban areas such as Asmara, high living costs make it difficult for families to allocate sufficient resources for education, hindering access to quality schooling.
Gender Disparities
Eritrea faces gender disparities in access to education. Deep-rooted cultural norms and expectations often prioritize boys’ education over girls’, leading to lower enrollment rates for girls. Early marriage and assigned domestic responsibilities limit girls’ educational opportunities. Early marriage is prevalent in some areas, such as the Debub region, and girls are often forced to drop out of school at a young age, hindering their educational advancement. Furthermore, societal perceptions of traditional gender roles contribute to girls’ limited educational and career opportunities, constraining their full potential and undermining efforts to achieve gender equality in education.
The cloister of the Catholic Cathedral in Asmara hosts a large school. Photo by David Stanley.
Quality of Education
The quality of education in Eritrea is a significant concern. Insufficient numbers of qualified teachers, especially in rural areas, contribute to inadequate learning experiences. Teachers’ lack of professional development opportunities further hampers their ability to deliver quality instruction. The absence of essential resources such as textbooks, learning materials, and proper infrastructure also impacts the overall learning environment. In the Maekel region, for example, overcrowded classrooms and a shortage of trained teachers compromise the quality of education and hinder students’ learning outcomes.
Limited Access to Higher Education
Access to higher education is limited in Eritrea. The scarcity of universities and highly competitive admission processes restrict the number of students who can pursue tertiary education. This limitation impedes the development of a skilled workforce and hampers the country’s progress towards a knowledge-based economy. For instance, in the Central region, where the capital city Asmara is located, the few available spots in universities cannot accommodate the growing number of qualified students seeking higher education, leading to a significant gap between the demand and supply of tertiary education opportunities.
Conclusion
The educational challenges in Eritrea are deeply rooted in historical factors and compounded by current issues. Inequitable access, economic constraints, gender disparities, poor quality of education, and limited access to higher education continue to hinder the development and progress of the country’s education system. These challenges require urgent attention and comprehensive solutions. By addressing the underlying causes, investing in infrastructure, promoting gender equality, and improving the quality of education, Eritrea can pave the way for a more inclusive and effective education system that empowers its citizens and supports the country’s long-term development goals.
Human rights are the rights one enjoys simply because they are human. According to the UN Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), there are thirty rights to which all people are entitled, irrespective of their race, color, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth, or other status. Article 26 of the UDHR states that everyone has the right to education and recognizes education as one of the fundamental rights to which all humans are entitled. Education has not only proven to be a pivotal tool for every country’s development but has also served as an indispensable element that facilitates the realization of other human rights (UN, 2001). Botswana, since it gained independence in 1966, has made a commitment to ensuring that all children, regardless of gender, ethnicity, socio-economic background, or circumstances, realize their right to a quality education. While Botswana has made significant strides in its development journey, the country still faces several challenges that need to be addressed in order to improve the quality of education and provide better opportunities for its citizens. This report will explore the educational system, challenges, and recommended solutions to improve Botswana’s educational accessibility, quality, and delivery.
School students celebrating Botswana’s 50th independence day. Photo by Mahyar Sheykhi
Botswana’s Education System.
Botswana has made significant strides in its education system through key reforms implemented over the years. These include the enactment of the Education Act in 1967, followed by the establishment of the National Commission on Education (NCE) in the 1970s. The NCE formulated Botswana’s education philosophy and set development goals. In 1977, the National Policy on Education (NPE) was adopted, emphasizing access and social harmony. The introduction of the National Literacy Policy (NLP) in 1981 addressed adult literacy challenges. The Revised National Policy on Education (RNPE) was adopted in 1994, aligning with international education goals. Vision 2016 was launched in 1996, highlighting education as a pillar for national development. Also, the Education and Training Sector Strategic Plan (ETSSP) was introduced in 2015 to transform education quality. In 2016, Botswana built upon the successes and lessons learned from the previous national development vision, Vision 2016, and formulated Botswana Vision 2036, a long-term development plan with a strong focus on education and skills development. Recognizing that education and skills are crucial for human resource development, the vision prioritizes quality education at all levels and aims to equip citizens with the knowledge and capabilities needed for sustainable socio-economic growth.
Botswana’s school system consists of pre-primary, 7 years of primary school, 3 years of junior secondary, and 2 years of senior secondary education. The various national policies mentioned above have resulted in significant developments in Botswana’s education system. These include a considerable increase in public education funding and enhanced access to educational opportunities. Consequently, literacy rates have experienced notable improvement, enabling more individuals to acquire basic literacy skills. To meet the growing demand for education, additional schools have been constructed, expanding the overall education infrastructure. Furthermore, there has been a substantial increase in student enrollment rates in both primary and secondary schools, reflecting the heightened emphasis placed on education in Botswana.
Botswana’s Educational Challenges and Recommended Solutions
Despite the significant milestones achieved in Botswana’s educational system over the years, the country still faces several challenges.
One of such challenges includes significant socio-economic disparities, particularly in rural areas where high poverty rates prevail. A study by Makwinja (2022) revealed that in Botswana, poverty poses challenges for families sending their children to school, and some children are forced to work as maids, farm hands, or babysitters to support their families instead of attending school. Again, many students attend school without proper uniforms, and the lack of school buses results in long walks to reach educational institutions, with limited access to educational institutions such as books and computers. All this contributes to low literacy rates, leading to inequality in education delivery in Botswana. This clearly infringes on the right of children to education as against Article 29 of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC). While the government provides some support through the social welfare department, more comprehensive and accessible poverty alleviation programs are needed to address this issue effectively. By improving the nutritional quality of meals provided to children and implementing targeted interventions, Botswana can encourage school attendance, reduce dropout rates, and improve overall academic performance.
Also, the education budget in Botswana is disproportionately focused on tertiary education, resulting in limited resources allocated to pre-primary and primary education (Mokibelo, 2022). This imbalance poses a significant challenge to the delivery of quality education, particularly at the early stages of learning. Despite the recognition of the importance of education and skills development in Botswana’s Vision 2036, the budgetary prioritization hinders the necessary investments in pre-primary and primary education, leading to educational inequality and a lack of adequate support for early childhood development (Mokibelo, 2022). According to a UNICEF report in Botswana in 2022, only 43% of children between the ages of 4-5 have access to early learning opportunities, indicating limited participation in early childhood education. Furthermore, approximately one-third of children struggle to acquire basic literacy skills after 4–5 years of primary education. The pass rates in the Primary School examination and Junior Certificate examination are also concerning, with around one-third and two-thirds of children failing, respectively. These issues can be attributed to a lack of proper training and support during the early stages of children’s education. Additionally, there remains a notable proportion of children who are not enrolled in school, further impeding progress towards achieving universal access to education. To uphold the rights of children as stated in the UNCR and address the challenge above, Botswana should prioritize investment in early childhood and primary education to ensure equitable access to education for all children, regardless of their circumstances, and foster an inclusive and fair society. Secondly, provide comprehensive teacher training programs to enhance teaching practices and create child-centered learning environments.
Likewise, Botswana faces poor quality education, as evidenced by low pass rates at the junior and senior secondary levels (Suping, 2022). Currently, the teaching approach in Botswana remains predominantly traditional, with students passively listening to teachers and taking notes (Makwinja, 2022). There is limited emphasis on critical thinking and active student engagement. To address this, teachers and lecturers need to adopt innovative teaching methods that encourage collaboration, group work, and utilize available internet resources. It is crucial for teachers to undergo training to enhance their knowledge, skills, and competencies, aligning with international standards of performance. The focus should shift from test scores to fostering critical and analytical thinking through competence-based approaches. Collaboration among teachers as a community is essential, allowing for immediate support and shared challenges. These measures are crucial for improving educational outcomes and promoting youth development in Botswana.
Furthermore, the education system in Botswana faces the significant challenge of overcrowded classrooms and inadequate infrastructure, especially in rural areas, which hinders the delivery of quality education. The lack of suitable structures, overcrowding, and shortage of classrooms contribute to uneven teacher-student ratios and impede individualized instruction and high-quality learning experiences. In secondary schools, it is not uncommon to find classes with over 40 students, far exceeding the recommended ratio of 1:15 in primary schools. (Mokibelo, 2022). These infrastructure constraints also limit access to technology and educational resources, exacerbating the existing challenges. Resolving these issues by investing in infrastructure 2Wdevelopment and reducing class sizes is crucial to improving the overall quality of education and providing students with the necessary resources for their academic success.
Again, in Botswana, school dropouts are a significant challenge that requires immediate attention. According to survey data, when school was free, although not compulsory, most children were enrolled in primary and junior secondary schools. For instance, it has been reported that approximately 70% of junior secondary school (JSS) leavers progressed to senior secondary school (SSS) during that time, and the dropout rate was relatively low (UNICEF, 2022). While the rest of the JSS leavers progress to Brigades, which offer more vocationally based training. However, the reintroduction of school fees in 2007 has led to inequality in education in Botswana, particularly for families with lower economic means, which has exacerbated dropout rates. To combat school dropout, Botswana needs to improve education quality, provide support for struggling students, and address financial barriers. Collaboration among government, NGOs, and community stakeholders is vital for creating an inclusive learning environment. By implementing comprehensive solutions and targeting specific challenges, Botswana can reduce dropout rates, ensure equal access to education, and empower its youth.
In addition to the above, gender-based challenges, such as early sexual initiation, the risk of HIV infection, and gender-based violence, pose significant obstacles to girls’ education in Botswana (UNICEF, 2022). Adolescent girls and young women face multiple barriers that impede their access to quality education. Consequently, these challenges contribute to high dropout rates among girls, exacerbating gender disparities in the education system. Limited access to sexual and reproductive health services and inadequate support systems further hinder girls’ educational progress. To address these issues, it is essential to implement comprehensive strategies. This includes promoting gender equality, providing comprehensive sexual and reproductive health education, enhancing access to healthcare services, and establishing safe and supportive learning environments. By prioritizing these measures, Botswana can create an inclusive educational system that empowers girls, enables their educational advancement, and fosters gender equality in education.
Similarly, mental health issues, including high suicide rates and poor mental well-being, have a profound impact on educational outcomes in Botswana. The limited availability of mental health services, particularly for adolescents, exacerbates these challenges. The lack of youth-friendly services and inadequate support within schools create significant barriers to learning and student engagement. Recommended solutions to address mental health challenges in Botswana’s education system include increasing access to mental health services, integrating mental health education into the curriculum, creating supportive learning environments, and fostering collaboration with stakeholders for holistic support.
In conclusion, ensuring quality and accessible education for all, regardless of background, is of utmost importance. Education plays a crucial role in promoting socio-economic growth and development. It is, therefore, imperative that policymakers, government officials, NGOs, and advocacy groups collaborate at various levels, including national, regional, district, and grassroots levels, to initiate meaningful and sustainable changes that allow for quality and accessible education for all.
References
Makwinja, V. M. (2017). Rethinking education in Botswana: A need to overhaul the Botswana education system. Journal of International Education Research (JIER), 13(2), 45-58. DOI: https://doi.org/10.19030/jier.v13i2.10075
Makwinja, V. M., & Nthoi, O. N. Finding Solutions for Addressing Poor Performance in the Botswana Education Systems and Lessons Learnt From COVID-19. DOI: https://doi.org/10.22492/issn.2435-9467.2022.6
Mokibelo, E. (2022). Implementing Early Childhood Education in Botswana: Teething Problems. Journal of Emerging Trends in Educational Research and Policy Studies (JETERAPS), 13(2), 41-51.
Suping, K. (2022). Political Spectacle and the Decline of Public Education in Botswana. Journal of Asian and African Studies, 00219096221117077. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/00219096221117077
Over the last few decades, Sierra Leone has faced numerous setbacks. Between 1991 and 2002, Sierra Leone was witness to the devastating Sierra Leone Civil War (Ozisik 2015). 1,270 elementary schools were destroyed and 67% of all school-age students were forced out of school in 2001 as a result (ibid). A decade later, in 2012, Ebola struck Sierra Leone, leading to the closure of schools for at least nine months (Son, 2016). The nation has now stabilized and is trying to realize its potential (O’Neill 2014: 44). However, around 70% of people in Sierra Leone continue to live in poverty. This has led many children to work rather than attend school (ibid). In this context, it does not help that there are supply and space shortages, high student-to-teacher ratios and the lack of qualification and training of teachers. Additionally, an educational environment that disproportionately affects girls due to young pregnancies, child marriage, gender-based violence and cultural biases respectively. This, among other confounding factors, has laid a foundation for serious setbacks in the Sierra Leonean educational system, such as low enrollment rates, poor educational standards, and a gendered education gap. These factors are explored in this article.
The educational system in Sierra Leone has three basic levels: primary, junior secondary and senior secondary (Ozisik 2015). Primary school consists of six years, until the age of twelve, which are free for all. Between the ages of twelve and fifteen students enroll in junior secondary schools (ibid). After that, for children aged between fifteen and eighteen, students enroll in senior secondary schools (ibid). At this level, students choose whether they wish to continue their academic education by proceeding to university or focusing on vocational training instead (ibid). Regarding the first, there are two options available to students in Sierra Leone who want to pursue higher education: Njala University and the University of Sierra Leone (ibid). For vocational education programmes, agriculture is the primary subject of study, followed by skills in mechanics, carpentry, and bricklaying (ibid).
Challenges and their causes
Low attendance rates
First, only about 6% of children attended pre-primary school in 2011, meaning very few children got the foundations for learning and education (O’Neill 2014: 48-50). The primary school enrollment rate is high for males, around 100%, although much lower for females, around 70% (ibid). However, the completion rate for primary school is only about 71% for females and 76% for males (ibid). After primary school enrollment the numbers decrease drastically. Secondary school enrollment is about one-third of that of primary school enrollment (ibid). Even worse, tertiary school enrollment is just a few per cent, with the highest percentage of enrollment being 3% for men and 1% for women (ibid). This incredibly low rate of young people continuing their education demonstrates that education in Sierra Leone is neither a top priority nor an objective that most people value (ibid). This data is from 2001, following the Civil War (ibid).
In Sierra Leone, many children drop out or do not attend school for several reasons. Although many factors influence the low enrollment and high dropout rates in Sierra Leone, such as “living situations (presence of parents), location, gender, religion, cost, teen pregnancy, and early marriage” the article “The Out-of-school Children of Sierra Leone” by UNICEF (2008) argues that the main reason for children not being in school is poverty (Coinco 2008: 4). Due to the pervasive poverty, 87% of Sierra Leonean children decide to work instead of attend school, stating that they would “rather work and get paid than sit in school and be hungry” (ibid). In many cases, children are forced to work rather than attend school (O’Neill 2014: 50). For many families, children are seen as another source of income and are forced into manual labour at a young age (ibid). In line with this, many kids cannot attend school because their families simply cannot afford it (idem: 50-51). Despite the government taking steps to decrease or eliminate costs connected with attending school, many schools still require payment for services (ibid). In fact, 37% of the families who pay for their kids’ education say they struggle to do so (ibid). These two factors demonstrate that many children’s inability to attend school is mostly a result of poverty.
Low-quality education
A “Report on Basic Education in Sierra Leone”, prepared by The Campaign for Good Governance (CGG) (2006), found several factors that threaten the quality of education in Sierra Leone (O’Neill 2014: 45-46). These include supply and space shortages, high teacher-pupil ratios and the lack of qualification and training of teachers (ibid).
The past educational system in Sierra Leone was not prepared for the rapid increase in enrollment of children that would occur after the end of the Civil War (idem: 51). Although this increase was a positive development, it also resulted in supply and space shortages that made class sizes too large and simultaneously created higher pupil to teacher ratios (ibid). Due to the shortage in supplies, it is not uncommon for multiple students to share a single book for instance (Ozisik 2015). Moreover, higher student-to-teacher ratio results in less individualized learning time with the teacher (O’Neill 2014: 52). Spending time with the teacher in-person can frequently be a crucial component of understanding and learning (ibid). Without as much one-on-one time, a student can fall behind or feel lost, which would make it more difficult for them to learn fundamental skills (ibid). Additionally, larger classrooms make it more difficult for the teacher to educate, especially if the students are all at various levels of understanding (ibid).
A high student-to-teacher ratio is made even worse when taken into consideration with the reality that many teachers lack the necessary training (ibid). Since there are so few qualified teachers available, many school systems are forced to hire unqualified instructors (ibid). In fact, more than 40% of primary school teachers are untrained (Ozisik 2015). Untrained teachers might not be delivering the right lessons, they might not know how to manage huge classes of kids, and they might not know how to adapt their teaching methods to fit diverse learning types (O’Neill 2014: 52). There is also a good likelihood that Sierra Leonean native teachers did not finish primary school or go on to intermediate or university education (ibid).
It is simple to understand why Sierra Leonean children decide to take different pathways than that of education when there are so many things working against them, from a lack of resources to the large student-to-teacher ratio and their presumable inexperience (ibid). These kids and their families must put enormous work into keeping children in school for so little in return (ibid).
Children learn and play at the UNICEF-Supported Child Friendly Space at Sierra Leone’s National Stadium. Photo by UNICEF Sierra Leone.
Gendered education gap
The educational environment that disproportionately affects girls is a prevalent and particularly relevant issue that continues to affect education in Sierra Leone. Despite improvements in their access to education, a lack of class completion, high dropout rates, and continually low secondary enrollment persist for girls. The cycle of gender inequity is fueled by young pregnancies, child marriage, gender-based violence and cultural biases.
Sierra Leone is responsible for one of the highest teen pregnancy rates in the world, a phenomenon that is largely responsible for the high incidence of female dropouts (Ozisik 2015). In fact, the country’s education ministry has decidedly prohibited pregnant girls from attending school, under claims that they would be unable to perform well in class (Son 2016). The ministry argued that exposing pregnant girls to classmates would humiliate them and encourage others to become pregnant (ibid).
In Sierra Leone, girls frequently are married as young as age 11, and more than 60% of females nationwide are married before the age of 18 (Ozisik 2015). Early marriage makes it even more difficult for these females to pursue education and independence (ibid).
Furthermore, there is a strong gender disparity brought about by a strong bias that prioritizes male education and subverses that of girls (ibid). The reality is that girls in Sierra Leone are frequently instructed to stay home and take care of household chores while their brothers go to school (ibid). The general challenges articulated so far, namely supply and space shortages, high pupil-to-teacher ratios and the lack of qualification of teachers, have already made it challenging enough for all children to enroll in school (ibid). In an environment that has a dominant preference for boys’ education, the education of girls is made virtually impossible (ibid).
Conclusion
Overall, low enrollment rates, poor educational standards and a gendered education gap remain challenges for children trying to pursue quality education in Sierra Leone. These factors are compounded by problems ranging from poverty, to supply and space shortages, high student-to-teacher ratios and the lack of qualification and training of teachers, as well as young pregnancies, child marriage, gender-based violence and cultural biases.
Reference list
Ozisik, S. (2015). “Education in Sierra Leone”, The Borgen Project, https://borgenproject.org/education-sierra-leone/. Consulted on May 24th, 2023.
Son, P. (2016). “Education in Sierra Leone: Gender Inequality After Ebola”, The Borgen Project, https://borgenproject.org/education-in-sierra-leone-2/#:~:text=According%20to%20Business%20Insider%2C%20only,in%20Sierra%20Leone%27s%20education%20system. Consulted on May 24th, 2023.
O’Neill, R. (2014). Perpetuating a Vicious Cycle: The Causes and Effects of Poorly Educated Children in Sierra Leone. Global Majority E-Journal, 5(1): 44-56.
Coinco, E., Khatete, D. and Obdura, A. (2008). “The Out-of-school Children of Sierra Leone”, UNICEF, http://www.globalpartnership.org/media/library/Final_Out_of_School_Study_Sierra_Leo ne_012009.pdf. Consulted on May 24th, 2023.
UNICEF Sierra Leone (2022). “Education”, www.unicef.org/sierraleone/education. Consulted on May 24th, 2023.
In Afghanistan’s rugged and culturally diverse landscape, education has always been an intricate tapestry woven with threads of resilience, determination, and hope. Despite decades of conflict, political turmoil, and economic instability, the pursuit of knowledge continues to ignite a flame of possibility within the hearts of the Afghan people. However, the path to education in Afghanistan is laden with numerous challenges that pose formidable obstacles to its realization.
In this article, we delve into the profound educational challenges that have plagued Afghanistan, shedding light on the systemic issues that have hindered progress and examining the far-reaching consequences for the country’s future.
By understanding the complexities of the educational landscape, we can uncover the potential solutions and interventions necessary to pave the way towards a brighter future for Afghan students.
The history of education in Afghanistan is a tale deeply intertwined with the country’s rich cultural heritage and the struggles it has endured over the centuries. Education has long been valued as a cornerstone of Afghan society, with early records indicating the existence of educational institutions as far back as the 11th century. Islamic schools, known as madrasas, played a crucial role in teaching religious studies and the Arabic language. During the 20th century, a wave of modernization and reforms sought to establish a formal education system, introducing secular schools and universities.[1] However, decades of conflict, including the Soviet invasion, civil wars, and the Taliban regime, severely disrupted the educational landscape. Schools were destroyed, teachers were displaced, and access to education became limited, particularly for girls.[2]
Educational Challenges
Gender Disparity
As mentioned above, one of the most pressing challenges faced by the education sector in Afghanistan is the pervasive gender disparity. Cultural norms and deep-rooted societal barriers have led to the exclusion of girls from schools, denying them access to the transformative power of education.[3]
During the Taliban regime in Afghanistan, which lasted from 1996 to 2001, access to education for girls was severely restricted and, in many cases, wholly denied. The Taliban implemented a strict interpretation of Islamic law, imposing a series of oppressive policies that targeted girls’ education. Girls were forbidden from attending schools, and educational institutions for girls were systematically shut down or repurposed for other uses. This denial of education deprived girls of their fundamental rights and perpetuated a cycle of illiteracy and limited opportunities for their futures. The Taliban’s restrictive policies affected formal schooling and limited women’s access to vocational training and higher education. The detrimental impact of these restrictions on girls’ education during the Taliban regime underscores the urgent need for ongoing efforts to ensure educational opportunities and gender equality for all Afghan children.[4]
After the fall of the Taliban regime, significant progress has been made in improving education for girls. With the establishment of a new government and the support of international organizations, a concerted effort has been made to promote gender equality and expand access to education. Schools that were previously closed or destroyed have been reopened, and new educational institutions have been established across the country. Numerous initiatives have focused on increasing girls’ enrollment and retention rates, ensuring safe learning environments, and providing resources and infrastructure. In collaboration with NGOs and international partners, the Afghan government has implemented policies to address cultural barriers and discriminatory practices that hinder girls’ education. As a result, millions of girls have gained the opportunity to attend school, pursue higher education, and broaden their horizons. The improved access to education for girls in Afghanistan since the fall of the Taliban regime represents a significant step towards empowering women, enhancing gender equality, and fostering the country’s social and economic development.[5]
However, the current situation for girls in Afghanistan following the Taliban’s takeover is a matter of deep concern and uncertainty. The Taliban’s return to power has raised fears about the potential rollback of hard-won gains in girls’ education. While the Taliban leadership has made statements indicating that they will allow girls to receive an education within the framework of their interpretation of Islamic law, the extent to which this will be upheld remains uncertain. Reports from various regions indicate that girls face barriers to education, with reports of schools being closed or converted to Islamic education centres. Additionally, there are concerns about the safety and security of female students, as the Taliban’s previous regime was notorious for its restrictions on women’s rights and education. The international community, along with local activists and organizations, is closely monitoring the situation and advocating for the protection of girls’ rights to education, which has already been significantly restricted.[6]
Poverty-related issues
Moreover, poverty and limited resources further exacerbate the educational challenges in Afghanistan. Insufficient funding, lack of infrastructure, and inadequate teacher training hinder the quality of education provided. Many schools operate in overcrowded classrooms, lacking basic amenities and learning materials. Additionally, the widespread prevalence of child labour and the need for children to contribute to their families income further impedes their access to education.
Limited access to quality schools and educational resources is a significant hurdle impoverished communities face. Many families struggle to afford necessities, let alone invest in their children’s education. As a result, child labour and early marriage often become alternatives to schooling. Additionally, widespread insecurity and conflict in some areas of the country threaten educational facilities and discourage attendance. These challenges contribute to a high illiteracy rate and perpetuate the cycle of poverty, limiting opportunities for socioeconomic advancement. Addressing the academic challenges related to poverty in Afghanistan requires a comprehensive approach involving targeted interventions, increased investment in education, and the provision of social support to vulnerable communities.[7]
In conclusion, the educational challenges concerning gender disparity and poverty in Afghanistan are deeply intertwined and pose significant obstacles to achieving a more equitable and prosperous society. The intersection of poverty and gender discrimination perpetuates a vicious cycle where girls and women from impoverished backgrounds face multiple barriers to accessing quality education. These challenges not only hinder their personal development but also restrict the overall progress and development of the nation. Efforts to address these challenges require a holistic approach that tackles poverty, gender inequality, and educational barriers simultaneously. By investing in inclusive and accessible education, empowering girls and women, and providing socioeconomic support to marginalized communities, Afghanistan can break the cycle of poverty and gender disparity, fostering a brighter future for all its citizens. Through concerted and sustained efforts, Afghanistan can overcome these challenges and ensure that every child, regardless of gender or socioeconomic background, has an equal opportunity to receive a quality education and fulfil their potential.
Bibliography
Baiza, Y. (2013). Education in Afghanistan: Developments, influences and legacies since 1901. Routledge.
Khwajamir, M. (2016). History and problems of education in Afghanistan. In SHS Web of Conferences (Vol. 26, p. 01124). EDP Sciences.
Mashwani, H. U. (2017). Female education in Afghanistan: Opportunities and challenges. International Journal for Innovative Research in Multidisciplinary Field, 3(11).
Ahmad, S. (2012). THE TALIBAN AND GIRLS EDUCATION IN PAKISTAN AND AFGHANISTAN–with a case study of the situation in the Swat District.
Alvi‐Aziz, H. (2008). A progress report on women’s education in post‐Taliban Afghanistan. International Journal of lifelong education, 27(2), 169-178.
Amiri, R., & Jackson, A. (2021). Taliban attitudes and policies towards education. ODI Centre for the Study of Armed Groups.
Ochilov, A. O., & Najibullah, E. (2021, April). HOW TO REDUCE POVERTY IN AFGHANISTAN. In E-Conference Globe (pp. 114-117)
[1] Khwajamir, M. (2016). History and problems of education in Afghanistan. In SHS Web of Conferences (Vol. 26, p. 01124). EDP Sciences.
[2] Baiza, Y. (2013). Education in Afghanistan: Developments, influences and legacies since 1901. Routledge.
[3] Mashwani, H. U. (2017). Female education in Afghanistan: Opportunities and challenges. International Journal for Innovative Research in Multidisciplinary Field, 3(11).
[4] Ahmad, S. (2012). THE TALIBAN AND GIRLS EDUCATION IN PAKISTAN AND AFGHANISTAN–with a case study of the situation in the Swat District.
[5] Alvi‐Aziz, H. (2008). A progress report on women’s education in post‐Taliban Afghanistan. International Journal of lifelong education, 27(2), 169-178.
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
Cookie
Duration
Description
cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics
11 months
This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional
11 months
The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary
11 months
This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
cookielawinfo-checkbox-others
11 months
This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance
11 months
This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
viewed_cookie_policy
11 months
The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.