UNIVERSAL PERIODIC REVIEW OF MAURITANIA

UNIVERSAL PERIODIC REVIEW OF MAURITANIA

By Jonathan Murphy

Broken Chalk has drafted the following report as a stakeholder contribution to the fourth cycle of the Universal Periodic Review [UPR] for Mauritania. As Broken Chalk focuses on combating human rights violations in education, this report and the following recommendations focus on the Right to Education.

Introduction

 

The following report has been drafted by Broken Chalk as a stakeholder contribution to the fifth cycle of the Universal Periodic Review [UPR] for Mauritania. As Broken Chalk’s focus is to combat human rights violations within the educational sphere, the contents of this report and the following recommendations will focus on the Right to Education

The Islamic Republic of Mauritania is located on the northwest coast of Africa, with a population of 3,364,940 and a literacy rate of 51.2%. While the official spoken language of Mauritania is Arabic, other national languages include Pulaar, Soninke, and Wolof. Additionally, French is widely spoken, particularly among those who have pursued higher education. i

Historically, Mauritania maintained two parallel educational systems: one operating exclusively in Arabic and another bilingual system incorporating both Arabic and French. In 1999, a new curriculum was adopted, making Arabic the primary language of instruction, while French is taught as a foreign language. At the secondary level of education, science and mathematics are taught exclusively in French. ii

Mauritania, like many other African countries, is facing a learning crisis. While education is free and compulsory from the ages of 6 to 14, attendance enforcement is lax. This has led to most children completing only 5 years of education iii.

Primary school education begins at 6 years old and lasts for 6 years. Upon completion, students are awarded a Certificat d’Études Fondamentales. Subsequently, students attend Collège or Lower secondary school, which lasts for 3 years, and attain the Brevet d’Études du Premier Cycle (BEPC). Afterwards, students may choose between Lycée technique (a vocational upper secondary school) or Lycée (a general upper secondary school).iv

Vocational upper secondary school lasts for 3 years, with students targeting a certification of Brevet d’Enseignement Professionnel (BEP). Students who have completed at least 2 years of vocational upper secondary school can enter a further 2-year programme leading to the Brevet de Technicien (BT).v

General upper secondary school is also designed as a 3-year course. Upon completing the programme, students must pass the national examination to obtain the Diplôme du Baccalauréat de l’Enseignement du Secondaire.vi

Admission to university-level programmes in Mauritania remains highly competitive, owing to the restricted number of available places. Admission is based on Baccalauréat exam results, with some programmes requiring an additional entrance exam. After two years of study, students receive a Diplôme d’Études Universitaires Générales (DEUG). Students may opt to continue their studies for an additional two years to earn a Maîtrise certification, which is equivalent to a master’s degree. vii

 

Brief overview of the last UN-UPR cycle

The review of Mauritania was held at the 3rd meeting, on 19 January 2021, resulting in 266 recommendations having been made, with 201 of those recommendations supported by the Mauritanian government. Of those supported recommendations, eight were explicitly aimed at enhancing access to education, while an additional 30 recommendations concerned broader educational objectives.

Broken Chalk notes that all the education recommendations were supported. The Mauritanian government has focused its attention on broadening girls’ access to education, providing safer and more hygienic WASH facilities, and expanding access to students in poverty and those in rural areas.

These developments have been facilitated by Mauritania’s commitment to enacting the recommendations through domestic legislation. The Global Partnership has noted that access to education has improved with the construction of over 390 new, fully equipped classrooms to meet demandviii. Other measures include government policies that have established compulsory and free education for children from the ages of 6 to 15ix. Furthermore, while independent monitoring remains limited, the government has reported progress through initiatives such as expanding rural school access, increasing education funding, and providing conditional cash transfers to encourage girls’ enrolmentx.

 

Learning Poverty within the Mauritanian Education System

Firstly, as in many sub-Saharan countries, learning poverty remains a significant challenge. Learning poverty can be described as the inability to read and understand a simple text by the age of 10 xi. Even when compared to states with similar regional and developmental profiles, Mauritania’s education system struggles to meet expected standards, with test results for 4th-grade students in French alarmingly low. At the same time, Arabic and mathematics also show significant deficiencies xii. In a 2017 report, the World Bank noted that ”only a quarter of grade 6 students scored above 50 per cent on the end-of-primary-school national exam, while only 1.7 per cent of grade 4 students in public schools could read a simple eight-word sentence in French, and about 37 per cent could not add two single-digit numbers” xiii.

These figures are stark given that comparable neighbouring states’ literacy rates are almost 10 times higher than those in Mauritania. Senegal, for example, showed that French proficiency among students of the exact age had attained 15% proficiency in French and 35% according to a 2021 Monitoring Impacts on Learning Outcomes (MILO) study xiv.

The reasons for the ongoing learning poverty in Mauritania are multitudinous. Evidence suggests that a leading factor is the pedological (mis)management of schools. According to the UNESCO report on Mauritanian education, the average attainment level gained by students varied considerably within the same regions from one school to another, even when all other factors, such as gender and poverty, are consideredxv. This suggests an ongoing struggle to set and maintain widely adopted educational standards.

Compounding the lack of a structured pedological framework is the lack of quality teachers. A 2018 assessment of education service delivery in Mauritania found that no teacher met the required competency standards to teach French or Arabic, and only 3.6% of public-school teachers possessed the minimum skills necessary to teach mathematicsxvi. While teacher training programmes have since been implemented to improve the standard of education in the country, there appears to be a startling lack of competency from those in the education sector. Additionally, teacher absenteeism is extraordinarily high. The UNESCO report indicates that almost one-quarter of teachers were absent from schools during unannounced visitsxvii.

The combination of these factors has left the vast majority of Mauritanian students facing overwhelming challenges in their search to secure a quality education. The uncoordinated nature and implementation of the education they receive means that they initially require luck to attend one of the few effective schools in the country. Thereafter, students may face undertrained teachers who lack the required knowledge or skills to ensure proficiency in core subjects effectively.

Widespread Enrolment and Retention Gaps Across All Education Levels

The second major challenge confronting the Mauritanian education system is persistent low enrolment across all age groups, despite notable efforts by the government and its partners to improve access and coverage.

Mauritania has failed to meet its target for preschool enrolment. With current coverage reaching only 9%—well below the 16% target—Mauritania continues to have one of the lowest rates of pre-school enrolment in West and Central Africa xviii. Furthermore, the vast majority of students who attend pre-school education do so through private schools, with only 5% attending those provided by the state. This represents an education equity risk, as students from poorer backgrounds or less populous areas are unlikely to benefit from these institutions.

This is a significant challenge as disparities in educational outcomes emerge early in childhood. Once these gaps are in place, they tend to limit a child’s chances of upward mobility. Early differences in learning and development often shape key aspects of a child’s experience, such as their relationships with teachers and peers, the type of curriculum they are enrolled in, and the support they receive at home. Over time, these factors reinforce initial disadvantages, making them more challenging to overcome. As such, early childhood represents a critical period for addressing long-term educational inequality xix.

Likewise, despite commendable efforts by the Mauritanian government, primary school enrolments have failed to meet targets. Although the Gross Enrolment Rate in primary education has exceeded 100 per cent over the past decade, the Net Enrolment Rate for children aged 6 to 11 has remained below 75 per cent, significantly lower than the averages for both Sub-Saharan Africa and the Arab states xx.

The gap between gross and net enrolment suggests that many children in Mauritania either start school late, repeat grades, or drop out early. Although primary education is officially free and compulsory, this guarantee is not effectively upheld. As of 2019, an estimated 210,000 children aged 6 to 11 were not enrolled in any form of schooling, representing almost 40% of the age group. Among those who do enrol, only 68% complete primary education, and fewer than half do so without repeating a year. Dropout rates are particularly concentrated between Grades 4 and 6, reflecting structural inefficiencies and weak retention. These trends are exacerbated by the fact that only 40% of the country’s 3,500 schools allow students to complete the full cycle of basic education, limiting access in remote or under-resourced areas xxi.

Enrolment in secondary education in Mauritania remains extremely limited. According to the 2024 Education Sector Analysis, the gross enrolment rate (GER) in lower secondary education stands at just under 50%, while the GER in upper secondary education is only 30% xxii. These figures reflect a steep drop-off after the completion of primary school, with the transition to secondary education described in the report as a “bottleneck.” Only 63% of students who complete basic education proceed to lower secondary school, and even fewer advance to upper secondary education xxiii. Structural limitations—including insufficient school capacity, geographic barriers, and resource constraints—contribute to widespread exclusion from the upper levels of the education system. Despite small annual increases in enrolment, progress remains too slow to achieve universal secondary access.

Mauritania lags significantly behind its regional peers in tertiary education, with a gross enrolment rate of just 5.8%, among the lowest in West and Central Africa xxiv. In 2019, the gross enrolment rate for higher education was estimated at 5.8%, compared to an average of over 30% across Sub-Saharan Africa xxv. University admission is primarily restricted to students who pass the Diplôme du Baccalauréat; yet, the proportion of students achieving this qualification remains critically low. The system’s limited intake capacity and weak secondary completion rates mean that only a small elite can access higher education. While the government has committed to expanding tertiary institutions and diversifying programme offerings, access remains highly restricted, and enrolment growth has not kept pace with rising demand. Without a significant investment in secondary school completion and university preparation, higher education will remain inaccessible to the vast majority of Mauritanian youth.

Disruption of Education Due to Climate Shocks

Finally, the ongoing climate crisis has already begun to affect the education system in Mauritania critically. This is particularly true of rural and marginalised communities who are facing growing food insecurity due to droughts, floods, and other destabilising elements brought about by climate change. Between 1993 and 2022, Mauritania was ranked among the twenty countries most affected by climate-related disasters worldwide, when adjusted for its level of human development. The country faces increasingly severe environmental shocks as the climate crisis worsens. These events are especially disruptive for rural and marginalised communities, where weak infrastructure, food insecurity, and displacement already limit access to education. The frequency and intensity of these climate impacts have increased significantly in recent years, placing additional strain on schools, families, and public services that lack the capacity or resources to respond effectively xxvi.

Climate-related shocks increasingly disrupt Mauritania’s education system. According to UNESCO’s 2024 Education Sector Analysis, prolonged droughts, flash floods, and advancing desertification particularly affect rural wilayas—Guidimakha, Gorgol, Assaba, Hodh El Chargui, and Hodh El Gharbi—where educational indicators such as enrollment, retention, and completion are already significantly below national norms xxvii. These same regions, repeatedly hit by food insecurity and seasonal displacement, experience acute climate vulnerability that undermines schooling.

Despite the scale of these risks, the education sector in Mauritania lacks a clear strategy for climate adaptation. There is currently no national framework in place to ensure continuity of schooling during climate-related emergencies, nor is there formal guidance for schools or teachers on how to respond to disruptions caused by floods, droughts, or displacement xxviii. According to the 2024 Education Sector Analysis, data on climate-related school closures, infrastructure damage, or student displacement are not systematically collected or incorporated into national education planningxxix. This absence of climate-responsive policy leaves schools in high-risk areas without the support or tools needed to protect learners’ right to education during and after environmental shocks. Repeated cycles of disruption deepen exclusion for children already marginalised by geography, poverty, or gender, as confirmed in recent UNICEF emergency reporting xxx.

The Consequences of this policy gap are increasingly visible. When flooding damages schools or drought drives seasonal displacement, children often miss weeks or months of class. This phenomenon is particularly prevalent for students in poor and rural areas. Many children are unable to return. Climate shocks also intensify existing gendered risks: during crises, girls are more likely to be withdrawn from school to support household labour or are pushed into early marriage, both of which are particularly prevalent in Mauritania. xxxi. The absence of school continuity measures, catch-up programming, or flexible enrollment policies means that these disruptions frequently become permanent. In a system already marked by high dropout and low retention rates, climate-driven shocks are exacerbating exclusion for those least able to recover from interrupted schooling.

The failure to address these foreseeable risks reflects a broader gap in the state’s responsibility to protect the right to education. Under international law—including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights, and the Convention on the Rights of the Child—Mauritania is obligated to ensure continuous and equitable access to education, even in the face of climate-related shocks xxxii. As these environmental threats become more frequent and more severe, the urgency to build climate resilience into education planning cannot be overstated. This includes anticipating disruption, protecting displaced learners, and maintaining access through appropriate institutional and infrastructural responses. Without such measures, the right to education for many of Mauritania’s most vulnerable children remains unrealised.

Recommendations

In light of the persistent and emerging challenges described above, Broken Chalk offers the following recommendations to strengthen the realisation of the right to education in Mauritania.

  1. Broken Chalk urges the Government of Mauritania to develop and enforce national minimum standards for pedagogical practice, learning assessment, and curriculum delivery to ensure a coherent and equitable education experience across schools.
  2. Broken Chalk recommends increased investment in evidence-based teacher training programmes, with particular emphasis on subject-matter proficiency in Arabic, French, and mathematics.
  3. Broken Chalk encourages the establishment of an independent, transparent system to monitor teacher attendance and classroom performance, with remedial support provided where deficiencies are identified.
  4. Broken Chalk urges the Government of Mauritania to accelerate efforts to meet preschool enrolment targets by expanding public early childhood education, especially in rural and low-income areas.
  5. Broken Chalk recommends targeted interventions to reduce dropout rates between Grades 4 and 6, including school feeding programmes, family incentives, and expanded WASH facilities.
  6. Broken Chalk encourages the state to expand the number of schools offering complete primary cycles, particularly in underserved regions, to reduce structural barriers to completion.
  7. Broken Chalk recommends the expansion of secondary school infrastructure and the provision of transportation subsidies for students in remote areas to improve transition and retention.
  8. Broken Chalk recommends that the Government of Mauritania expand higher education opportunities by diversifying programme offerings, increasing institutional capacity, and investing in preparatory support for secondary students.
  9. Broken Chalk encourages the creation of targeted scholarship schemes and university bridging programmes to support access for students from marginalised communities.
  10. Broken Chalk urges the Government of Mauritania to develop and implement a national strategy for climate-resilient education, including infrastructure standards, school continuity plans, and teacher training in emergency response.
  11. Broken Chalk recommends the systematic collection of data on climate-related school closures, damage, and displacement, and its integration into education sector planning and emergency preparedness.
  12. Broken Chalk urges the Government to establish mobile or flexible education models to ensure continuity of learning for children affected by seasonal displacement, drought, or flooding.
  13. Broken Chalk recommends expanding school-based support services for girls at risk of early marriage or pregnancy during climate crises, including re-entry pathways and catch-up programmes.

 

References

References
i AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
ii AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
iii AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
iv AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
v AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
vi AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
vii AACRAO. “Mauritania.” EDGE: Electronic Database for Global Education.
https://www.aacrao.org/edge/country/mauritania.
viii GPE Secretariat and World Bank, “Mauritania: Improving Primary Education and School Management | Global
Partnership for Education,” Global Partnership for Education, 2025, https://www.globalpartnership.org/blog/mauritaniaimproving-primary-education-and-school-management.
ix UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
x
Islamic Republic of Mauritania, National Report Submitted in Accordance with Paragraph 5 of the Annex to Human Rights
Council Resolution 16/21: Mauritania, A/HRC/WG.6/37/MRT/1 (Geneva: United Nations Human Rights Council, 2021),
https://documents-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/GEN/G20/361/26/PDF/G2036126.pdf.
xi World Bank Group, “What Is Learning Poverty?“ Oclc.org, April 28, 2021, https://www-worldbank-org.vunl.idm.oclc.org/en/topic/education/brief/what-is-learning-poverty.
xii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xiii World Bank Group, Mauritania Country Economic Memorandum: Accelerating Growth through Diversification and
Productive Cities (Washington, DC: World Bank, 2020),
https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/652481590432527403/pdf/Mauritania-Country-Economic-MemorandumAccelerating-Growth-Through-Diversification-and-Productive-Cities.pdf.
xiv UNESCO Global Education Monitoring Report Team, “Spotlight on Basic Education Completion and Foundational Learning
in Senegal: Spotlight Advocacy Brief ,” UNESCO IIEP (UNESCO.org, 2023), https://www.unesco.org/gemreport/sites/default/files/medias/fichiers/2023/05/Spotlight_Advocacy_Senegal_EN.pdf.
xv UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xvi GPE Secretariat and World Bank, “Mauritania: Improving Primary Education and School Management | Global
Partnership for Education,” Global Partnership for Education, 2025, https://www.globalpartnership.org/blog/mauritaniaimproving-primary-education-and-school-management.
xvii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xviii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xix Arya Ansari, “The Persistence of Preschool Effects from Early Childhood through Adolescence.,” Journal of Educational
Psychology 110, no. 7 (October 2018): 952–73, https://doi.org/10.1037/edu0000255.
xx World Bank Group, “MAURITANIA Country Economic Memorandum: Accelerating Growth through Diversification and
Productive Cities,” Worldbank.org, 2020,
https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/652481590432527403/pdf/Mauritania-Country-Economic-MemorandumAccelerating-Growth-Through-Diversification-and-Productive-Cities.pdf.
xxi UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xxii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xxiii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xxiv Wachira Kigotho , “Small Island States Lead the Way in Tertiary Enrolments,” University World News, February 4, 2021,
https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=20210203120517283.
xxv Wachira Kigotho , “Small Island States Lead the Way in Tertiary Enrolments,” University World News, February 4, 2021,
https://www.universityworldnews.com/post.php?story=20210203120517283.
xxvi Lina Adil et al., “Climate Risk Index 2025” (GermanWatch, February 12, 2025).
xxvii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xxviii UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xxix UNESCO, “Analysis of Mauritania’s Education Sector,” UNESCO IIEP, 27 November 2024,
https://www.iiep.unesco.org/en/articles/analysis-mauritanias-education-sector.
xxx UNICEF, “Mauritania Consolidated Emergency Report 2021,” UNICEF, March 22, 2022,
https://open.unicef.org/sites/transparency/files/2022-04/Mauritania%20CER%202021.pdf.
xxxi UNICEF EDUCATION, “Reimagine Education Case Study,” Unicef, December 23, 2021,
https://www.unicef.org/media/113696/file/Mauritania%E2%80%99s%20first%20digital%20learning%20program:%20Akeliu
s%20Digital%20French%20Course%20(Mauritania).pdf.
xxxii Olivia Gratton and Fiona Chiu, “How Climate Change Is Affecting the Right to Education,” Australian Institute of
International Affairs, June 27, 2022, https://www.internationalaffairs.org.au/australianoutlook/how-climate-change-isaffecting-the-right-to-educat

 

 

Turkish authoritarianism continues to flout international law

Turkish authoritarianism continues to flout international law

The arrest of Orhan Artar, an internationally protected asylum seeker, highlights the growing trend of international repression practiced by Turkish leaders.

 

President Erdoğan has constructed a sophisticated apparatus of repression, reaching from domestic institutions to international arenas. This machinery has been activated at several pivotal moments: the Gezi Park protests, which revealed deep public discontent; the 2013 corruption probes, which threatened Erdoğan’s inner circle and were linked to Gülenist-aligned prosecutors; and the failed 2016 coup, widely seen by the government as the culmination of Gülenist infiltration. While Ankara blames the Gülen movement for the attempted coup, international observers have consistently dismissed this claim as politically motivated and unsubstantiated. Once allies, the movement and the ruling party are now fierce adversaries; the former has been designated a terrorist organisation by the Turkish state. Its alleged members have faced sweeping purges, arbitrary arrests, and extraterritorial targeting. The recent illegal deportation of Orhan Artar and his three children from Rwanda to Turkey illustrates the reach of this repression. Upon return, Mr. Artar was detained on suspicion of Gülenist ties, while his children were reportedly placed with relatives.

Who is Orhan Artar?

Orhan Artar is a father, husband, and educator.

In the aftermath of the 2016 coup attempt attributed to the Gülen movement, Turkish pressure prompted Pakistani officials to order the expulsion of 108 Turkish families. Among those affected was Orhan Artar, who, at the time, worked within a network of schools in Pakistan linked to the movement—an affiliation that drew official scrutiny. In response, the Artar family briefly went into hiding before registering for asylum with the UNHCR in Islamabad in 2017. This application was accepted which meant that: Orhan and his family could not be legally returned to a country where their safety and liberty would be threatened.

Despite the official protection offered, the family continued to feel unsafe in Pakistan as compatriots who had received similar legal protections were repatriated to Turkey. In 2018, Mr. Artar was charged in absentia in Turkey with an arrest warrant issued. The family sought refuge in Kenya where they remained until 2023. Here, the family parted ways as Mr. Artar did not have a valid passport; his wife and child went to claim asylum in Germany while he planned to meet them with the other three children later. Further complicating the issue, Mr. Artar’s wife eventually had her asylum claim rejected in May 2024. In spite of these difficulties, Mr. Artar planned to meet his wife and child in Germany, via Rwanda, this month. After travelling through Tanzania, Mr. Artar planned to fly to Belgium before finally reuniting with his family. Instead, Mr. Artar and his children were forcibly detained by Rwandan officials and forcibly deported to Turkey – where he currently awaits trial.

International Law

Seeking asylum is an inalienable human right protected under customary international law, human rights law, and treaty law. The principle of non-refoulement, which prohibits returning individuals to a country where they face persecution, is enshrined in international law through the 1951 Refugee Convention. Both Rwanda and Turkey are signatories to the Convention meaning that both Mr. Artar and his family should enjoy these protections. In deporting the Artar family, Rwanda is in contravention of international law. Furthermore, if Turkey’s actions result in persecution or torture, it too risks breaching its obligations under both refugee and human rights law.

Turkish Repression

Transnational repression has become a systematic weapon wielded against Turkish dissidents based abroad. The Artar case is far from unique: over 100 Turkish nationals based abroad have been forcibly returned since 2016. Turkish authorities level diplomatic demands of repatriation of citizens abroad, with varying degrees of success. For example, while Sweden has steadfastly refused to comply with these demands, other states have proven much more open to accede. Pakistan, Rwanda, and Kenya have facilitated the repatriation orders in violation of international law.

Extrajudicial kidnappings are another tool of the Turkish National Intelligence Organisation (MIT). Freedom House has reported that security forces brazenly carried out such an operation in Azerbaijan against Turkish businessman Uğur Demirok. Tajikistan has seen similar disappearances of at least two Turkish citizens who have since reappeared in Turkish prisons.

Broken Chalk

Broken Chalk stands with the international community in decrying the rise in transnational authoritarianism coming from Turkey. Orhan Artar is a symptom of the growing disdain exhibited by states towards international law. To stem the erosion of the international legal system, supranational organisations, states, and other stakeholders must address the rising tide of authoritarianism. Below are our demands to address the ongoing situation:

  1. Broken Chalk calls for the immediate release of Orhan Artar following his illegal repatriation and arbitrary detention.
    His continued imprisonment contravenes international refugee protections and the principle of non-refoulement. Turkey must release Mr. Artar and drop all charges linked to peaceful association or political affiliation.
  2. We call for an independent international investigation into the actions of both Rwandan and Turkish authorities.
    This investigation should examine the circumstances of Mr. Artar’s detention and deportation, the legality of Rwanda’s cooperation with Turkish demands, and any breaches of international human rights and refugee law.
  3. We urge the UNHCR and relevant UN Special Rapporteurs to publicly condemn this violation of international law.
    The UN Special Rapporteur on torture and the Special Rapporteur on the human rights of migrants should formally request information from both governments and raise the case before the Human Rights Council.
  4. We demand EU Member States suspend deportations to Turkey of individuals affiliated with the Gülen movement.
    Until credible safeguards are in place to prevent arbitrary detention or torture, no individual should be returned to Turkey where they face a real risk of persecution.
  5. We emphasise the binding obligation which states have undertaken to uphold their non-refoulement obligations and resist diplomatic pressure to return Turkish dissidents.
    The use of asylum law must remain rooted in principle, not politics. Countries must resist bilateral pressure and prioritise international legal standards over appeasement.
  6. We condemn the continued inaction of the international community to establish stronger safeguards to prevent transnational repression.
    This includes creating accountability mechanisms for states that collaborate in cross-border targeting of dissidents, especially where asylum seekers and refugees are involved.