The Role of NGOs in Improving Access to Education in Pakistan 

Written by Mahnoor Ali

Pakistan’s education system has long faced numerous challenges that have hampered the country’s socioeconomic development. In Pakistan, all children aged 5 to 16 have the right to a 12-year school education.1 However, despite various government initiatives such as the ‘Education Emergency’ plan2 and ‘Punjab Education Sector Plan3’, Pakistan continues to face low literacy rates, gender disparities, and inadequate educational infrastructure. Against this backdrop, non-governmental organisations (NGOs) have emerged as critical players in the effort to improve educational access and quality throughout the country. This article examines the current state of Pakistan’s education system, the contributions of key NGOs, and potential strategies for increasing their impact. 

Current Situation of the Education System in Pakistan 

The education system of Pakistan consists of approximately 260,903 institutions serving approximately 41 million students, with an estimated 1.5 million teachers. The system is predominantly public, with the government running 69% of institutions. Despite these figures, the literacy rate has remained stable at approximately 62.3% as of 2023, with urban areas having a higher rate (74%) than rural areas (54%). The Pakistan Education Statistics for 2021-22 highlighted a lack of funds, a low pupil-teacher ratio, and a lack of basic facilities.4 

Furthermore, Pakistan has alarmingly high dropout rates, particularly at the primary and secondary levels. Several socioeconomic factors, such as poverty, child labour, and cultural norms, contribute to the high dropout rate. The number of out-of-school children is approximately around 26.21 million which basically means that 39% of children in Pakistan are out of school. Moreover, outdated curricula, insufficient teacher training, and a lack of learning resources frequently jeopardise the educational quality. These difficulties are exacerbated by political unrest and inconsistent policy implementation. 

The Role of NGOs in Improving Educational Access 

In response to these educational challenges, many non-governmental organisations (NGOs) have stepped in to fill the gaps left by the government. They are at the forefront of implementing impactful programs that seek to uplift impoverished communities.5 These organisations work tirelessly to provide quality education, particularly in underserved communities. Their efforts include school construction, scholarship funding, teacher training, and the development of innovative learning programs. There are numerous NGOs in Pakistan which are working for the betterment of education in Pakistan, some of them are mentioned below: 

One of the leading NGOs is The Citizens Foundation (TCF). TCF6 is a non-governmental organisation (NGO) in Pakistan’s education sector which was founded in 1995. Since then, the organisation has established a vast network of 1,921 school units throughout Pakistan, educating approximately 286,000 students. TCF schools provide high-quality education at a low cost, ensuring that low-income children have access to education. This places TCF as one of the largest privately owned networks of low-cost formal schools in the country. The organisation also emphasises gender equality, with nearly half of its students being female. Its comprehensive approach includes community mobilisation and parental involvement, both of which are critical for long-term educational gains. 

Another prominent NGO is the Developments in Literacy (DIL)7 organization. The organisation was established in 2000 and has been providing low-cost, high-quality education to underprivileged children in Pakistan. The organization’s mission is to educate and empower underprivileged students, particularly girls, through student-centered model schools and high-quality professional development for teachers and principals. DIL’s vision is for every child in Pakistan to have equal access to a quality education, regardless of socioeconomic status. Moreover, the organisation currently educates over 61,000 students in 191 schools throughout Pakistan, and many of its graduate’s work in fields such as medicine, engineering, and public service. 

Zindagi Trust8 is another NGO in Pakistan dedicated to improving education by transforming government schools. The trust also works to improve school infrastructure, create safe learning environments, and provide necessary facilities. Moreover, it has transformed under-resourced Karachi schools into model institutions, such as the SMB Fatima Jinnah Government School and the Khatoon-e-Pakistan Government Girls School, which have significantly improved their infrastructure and academic quality. In addition to these initiatives, Zindagi Trust runs comprehensive educational programs like Life-Skills Based Education (LSBE), which provides students with the necessary skills to protect themselves from abuse and health problems. The trust also provides a variety of extracurricular activities, such as art, music, and sports, to promote holistic growth. 

Challenges and the Way Forward 

Despite the significant contributions made by non-governmental organisations, many challenges remain. Scalability is one of the most significant issues. While NGOs working in Pakistan have achieved remarkable success, their reach remains limited in comparison to the large number of children who are still not in school. Scaling up these initiatives necessitates significant financial investment, logistical planning, and collaboration between the government and the private sector. 

Another challenge is of sustainability. Many NGOs projects are heavily reliant on donor funding, which can be unpredictable. Long-term sustainability necessitates the development of self-sustaining models, such as community ownership of schools and revenue-generating activities that support educational initiatives. Furthermore, there is a need for improved coordination among all stakeholders. The government, NGOs, and private sector must collaborate to create a cohesive strategy. 

Conclusion 

The contribution of non-governmental organisations to improving educational access in Pakistan cannot be overstated. Organisations such as the Citizens Foundation, Developments in Literacy, and Zindagi Trust, among others, have made commendable efforts to provide quality education to the country’s most vulnerable populations. However, achieving universal education requires a concerted effort by all stakeholders. This includes expanding on successful models, ensuring sustainability, and encouraging collaboration. By addressing these challenges, Pakistan can get closer to its goal of providing quality education to all, paving the way for a better future. 

To conclude, the journey to educational reform in Pakistan is undoubtedly complex and difficult, but with the continued efforts of NGOs and a collective commitment from all sectors of society, it is attainable. Pakistan’s future depends on its children’s education, and every effort must be made to ensure that no child falls behind. 

References 

  • Abbasi, K. (2024, January 23). Govt turns its back on education sector. DAWN.COM. https://www.dawn.com/news/1807937 
  • Ahmad, H., Fatima, N., & Nazeer, A. (2023). ROLE OF NGO’S IN PAKISTAN. International Journal of Social Sciences Bulletin, 1(1). https://ijssb.org/index.php/IJSSB/article/view/13 
  • Education Program – The Citizens Foundation (TCF). (2022, October 12). The Citizens Foundation (TCF). https://www.tcf.org.pk/education-programme/ 
  • Government of the Pubjab. (n.d.). Punjab Education Sector Plan. https://schools.punjab.gov.pk/system/files/Punjab%20Education%20Sector%20Plan%20(2019-20%20to%202023-24).pdf 
  • Halai, A., & Durrani, N. (2021). School education system in Pakistan. In Global education systems (pp. 665–693). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-15-0032-9_17 
  • Ministry of federal education and professional training. (n.d.). Malala Fund welcomes Pakistan’s new plan to address its national education crisis [Press release]. https://www.mofept.gov.pk/NewsDetail/MWNmNTA3ZTYtYTU3ZS00NDA0LWIwOTQtMTZiZjNhNjlmMzJj 
  • Our impact — developments in literacy. (n.d.). Developments in Literacy. https://www.dil.org/our-impact/index 
  • School reform | Revamping learning | Zindagi Trust – Non-Profit Organization. (n.d.). https://www.zindagitrust.org/school-reform 
  • Image source: “Girls in school in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan” via Flickr

The University of Peshawar Faces Indefinite Strikes as Staff Seek Fulfilment of Demands

Written by Ibrahim Zulfiqar

PESHAWAR: 10th April 2023. It has been more than a month since The University of Peshawar (UoP) closed its gates indefinitely in a conundrum of protests from multiple stakeholders. The decision to close the institute came as a result of all the faculty and professors going out on strike following the tragic killing of security supervisor, Saqlain Bangash, by a security guard. The students have also resorted to the streets demanding the reopening of the college.

The decision for a complete boycott was made during a meeting of the Joint Action Committee, in collaboration with the Peshawar University Teachers Association (PUTA) after the killing of the security supervisor. PUTA believes that the tragic incident is an eye-opener to the negligent security personnel employed by the institute, they demand a thorough investigation into the training and employment process of these personnel along with another 16 demands.

In response to the protest, University of Peshawar Vice-Chancellor, Dr. Mohammad Idrees, issued a detailed statement claiming that the administration had already accepted almost all the demands, and there was no justification for the protest. However, the protesting employees have dismissed his claims as baseless and are determined to continue the strike.

While speaking to a student union head, Muhammad Asfandyar, we learned that the ground realities were much different and nuanced in contrast to what was being reported. Asfandyar revealed an inquiry that had taken place which concluded the tragic incident as actually an accident. The continued strike by the staff is not for the peace and wellbeing of academicians but ‘to score leverage over the vice chancellor for sinister demands such as increased salaries’ he added. Perhaps the most alarming among these revelations was that PUTA was also given a green signal by the sitting governor of the interim government, Ghulam Ali, to continue striking which he would use as political pressure to remove the vice chancellor and appoint a new one of mutual choice, resulting in everyone’s demands being met. However, since the current government is an interim one, the governor soon realized that his powers were limited, and efforts made to remove the Vice Chancellor were in vain. Orphaned from their political backing, PUTA has no choice but to continue striking and hoping the Vice Chancellor could somehow be removed otherwise it would be their jobs and reputation in question if the university opens any time soon.

Amidst all this politicization of a tragic death for personal gains, the students are suffering. It is their fundamental right to education that is hindered as a consequence. Muhammad mentioned that in the last decade, the campus had closed 9 times before this. The student union is united under the opinion that, [considering the fragile conditions of the province], ‘the blatant denial of education is a form of educational, economic, and social terrorism, which in no form is acceptable’.

It is rather egregious to use a tragic death for vested interests, but it is considerably worse to continue living in the university’s houses allocated for the staff and getting full salaries at the expense of the most important stakeholders, the students, suffering. We hope that the institute can reopen soon, and the student’s education may resume.

The writer Ibrahim Zulfiqar was born and raised in Peshawar

Educational challenges in Pakistan

Written by Sara Ahmed

 

Introduction

Education lays the foundation for political, social and economic development of any country.[1] As a developing country, Pakistan has faced many critical problems when it comes to education and has one of the world’s highest numbers of out-of-school children (OOSC). There are various factors responsible for the educational situation in Pakistan. This article explores some of the challenges that Pakistan faces when it comes to the educational sector.

The Pakistani educational system

The Pakistani educational system exists of public schools, private schools and madrassas. Madrassas are working as Islamic Seminaries; they are imparting Islamic education at graduation level and are often found in more rural areas of Pakistan. These different institutions all have different mediums of teaching, curricula, and also examination systems. This is a barrier in the countries education sector, because it has become a dividing force between the privileged and underprivileged people in the society, leading to economic disparity.[2]

Across all levels of education, the public sector remains the main provider for educational services in Pakistan. Except for the pre-primary level, total enrollment in public schools is almost double compared to private schools.[3] The majority of public schools in Pakistan are primary schools; only 20% are middle and secondary schools. Limited and uneven school access is one of the most daunting challenges for augmenting school enrollment and completion.

Image 1

As can be seen from Image 1, The United Nations Development Program mentioned that in 2020, 64% of the Pakistani youth lived in urban areas and 26% in rural areas. 70% of the Pakistani youth was literate, while 30% was illiterate in 2020. Furthermore, 39% of the youth was employed, while the majority (61%) was unemployed and only 4% looking for a job. Another issue is the access to internet. Only 15% of the youth had access to internet in 2020, while 85% did not. 48% of the youth did not even have a mobile phone. The latter was a huge issue during the COVID-19 Pandemic in Pakistan.

 

Another important issue is that of gender disparity. Throughout Pakistan’s educational system, there is a gender disparity between males and females. According to the 2016 Global Gender Gap Report, Pakistan was ranked the second worst country in the world regarding gender inequality.[4] This is of most concern in more rural areas where access to education for girls is limited.

Out-of-school children (OOSC) and literacy rates

Another major problem that Pakistan faces is that it has one of the world highest numbers of OOSC. Estimated is that 22.8 million children between the age of 5-16 are not attending school; representing 44 per cent of the total population in this age group.[5] The disparities based on gender, socio-economic status and geography are significant. In Sindh for example, 52 per cent of the poorest children (of which 58 per cent are girls) are out of school. The figures are even higher in Balochistan, where 78 per cent of girls are out of school.[6]

Image 2.

On image 2, one can see the different stages of education; the number of children enrolled in the type of education and the number of out-of-school children in that stage.

The socio-economic disparities in Pakistan do not only exist between rural an urban regions, but also between the different provinces in Pakistan. This has an impact on educational outcomes, including gaps in access to education and overall education attainment. A good example is the literacy rate in Pakistan. In the bigger cities, such as Lahore and Islamabad and Karachi, the literacy rates are almost 75%. On the other hand, we have the tribal regions in Balochistan (Pakistan’s poorest and largest province) where the literacy rates can be as low as 9%.[7]

Quality of education

According to a report of UNESCO, the quality of educational institutions and teachers in Pakistan is very low. In remote parts of Pakistan, the availability of teachers is drastically lower.[8] There are also a lot of so called ‘ghost teachers’ that sap public payrolls by not showing up for work. While most of these problems are worse at the elementary level, where most of Pakistan’s students are enrolled, they have ripple effects for the entire education system and depress enrollment rates at all levels.

Furthermore, teachers are often not provided with the necessary equipment’s and training for the knowledge and skills. The main reason is the poor management, lack of finding and improper training standards. In addition to this, the curriculum is often outdated, resulting in a major lack of professional development.

Most students in Pakistan attend public schools. Public schools often do not contribute to a positive learning environment. The classrooms tend to be overcrowded, the electricity and air conditioning is not always working, insufficient use of playgrounds and libraries and most schools do not have commuting systems in place, which exacerbated female drop-out rates. Long home- to-school distances and poor transportation and communication facilities are among the important causes of dropout at the primary level in Pakistan. Poor children, especially girls who are not allowed to travel long distances alone, suffer the most as commuting costs and time increase.

In an interview with TCM Originals, Tariq Banury (a Pakistani educationist, professor and economist), opens up about the current struggles of the Pakistani educational system. He explains that a lot of students, after finishing their degree, do not have the basic skills they should possess. He blames the process in which professors are hired and the outdated curriculum. He continues to explain that professors and curriculum should not stand still, but should evolve with time and science available.[9]

Another major issue is the government’s annual spending on the educational field. Most of the United Nation’s agencies recommend countries to spend a minimum expenditure of 4% on education. Pakistan had only spent 1,77% of GDP on education in 2021-2022. In recent years, the highest percentage of GDP Pakistan has spent on education was in 2017-18, when education expenditures were raised to 2.12%. The usual argument given for lack of spending on education has always been and still is that Pakistan does not have the resources to increase the level of spending on the educational field.[10]

The effects of the COVID-19 Pandemic

The COVID-19 Pandemic also had its effect on Pakistan and its educational system. Because of COVID-19, Pakistan had to consider using online classes. However, many students, especially in rural areas, do not and did not have access to the Internet. Students who are on the lower ladder of the economical circle and students who live in rural areas had been greatly disadvantaged by this new learning method. Many students did not have access to a laptop or even internet. This has greatly impacted the lives of many students in Pakistan, who therefore could not access their education online.[11] This has also resulted in high drop-out rates across the various levels of education in Pakistan.[12]

Low-income families have been the hardest hit by the pandemic. High rates of poverty have put more burden on adolescent girls to stay at home to reduce schooling costs. Coupled with household chores and early marriage, many may never return to the classrooms.[13]  Pakistan was already struggling with high illiteracy rates, the Pandemic has made this situation even worse and has affected the learning of approximately 40 million students across Pakistan.[14]

Conclusion

Pakistan’s educational system has improved over the years, but still tends to rely too heavily on outdated teaching and examination methods. While great strides have been made in improving literacy and participation rates, the education system remains largely elitist with access to the best educational opportunities available only to the more affluent or well-connected students. Furthermore, the COVID-19 Pandemic has had a great impact on the lives of many students who could not access education at the time and increased the drop-out rates across all educational levels in Pakistan. Additionally, Pakistan does not spend the suggested minimum amount of 4% of GDP on education, the percentage is not even half of the suggested amount by the United Nations Bodies. Pakistan does have the intention to increase its annually spending on the educational field. Is this a feasible goal? Only time can tell. In the meantime, many students will still struggle to access the educational system of Pakistan.

 

 

References

 

[1] Iqbal Ahmad et al, ‘Critical analysis of the problems of education in Pakistan: possible solutions’, IJERE (3:2) June 2014, p 79.

[2] Robert Hunter, World Education Services: Education in Pakistan (2020), >https://wenr.wes.org/2020/02/education-in-pakistan< accessed on 5 March 2023.

[3] ADB Briefs, ‘Access Challenges to Education in Pakistan’ (2022), NO. 27, <https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/publication/771091/adb-brief-207-access-challenges-education-pakistan.pdf< accessed on 6 March 2023.

[4] World Economic Forum, ‘Global Gender Gap Report 2016’ (2016) p 22.

[5] Unicef, ‘Education: giving every child the right to education’, <https://www.unicef.org/pakistan/education> accessed on 6 March 2023.

[6] Idem.

[7] Robert Hunter, World Education Services: Education in Pakistan (2020), >https://wenr.wes.org/2020/02/education-in-pakistan< accessed on 5 March 2023.

[8] Unicef, ‘Education: giving every child the right to education’, <https://www.unicef.org/pakistan/education> accessed on 6 March 2023.

[9] TCM Orginals, ‘Does Pakistan’s Higher Education System Need Reform? Educationist Tariq Banuri’ (2021), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPkv9hEIUJw.

[10] Sahiba Abid, ‘Education in Pakistan: problems, challenges and perspectives (2022) >https://www.pakistangulfeconomist.com/2022/08/29/education-in-pakistan-problems-challenges-and-perspectives/< accessed on 3 March 2023.

[11] Adnan Muhammad “Online learning amid the COVID-19 pandemic: Students perspectives” (2020) Journal of Pedagogical Sociology and Psychology. 1 (2): 45–51.

[12] Rabea Malik, ‘The Impact of COVID-19 on education in Pakistan’ (2020), https://www.cambridge.org/partnership/research/challenges-and-opportunities-pakistan-education-systems-covid-19-response.

[13] Anooshay Abid, ‘How has COVID impacted Pakistans’s education system?’ (2021), https://www.dw.com/en/how-has-covid-impacted-pakistans-education-system/a-59264829.

[14] Idem.